Opinion

Lawmakers Resolve California Fast Food Battle but Clash Still Rages in Another Industry

Published

2 months ago

October 2, 2023

A clash between auto manufacturers and their own franchised dealers in California has each side trying to persuade Gov. Gavin Newsom to favor its position. (GV Wire File/Jahz Tello)

Share with friends

The California Legislature devoted much of its time this year to a battle over regulating wages and working conditions of fast food workers.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Last year, legislators and Gov. Gavin Newsom created a state agency that would oversee the fast food industry, which fought back with a referendum asking voters to overturn the new law, arguing that it would undermine the franchise business model.

With the referendum qualified for the ballot, the battle was rejoined this year with a proposal to make parent companies liable for labor law violations, further eroding the franchise model.

Ultimately, the clash was resolved with a compromise that gave sponsors of the legislation, unions mostly, what they wanted, including a new $20 minimum wage, but removed the threat to the franchise system. Newsom signed the compromise legislation, Assembly Bill 1228, last week, and the fast food industry will remove its referendum from the 2024 ballot.

“Signature of AB 1228 preserves the franchise business model in the state and solidifies the best possible outcome for workers, local restaurant owners, and brands,” Matt Haller, president of the International Franchise Association, said in a statement.

While the fast food battle drew much media attention, there was another, much quieter clash over the franchise business model, involving a much more important segment of the consumer economy: new car sales.

This one, however, pitted auto manufacturers against their own franchised dealers in California and it’s still underway as each side tries to persuade Newsom to favor its position.

During the 1930s, as the nation’s auto industry consolidated into a few major manufacturers, they created a system for selling their vehicles through local franchised dealers.

When European and Asian automakers began peddling their vehicles in the United States after World War II, they also adopted the franchise system.

Dealerships often became major businesses unto themselves, particularly when corporations acquired multiple franchises. And it is common knowledge that dealerships profit handsomely from after-sale maintenance and repair work for their new car customers, as well as used car sales.

In many states, holders of valuable new car franchises bolstered their monopolies by persuading legislatures to pass laws making it illegal for anyone other than franchised dealers to sell new cars.

Relationships between automakers and their franchisees haven’t always been smooth and their clashes have often reached the political arena, but the underlying system has remained intact.

The Elon Musk Factor

Then Elon Musk and Tesla came along.

Musk refused to sell his revolutionary, battery-powered cars through franchised dealers and set up his own dealerships, incurring the wrath of franchisees. Tesla waged legal battles in states that had barred or limited its direct sales to customers.

By and by, however, as major manufacturers began making their own electric cars, they began toying with the notion of emulating Tesla and bypassing franchises in favor of direct sales.

Franchised dealerships see that as a threat to their place in the multibillion-dollar business of selling and servicing new cars. In California alone, upwards of 2 million new cars and light trucks are sold each year.

Enter Assembly Bill 473, introduced at the behest of the state’s franchised new car dealers. It would put some tight restrictions on the ability of automakers to bypass the franchise system and also deals with other aspects of the business such as construction of electric car chargers and subscription services to new car owners.

The automakers mounted a lobbying campaign to block the bill but it survived committee and floor votes and has landed on Newsom’s desk.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.

GV Wire – Explore. Explain. Expose

Lawmakers Resolve California Fast Food Battle but Clash Still Rages in Another Industry

About the Author

You may like

Some Californians Released From Prison Will Receive $2,400 Under New State Re-Entry Program

How Well Is Your State Lawmaker Representing Your Interests?

Newsom Morphs From Bullet Train Skeptic to Booster, but His Criticisms Remain Valid

New Fresno Philharmonic Series to Celebrate Fresno Region’s Cultural Diversity

Dodging the Medicare Enrollment Deadline Can Be Costly

Palestine Flag Raising At Eaton Plaza

Merced Mall Renovations Still Moving Forward, Developer Says. Here’s What to Expect in 2024.

Palestinian Flag Flies in Downtown Fresno Following Weeks of Controversy

Federal Judge Prohibits Separating Migrant Families at US Border for 8 Years

Jon Rahm Joins LIV Golf. Here’s What It Means for LIV and the PGA Tour.

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Isn’t Rare, Says New CDC Survey. It Affects 3.3 Million US Adults

Fresno City Council Going to Court to Stop Closure of Mobile Home Park

Ian Bremmer: US CEOs Too Influential on China Policy, Says Rahm Emanuel

Ian Bremmer: Is an Israel-Palestine Two-State Solution Possible?

Newsom Morphs From Bullet Train Skeptic to Booster, but His Criticisms Remain Valid

Successful Reading Skills Upgrade, Rooted in Phonics, Offers a Lesson for California Politicians

Economic Reality Bites as Newsom Faces a Big Budget Problem

Newsom Chides GOP for Trying to Change Voting Rules yet Adopts the Same Tactics

Cowboys vs. Seahawks Game Was a Better Show Than Newsom vs. DeSantis

Newsom vs. DeSantis: A Real Debate on the Issues or Just More Mudslinging?

California’s Utilities Commission, Other Consumer Watchdogs, Often Protect Big Companies

Closed-off Interstate 10 Is No Stranger to Major Damage or Political Attention

California Keeps Expanding School Curricula. What About Improving Key Subjects?

Political and Economic Stakes Are High for San Francisco This Week

Palestine Flag Raising At Eaton Plaza

Palestinian Flag Flies in Downtown Fresno Following Weeks of Controversy

News Minute: Adventist Health Drops Blue Shield, 18 Year Old Criminal Prosecutor Makes History, and More!

Fresno Councilmembers Clash Over Palestinian Flag Raising at City Park

Analyst Breaks Down Heated TV Clash Over Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

Wired Wednesday: Farms, Food, and Future of the Valley

Crafting Automotive Dreams: Caliber Customs of Madera

GV Wire News Minute: Check Out the Trending Stories of the Week

The DeSantis-Newsom Debate in Less Than 60 Seconds, Including the Poop Map

Wired Wednesday: The Latest on Income-Based PG&E Charges

You Can Find ‘This n’ That’ at Fresno Collectibles Shop

Actress Cynthia Nixon Leads Hunger Strike Outside White House, Demanding Gaza Ceasefire