Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Kavanaugh-Ford Hearing: A Dramatic Lesson on Gender Roles
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 6 years ago on
September 28, 2018

Share

NEW YORK — He let his anger flare repeatedly, interrupted his questioners and cried several times during his opening statement. She strived to remain calm and polite, despite her nervousness, and mostly held back her tears.

“Imagine a woman openly weeping like this on a national stage and still getting elected to the Supreme Court. Or any office.” — Joanna Robinson, a senior writer with Vanity Fair
Throughout their riveting, nationally televised testimony on Thursday, Christine Blasey Ford and Brett Kavanaugh served as Exhibits A and B for a tutorial on gender roles and stereotypes. Amid the deluge of reaction on social media, one prominent observation: Ford, as a woman, would have been judged as a far weaker witness had she behaved as Kavanaugh did.
“Imagine a woman openly weeping like this on a national stage and still getting elected to the Supreme Court. Or any office,” tweeted Joanna Robinson, a senior writer with Vanity Fair.
Kavanaugh, nominated to fill a vacant seat on the U.S. Supreme Court, mixed tears with fury in his statement forcefully denying Ford’s allegation that he sexually assaulted her in 1982 when they were both in high school. He choked up at several points when referring to how his family has been affected by the tempest surrounding allegations by Ford and other women.
Opponents of Kavanaugh’s nomination said his behavior demonstrated a lack of judicial temperament. Some supporters said they were moved to tears when he broke down.
Later, during questioning by some of the Senate Judiciary Committee’s Democratic members, Kavanaugh aggressively interrupted his interrogators and even asked sharp questions of his own.
“Have you ever drank so much you didn’t remember what happened?” asked Sen. Amy Klobuchar, a Minnesota Democrat. “Have you?” countered Kavanaugh. He later apologized.

Ford Sought to Present Herself as Cooperative and Respectful

Ford, in contrast, sought to present herself as cooperative and respectful, expressing her wish that “we could collaborate in a way that could get at more information.”

“When women express strong emotions, we judge them to be emotional — or, in the extreme, ‘hysterical.’ When men express strong emotions, we infer that they must be facing extreme situations.”Zoe Chance, a marketing professor at Yale School of Management
“I’m used to being collegial,” she said at one point.At another, she said when asked about her emotional state: “I think that’s a great question.”
Zoe Chance, a marketing professor at Yale School of Management, said that in terms of winning over public opinion, Ford and Kavanaugh “are both doing the right thing.” She cited research indicating that men could seem more influential and competent through shows of anger, and women less so.
“When women express strong emotions, we judge them to be emotional — or, in the extreme, ‘hysterical,'” Chance said in an email. “When men express strong emotions, we infer that they must be facing extreme situations.”
However, Chance was unsure that Kavanaugh’s anger was effective in this case.
“In this particular situation, the emotional display casts doubt on his ability to be dispassionate and objective as a judge,” Chance suggested. “If we value the ability to separate emotion from facts, then Ford has behaved more judge-like than Kavanaugh has. ”

Communications Professor Analyzes Kavanaugh

Kathleen Hall Jamieson, communications professor and director of the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania, said some of Kavanaugh’s statements “were more consistent with one’s expectations of a partisan than a judge or prospective associate justice of the Supreme Court.”

“It is unusual to see a middle aged professional — male or female — experience the range of emotions in public in a formal setting expressed by Judge Kavanaugh.” — Kathleen Hall Jamieson, communications professor and director of the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania
“It is unusual to see a middle aged professional — male or female — experience the range of emotions in public in a formal setting expressed by Judge Kavanaugh,” Jamieson said in an email. “We expect judges to sound and seem dispassionate.”
Michael Cunningham, a psychology professor at the University of Louisville, said he found Ford’s body language and tone of voice to be persuasive.
“Her generally calm and soft-spoken, yet firm, voice seemed consistent with the feminine sex-role,” he said. “At the end, I believe she retained her credibility.”
As for Kavanaugh, Cunningham said the nominee “was successful in conveying the emotions of a man who has convinced himself that he has done nothing wrong.” But the professor had doubts about the impact of Kavanaugh’s show of emotions.
“Judge Kavanaugh tearing up when mentioning his daughter conveyed a man who was feeling sorry for himself,” Cunningham said. “Society wants men to be sympathetic, and even tearful at times, but not for themselves.”

Social-Media Directed at Kavanaugh’s Emotional Displays

Glenn Sacks, a commentator who writes often about men’s issues, expressed dismay at social-media derision being directed at Kavanaugh due to his emotional displays.
“The mocking of his demeanor is indicative of the restraints still upon men — no weakness allowed, suck it up or get laughed at,” Sacks said in an email. “Men are taught this at an early age — when women cry, we sympathize. When a man cries, it’s so unseemly we can barely stand to look at it.”
Jo Langford, a Seattle-based therapist who works with men and boys who have committed sexual offenses, said he was struck by the contrast between Kavanaugh’s anger and Ford’s “stable and straightforward cadence.” He concluded that Ford may have fared better in the court of public opinion.
Among those closely following the hearing was Danielle Campoamor, a New York-based writer and editor who says she was sexually assaulted by a co-worker five years ago.
Ford “was calm in a way every sexual assault victim is asked to be, lest they be written off as ‘unhinged’ and ’emotional’ and, as a result, no longer credible,” Campoamor said. “Kavanaugh, by contrast, was unapologetically angry. … He embodied the anger so many sexual assault victims fear; the anger that keeps so many of us from coming forward.”

DON'T MISS

Woman Accusing Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of Sexual Assault Acknowledges Inconsistencies

DON'T MISS

Ukrainian Drones Strike Russia as Kyiv Reels From Consecutive Massive Air Attacks

DON'T MISS

South Korea’s Parliament Votes to Impeach President Yoon Suk Yeol Over His Martial Law Order

DON'T MISS

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

DON'T MISS

YouTube TV Is Hiking Its Monthly Price, Again. Here’s What to Know

DON'T MISS

City, County of Fresno Reach Tax Agreement. Can Building Move Forward?

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Release Video of Gun Battle That Killed Gang Member, Injured Sergeant

DON'T MISS

Fresno Trustees Inch Closer to Hiring a New Superintendent

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Will Take Up a Challenge Related to Tough CA Vehicle Emissions Standards

DON'T MISS

Why CA Needs to Double-Down on Its Apprenticeship Programs

UP NEXT

Kennedy’s Lawyer Has Asked the FDA to Revoke Approval of the Polio Vaccine

UP NEXT

Fresno Sheriff’s Office Hunts for Two Sex Offenders. Can You Help?

UP NEXT

House Voting on $895B Defense Bill With Military Pay Raise, Ban on Transgender Care for Minors

UP NEXT

Supreme Court Allows Investors’ Class Action to Proceed Against Microchip Company Nvidia

UP NEXT

Palm Springs Police Chief Defends Parade Decision After Cop’s Motorcycle Crash Injures 12

UP NEXT

Suspect in the Killing of UnitedHealthcare’s CEO Charged With Weapons, Forgery and and Other Counts

UP NEXT

JD Vance, Elon Musk and the Future of America

UP NEXT

$197M Winning Lottery Ticket Bought in L.A. Must Be Postmarked Today or Forfeited

UP NEXT

US Announces Nearly $1 Billion More in Longer-Term Weapons Support for Ukraine

UP NEXT

FBI Offers $50,000 Reward in Hunt for UnitedHealthcare CEO’s Killer

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

4 hours ago

YouTube TV Is Hiking Its Monthly Price, Again. Here’s What to Know

7 hours ago

City, County of Fresno Reach Tax Agreement. Can Building Move Forward?

17 hours ago

Fresno Police Release Video of Gun Battle That Killed Gang Member, Injured Sergeant

19 hours ago

Fresno Trustees Inch Closer to Hiring a New Superintendent

20 hours ago

Supreme Court Will Take Up a Challenge Related to Tough CA Vehicle Emissions Standards

21 hours ago

Why CA Needs to Double-Down on Its Apprenticeship Programs

22 hours ago

Fresno Council Changes Rules on Presidency, Vice Presidency

22 hours ago

De’Vondre Campbell Won’t Be With 49ers After Refusing to Play: Shanahan

22 hours ago

Country Star Morgan Wallen Sentenced in Chair-Throwing Case

22 hours ago

Woman Accusing Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of Sexual Assault Acknowledges Inconsistencies

A woman who accused rappers Jay-Z and Sean “Diddy” Combs of sexually assaulting her when she was 13 at an awards show after-part...

54 minutes ago

54 minutes ago

Woman Accusing Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of Sexual Assault Acknowledges Inconsistencies

2 hours ago

Ukrainian Drones Strike Russia as Kyiv Reels From Consecutive Massive Air Attacks

2 hours ago

South Korea’s Parliament Votes to Impeach President Yoon Suk Yeol Over His Martial Law Order

This undated photo provided by UnitedHealth Group shows UnitedHealthcare chief executive officer Brian Thompson. (AP/UnitedHealth Group via AP)
4 hours ago

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

7 hours ago

YouTube TV Is Hiking Its Monthly Price, Again. Here’s What to Know

17 hours ago

City, County of Fresno Reach Tax Agreement. Can Building Move Forward?

19 hours ago

Fresno Police Release Video of Gun Battle That Killed Gang Member, Injured Sergeant

20 hours ago

Fresno Trustees Inch Closer to Hiring a New Superintendent

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend