Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Judge Orders Drugmaker to Pay $572 Million in Opioid Lawsuit
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
August 27, 2019

Share

NORMAN, Okla. — An Oklahoma judge on Monday found Johnson & Johnson and its subsidiaries helped fuel the state’s opioid crisis and ordered the consumer products giant to pay $572 million, more than twice the amount another drug manufacturer agreed to pay in a settlement.

“The opioid crisis has ravaged the state of Oklahoma. It must be abated immediately.” — Cleveland County District Judge Thad Balkman
Cleveland County District Judge Thad Balkman’s ruling followed the first state opioid case to make it to trial and could help shape negotiations over roughly 1,500 similar lawsuits filed by state, local and tribal governments consolidated before a federal judge in Ohio.
“The opioid crisis has ravaged the state of Oklahoma,” Balkman said before announcing the judgment. “It must be abated immediately.”
An attorney for the companies said they plan to appeal the ruling to the Oklahoma Supreme Court.
Before Oklahoma’s trial began May 28, the state reached settlements with two other defendant groups — a $270 million deal with OxyContin-maker Purdue Pharma and an $85 million settlement with Israeli-owned Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd.
Oklahoma argued the companies and their subsidiaries created a public nuisance by launching an aggressive and misleading marketing campaign that overstated how effective the drugs were for treating chronic pain and understated the risk of addiction. Oklahoma Attorney General Mike Hunter says opioid overdoses killed 4,653 people in the state from 2007 to 2017.

Oklahoma Pursued the Case Under the State’s Public Nuisance Statute

Hunter called Johnson & Johnson a “kingpin” company that was motivated by greed. He specifically pointed to two former Johnson & Johnson subsidiaries, Noramco and Tasmanian Alkaloids, which produced much of the raw opium used by other manufacturers to produce the drugs.
On Monday, Hunter said the Oklahoma case could provide a “road map” for other states to follow in holding drugmakers responsible for the opioid crisis.
“That’s the message to other states: We did it in Oklahoma. You can do it elsewhere,” Hunter said. “Johnson & Johnson will finally be held accountable for thousands of deaths and addictions caused by their activities.”
Among those seated in the courtroom on Monday were Craig and Gail Box, whose son Austin was a 22-year-old standout linebacker for the Oklahoma Sooners when he died of a prescription drug overdose in 2011.
One of the attorneys for the state, Reggie Whitten, said he also lost a son to opioid abuse.
“I feel like my boy is looking down,” Whitten said after the judge’s ruling, his voice cracking with emotion.
Oklahoma pursued the case under the state’s public nuisance statute and presented the judge with a plan to abate the crisis that would cost between $12.6 billion for 20 years and $17.5 billion over 30 years. Attorneys for Johnson & Johnson have said that estimate is wildly inflated. The judge’s award would cover the costs of one year of the state’s abatement plan, funding things like opioid use prevention and addiction treatment.

Sympathy for Those Who Suffer From Substance Abuse

Attorneys for the company have maintained they were part of a lawful and heavily regulated industry subject to strict federal oversight, including the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency and the Food and Drug Administration, during every step of the supply chain. Lawyers for the company said the judgment was a misapplication of public nuisance law.

“You can’t sue your way out of the opioid abuse crisis. Litigation is not the answer.” — Sabrina Strong, an attorney for Johnson & Johnson and its subsidiaries
Sabrina Strong, an attorney for Johnson & Johnson and its subsidiaries, said the companies have sympathy for those who suffer from substance abuse but called the judge’s decision “flawed.”
“You can’t sue your way out of the opioid abuse crisis,” Strong said. “Litigation is not the answer.”
Attorneys for the plaintiffs in the cases consolidated before a federal judge in Ohio called the Oklahoma judgment “a milestone amid the mounting evidence against the opioid pharmaceutical industry.”
“While public nuisance laws differ in every state, this decision is a critical step forward for the more than 2,000 cities, counties, and towns we represent in the consolidation of federal opioid cases,” they said in a statement.
Also on Monday, the Kentucky Supreme Court declined to review an earlier ruling , making previously secret testimony from former Purdue Pharma President Rickard Sackler and other documents public. The court record was sealed in 2015 as part of a $24 million settlement between Purdue and Kentucky.
The 17 million pages of documents were being shipped Monday from Frankfort to Pike County, where the case originated. The Pike County Circuit Court Clerk’s office could not immediately say how and when they would be available.

DON'T MISS

AIPAC Unleashes a Record $14.5 Million Bid to Defeat a Critic of Israel

DON'T MISS

From the Outhouse: 400-Meter Runner Goes From Locked in a Porta-Potty to the Olympics

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Rejects Appeal From Ex-Reality Star Josh Duggar

DON'T MISS

Fresno Investigation into Police Chief Balderrama Is Finished: Sources

DON'T MISS

Here’s What’s at Stake for Biden and Trump in This Week’s Presidential Debate

DON'T MISS

Stock Market Today: Most of Wall Street Rallies, Even as Nvidia Drags

DON'T MISS

California Gov. Gavin Newsom to Deliver State of the State Address on Tuesday

DON'T MISS

Russia Summons the American Ambassador Over a Deadly Attack That Moscow Says Used US-Made Missiles

DON'T MISS

Who Are the Winners and Losers in California’s Budget Deal?

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Rejects COVID-19 Vaccine Appeals from Nonprofit Founded by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

UP NEXT

Supreme Court Rejects COVID-19 Vaccine Appeals from Nonprofit Founded by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Will Target Dangerous Drivers on Saturday

UP NEXT

Still Need Your Landline? California Just Stopped AT&T from Pulling the Plug

UP NEXT

Newly Named Washington Post Editor Decides Not to Take Job After Backlash, Will Stay in Britain

UP NEXT

FDA OKs First Menthol E-Cigarettes, Citing Potential to Help Adult Smokers

UP NEXT

FBI Raids Several California Homes, Including Oakland Mayor’s

UP NEXT

Donald Sutherland, Iconic Actor of ‘M.A.S.H.’ and ‘Hunger Games,’ Dies at 88

UP NEXT

The Supreme Court Upholds a Tax on Foreign Income Over a Challenge Backed by Business Interests

UP NEXT

Mike Pence’s Foundation Launches a $10 Million Election-Year Campaign to Preserve Trump-Era Tax Cuts

UP NEXT

Biden Overtakes Trump in Fox News Poll Following Trump’s Conviction

Fresno Investigation into Police Chief Balderrama Is Finished: Sources

2 hours ago

Here’s What’s at Stake for Biden and Trump in This Week’s Presidential Debate

2 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Most of Wall Street Rallies, Even as Nvidia Drags

2 hours ago

California Gov. Gavin Newsom to Deliver State of the State Address on Tuesday

2 hours ago

Russia Summons the American Ambassador Over a Deadly Attack That Moscow Says Used US-Made Missiles

2 hours ago

Who Are the Winners and Losers in California’s Budget Deal?

2 hours ago

Supreme Court Rejects COVID-19 Vaccine Appeals from Nonprofit Founded by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

2 hours ago

Things to Know About the Gender-Affirming Care Case as the Supreme Court Prepares to Weigh In

2 hours ago

Netanyahu Says He Won’t Agree to a Deal That Ends the War in Gaza, Testing the Latest Truce Proposal

3 hours ago

Funny Car Legend John Force, 75, Alert After Fiery Crash in Virginia

4 hours ago

AIPAC Unleashes a Record $14.5 Million Bid to Defeat a Critic of Israel

Pro-Israel political groups have transformed a Democratic primary on the outskirts of New York City, overwhelming the race with record-shatt...

21 mins ago

21 mins ago

AIPAC Unleashes a Record $14.5 Million Bid to Defeat a Critic of Israel

1 hour ago

From the Outhouse: 400-Meter Runner Goes From Locked in a Porta-Potty to the Olympics

2 hours ago

Supreme Court Rejects Appeal From Ex-Reality Star Josh Duggar

2 hours ago

Fresno Investigation into Police Chief Balderrama Is Finished: Sources

2 hours ago

Here’s What’s at Stake for Biden and Trump in This Week’s Presidential Debate

2 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Most of Wall Street Rallies, Even as Nvidia Drags

2 hours ago

California Gov. Gavin Newsom to Deliver State of the State Address on Tuesday

2 hours ago

Russia Summons the American Ambassador Over a Deadly Attack That Moscow Says Used US-Made Missiles

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend