Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
New York's Highest Appeals Court Declines to Block Trump's Sentencing in His Hush Money Case
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 2 weeks ago on
January 9, 2025

Trump's legal team faces setback as New York court refuses to block sentencing in hush money case. (AP/Jose Luis Magana)

Share

New York’s highest court on Thursday declined to block Donald Trump’s upcoming sentencing in his hush money case, leaving the U.S. Supreme Court as the president-elect’s likely last option to prevent the hearing from taking place Friday.

One judge of the New York Court of Appeals issued a brief order declining to grant a hearing to Trump’s legal team.

Trump Seeks Supreme Court Intervention

Trump has asked the Supreme Court to call off Friday’s sentencing. His lawyers turned to the nation’s highest court Wednesday after New York courts refused to postpone the sentencing by Judge Juan M. Merchan. Merchan presided over Trump’s trial and conviction last May on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records in what prosecutors called an attempt to cover up a $130,000 hush money payment to porn actor Stormy Daniels. Trump has denied wrongdoing.

In a filing to the top New York court, Trump’s attorneys had said Merchan and the state’s mid-level appellate court both “erroneously failed” to stop the sentencing, arguing that the Constitution requires an automatic pause as they appeal and that the sentencing would disrupt the Republican’s presidential transition as he prepares to return to the White House on Jan. 20.

Prosecutors Push Back Against Delay

Prosecutors pushed back, saying there’s no reason for the high court to take the “extraordinary step” of entering a state case to halt a sentencing that’s been delayed at Trump’s request.

“There is a compelling public interest in proceeding to sentencing,” Manhattan prosecutors wrote. “Defendant has provided no record support for his claim that his duties as President-elect foreclose him from virtually attending a sentencing that will likely take no more than an hour.”

While Merchan has indicated he will not impose jail time, fines or probation, Trump’s lawyers argued a felony conviction would still have intolerable side effects, including distracting him as he prepares to take office.

Legal Arguments and Immunity Claims

Trump’s attorney D. John Sauer called the case politically motivated and said sentencing now would be a “grave injustice.” Sauer is also Trump’s pick to be solicitor general, who represents the government before the high court.

The emergency motion to the U.S. Supreme Court was submitted to Justice Sonia Sotomayor, who hears emergency appeals from New York.

Trump’s attorneys also argue that evidence used in the Manhattan trial violated last summer’s Supreme Court ruling giving Trump broad immunity from prosecution over acts he took as president. At the least, they have said, the sentencing should be delayed while their appeals play out on the immunity issue.

Judges in New York have found that Trump’s convictions related to personal matters rather than the official presidential at the core of the Supreme Court’s ruling.

Prosecutors argue Trump’s claims aren’t strong enough to overturn his conviction and his appeal shouldn’t freeze the case because it’s about evidence rather than the core charges.

Any pause now would likely push the schedule out past Trump’s inauguration, creating a yearslong or indefinite delay, prosecutors wrote.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Tulare Police Arrest Fake Bail Bondsman in Grandmother Scam

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Executive Orders Will Remake Immigration, but Legal Questions Remain

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Rosemary Quirarte

DON'T MISS

Democrats’ Crisis of the Future: The Biggest States That Back Them Are Shrinking

DON'T MISS

Tech Founder Pledges to Give Away Half His Wealth to Make the American Dream More Possible

DON'T MISS

Let the Latest Scramble Begin for California School Construction Money

DON'T MISS

Americans Say It’s Harder to ‘Make It’ Financially Than Ever Before

DON'T MISS

Feeling’s Mutual: Rams Rookie Jared Verse Already Feeling Ire From Eagles Fans on Social Media

DON'T MISS

Ravens and Bills Lost Plenty of Talent Last Offseason, but Stayed in Super Bowl Contention

DON'T MISS

Mahomes and Kelce Help Chiefs to 23-14 Win Over Texans and Another AFC Title Game Trip

UP NEXT

Trump’s Executive Orders Will Remake Immigration, but Legal Questions Remain

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Rosemary Quirarte

UP NEXT

Democrats’ Crisis of the Future: The Biggest States That Back Them Are Shrinking

UP NEXT

Tech Founder Pledges to Give Away Half His Wealth to Make the American Dream More Possible

UP NEXT

Let the Latest Scramble Begin for California School Construction Money

UP NEXT

Americans Say It’s Harder to ‘Make It’ Financially Than Ever Before

UP NEXT

Feeling’s Mutual: Rams Rookie Jared Verse Already Feeling Ire From Eagles Fans on Social Media

UP NEXT

Ravens and Bills Lost Plenty of Talent Last Offseason, but Stayed in Super Bowl Contention

UP NEXT

Mahomes and Kelce Help Chiefs to 23-14 Win Over Texans and Another AFC Title Game Trip

UP NEXT

Governor Newsom Negotiates Mortgage Relief for LA Firestorm Victims

Democrats’ Crisis of the Future: The Biggest States That Back Them Are Shrinking

1 day ago

Tech Founder Pledges to Give Away Half His Wealth to Make the American Dream More Possible

1 day ago

Let the Latest Scramble Begin for California School Construction Money

1 day ago

Americans Say It’s Harder to ‘Make It’ Financially Than Ever Before

1 day ago

Feeling’s Mutual: Rams Rookie Jared Verse Already Feeling Ire From Eagles Fans on Social Media

2 days ago

Ravens and Bills Lost Plenty of Talent Last Offseason, but Stayed in Super Bowl Contention

2 days ago

Mahomes and Kelce Help Chiefs to 23-14 Win Over Texans and Another AFC Title Game Trip

2 days ago

Governor Newsom Negotiates Mortgage Relief for LA Firestorm Victims

2 days ago

Fresno Women’s Celebration Calls for Equality for All

2 days ago

Homes Were Burning and Roads Already Jammed When Pacific Palisades Evacuation Order Came, AP Finds

2 days ago

Tulare Police Arrest Fake Bail Bondsman in Grandmother Scam

A Los Angeles man was arrested Thursday in connection with a scam that defrauded a 79-year-old woman out of thousands of dollars after false...

1 minute ago

1 minute ago

Tulare Police Arrest Fake Bail Bondsman in Grandmother Scam

Immigration instructions
13 minutes ago

Trump’s Executive Orders Will Remake Immigration, but Legal Questions Remain

23 minutes ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Rosemary Quirarte

1 day ago

Democrats’ Crisis of the Future: The Biggest States That Back Them Are Shrinking

1 day ago

Tech Founder Pledges to Give Away Half His Wealth to Make the American Dream More Possible

1 day ago

Let the Latest Scramble Begin for California School Construction Money

1 day ago

Americans Say It’s Harder to ‘Make It’ Financially Than Ever Before

2 days ago

Feeling’s Mutual: Rams Rookie Jared Verse Already Feeling Ire From Eagles Fans on Social Media

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend