Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Court to Decide on Transgender Ballot Measure Wording
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 2 weeks ago on
April 19, 2024

A proposed ballot measure in California that would require school staff to notify parents if their child asks to change gender identification at school is battling the attorney general in court Friday. (AP File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A group backing a proposed ballot measure in California that would require school staff to notify parents if their child asks to change gender identification at schools is battling the attorney general in court Friday, arguing he released misleading information about the proposal to the public.

The group is suing Attorney General Rob Bonta, a Democrat, in Sacramento Superior Court. They want the measure’s title to be changed from the “Restrict Rights of Transgender Youth” initiative to the “Protect Kids of California Act” and update what they say is a biased summary of the proposal.

“It’s an abuse of the attorney general’s power to oversee these ballot measures where he’s legally obligated to be neutral and draft a title and summary that’s impartial,” said Dean McGee, a lawyer with the Liberty Justice Center, which is representing proponents of the measure.

Ban on Transgender Athletes in School Sports

The initiative would also ban transgender girls in grades 7 through college from participating in girls’ and women’s sports, along with barring gender-affirming surgeries for minors, with some exceptions.

It is part of a nationwide debate over local school districts and the rights of parents and LGBTQ+ students. States across the country have sought to impose bans on gender-affirming care, bar trans athletes from girls and women’s sports, and require schools to “out” trans and nonbinary students to their parents. Some lawmakers in other states have introduced bills in their legislatures with broad language requiring that parents be notified of any changes to their child’s emotional health or well-being.

Ballot Measure Gaining Signatures

The proposed ballot measure in California has so far received at least a quarter of the more than 500,000 signatures it needs by May 28 to end up on the ballot in November, according to the secretary of state’s office. But backers of the measure say the title and summary Bonta released for the proposal are hindering their ability to garner enough support before time runs out. They want the secretary of state to extend their deadline by 180 days.

They want to remove language released by Bonta’s office that says the initiative would bar gender-affirming care for transgender youth “even if parents consent or treatment is medically recommended” and require schools to notify parents of their child’s request to be treated as a gender different from school records “without exception for student safety.” They also want the summary to say the measure would define “male” and “female.”

Bonta’s office did not respond to emails seeking comment Thursday on the lawsuit.

California citizens can place initiatives on the ballot if they gather enough supporting signatures, but the attorney general is typically responsible for writing the title and summary language that appears before voters. California judges can step in if they rule the attorney general is not using impartial language. In recent years, California judges have ordered the state to correct misleading information about proposals to repeal a gas tax and raise taxes on business properties.

Ballot measure summary language released by the attorney general can have a “huge impact” on how people vote, said Bob Stern, former president of the Center for Governmental Studies.

“For some people, that’s the only time that they’ll see any information about the measure — is when they go in to vote,” Stern said.

Stern believes the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office, not the attorney general, should release ballot measure summaries, because attorney generals are elected officials who often have a future in politics. Bonta, for example, is expected to run for governor in 2026.

Bonta is currently fighting a Southern California school district in court over a policy that, in part, required school staff to notify parents if their child asked to change their gender identification at school. Bonta said the policy discriminated against gender non-conforming students. The district, Chino Valley Unified, updated the rule last month to remove mention of gender identification changes. The updated rule is more broad, requiring school staff to notify parents if a child requests any changes to their “official or unofficial records.”

Kathie Moehlig, head of San Diego-based nonprofit TransFamily Support Services, said the proposed ballot measure and similar proposals at the school district level have left children she works with scared that “their very being is going to be legislated out of existence.”

“Schools don’t have an agenda to make kids trans. Schools have an agenda to keep all students safe.” Moehlig said. “The unfortunate truth is that there are some kids who are in homes where sharing about their gender identity or sexual orientation would make them unsafe.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

How to Reclaim the Israel-Palestine Debate From the Radicals on Both Sides

DON'T MISS

US Airstrike Targeting Al-Qaida Leader in Syria Killed a Farmer, American Military Says

DON'T MISS

Today’s Campus Protests Aren’t Nearly as Big or Violent as Those of the Vietnam Era

DON'T MISS

Mike Yaz Homers at Fenway In Giants Win After Visit From His Hall of Fame Grandpa

DON'T MISS

Lagging Revenue Drives California Budget Deficit as Deadline Nears

DON'T MISS

Valley Children’s Gets ‘Historic’ Gift to Boost Cancer Treatments. How Big Is It?

DON'T MISS

Californians Are Protecting Themselves from Wildfire. Why Is There an Insurance Crisis?

DON'T MISS

Family Fun, Community Events Highlight Cinco de Mayo Weekend in Fresno

DON'T MISS

Magical ‘Aladdin’ Delivers Magic Carpet Ride and Dad-Joke Humor

DON'T MISS

Over 2,000 Arrested in US Campus Pro-Palestinian Protests

UP NEXT

Today’s Campus Protests Aren’t Nearly as Big or Violent as Those of the Vietnam Era

UP NEXT

Valley Children’s Gets ‘Historic’ Gift to Boost Cancer Treatments. How Big Is It?

UP NEXT

Californians Are Protecting Themselves from Wildfire. Why Is There an Insurance Crisis?

UP NEXT

Family Fun, Community Events Highlight Cinco de Mayo Weekend in Fresno

UP NEXT

Magical ‘Aladdin’ Delivers Magic Carpet Ride and Dad-Joke Humor

UP NEXT

Over 2,000 Arrested in US Campus Pro-Palestinian Protests

UP NEXT

Another State Department Official Resigns Over Biden’s Gaza Policy

UP NEXT

These Two Fresno Pacific Students Faced Challenges. They’ll Graduate on Saturday.

UP NEXT

Biden Expands Two National Monuments in California Significant to Tribal Nations

UP NEXT

Boxer Ryan Garcia Denies Using Performance-Enhancing Drugs After Beating Devin Haney

Mike Yaz Homers at Fenway In Giants Win After Visit From His Hall of Fame Grandpa

47 mins ago

Lagging Revenue Drives California Budget Deficit as Deadline Nears

1 hour ago

Valley Children’s Gets ‘Historic’ Gift to Boost Cancer Treatments. How Big Is It?

Californians Are Protecting Themselves from Wildfire. Why Is There an Insurance Crisis?

2 hours ago

Family Fun, Community Events Highlight Cinco de Mayo Weekend in Fresno

2 hours ago

Magical ‘Aladdin’ Delivers Magic Carpet Ride and Dad-Joke Humor

3 hours ago

Over 2,000 Arrested in US Campus Pro-Palestinian Protests

3 hours ago

Another State Department Official Resigns Over Biden’s Gaza Policy

3 hours ago

These Two Fresno Pacific Students Faced Challenges. They’ll Graduate on Saturday.

Local Education /

5 hours ago

Crawford Goes 7 Innings, Wong Has 3 Hits, and Red Sox Beat Giants

5 hours ago

How to Reclaim the Israel-Palestine Debate From the Radicals on Both Sides

In a recent article for VOX, Zack Beauchamp sheds light on the flawed discourse surrounding the Israel-Palestine debate, particularly on col...

12 mins ago

12 mins ago

How to Reclaim the Israel-Palestine Debate From the Radicals on Both Sides

20 mins ago

US Airstrike Targeting Al-Qaida Leader in Syria Killed a Farmer, American Military Says

33 mins ago

Today’s Campus Protests Aren’t Nearly as Big or Violent as Those of the Vietnam Era

Photo of Mike Yastrzemski
47 mins ago

Mike Yaz Homers at Fenway In Giants Win After Visit From His Hall of Fame Grandpa

1 hour ago

Lagging Revenue Drives California Budget Deficit as Deadline Nears

Valley Children’s Gets ‘Historic’ Gift to Boost Cancer Treatments. How Big Is It?

2 hours ago

Californians Are Protecting Themselves from Wildfire. Why Is There an Insurance Crisis?

2 hours ago

Family Fun, Community Events Highlight Cinco de Mayo Weekend in Fresno

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend