Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Opinion: Parents Should Be Aware of Newsom’s Universal Pre-K Proposal
Opinion
By Opinion
Published 3 years ago on
June 18, 2021

Share

Like a baby going goo-goo, Governor Gavin Newsom is gaga for state-funded preschool and has proposed a massive pre-K program in his recent revised budget.  The evidence, however, shows that universal preschool will not improve student achievement and will negatively impact the children that Newsom claims to want to help.

Newsom included his preschool proposal as part of his plan to “re-imagine” California’s public schools.  His goal is to have “Universal transitional kindergarten by 2024, phasing in access for four-year-olds growing to $2.7 billion in 2024-25.”

Lance Izumi

Opinion

Rhetoric Unsupported by Research

Newsom’s press release claims that under his proposal California will “finally achieve universal Pre-K, providing high-quality, free transitional kindergarten to all four-year-olds in California, regardless of income or immigration status.”  Too bad, however, that research does not support his rosy rhetoric.

Pro-preschool politicians always claim that that their proposals will guarantee high-quality preschools, but, as Boston College psychology professor Peter Gray points out: “Yes, the language sounds comforting, but what does it mean?  What does ‘high quality’ actually mean?”

Professor Gray’s concern is not to be taken lightly.  He is the author of one of the world’s most acclaimed psychology textbooks and is an expert, as his biography says, “on the role of play in human evolution and how children educate themselves, through play and exploration, when they are free to do so.”

Evidence Early Schooling is Harmful

Writing recently in Psychology Today, Gray said that there is growing research evidence that early schooling is ineffective and harmful.

For example, he stated: “A well-controlled study of the effects of a government supported pre-kindergarten program for economically deprived families in Tennessee revealed that, by third grade, children in the program performed significantly worse than those who (by random assignment) were not in the program.”

The students in the Tennessee pre-K program “scored lower on academic tests, were more likely to be diagnosed as having a learning disorder, were less likely to have been diagnosed as intellectually gifted, and were more likely to have discipline problems than those who ha attended no preschool program.”

The study, authored by researchers at Vanderbilt University, came to very strong conclusions about the efficacy of government preschool programs.

Cautionary Tale About State Pre-K Programs

According to the Vanderbilt researchers, “the inauspicious findings of the current study offer a cautionary tale about expecting too much from state pre-K programs.”

“State-funded pre-K,” they noted, “is a popular idea, but for the sake of the children and the promise of pre-K, credible evidence that a rather typical state pre-K program is not accomplishing its goals should provoke some reassessment.”

“It is apparent,” they concluded, “that the phrase ‘high quality pre-K’ does not convey enough about what the critical elements of a program should be” and it is “time to pay careful attention to whether the country’s youngest and most vulnerable children are well served in the pre-K classroom environments currently operated.”

“In short,” Gray observed, “the [Vanderbilt] study revealed that being home, even if you are poor, resulted in better academic and behavioral development than attending this academically oriented preschool program.”

Further, Gray noted that many other studies have shown that any improvement in achievement by students participating in preschool are not only lost by the third or fourth grade, “but have been reversed.”

Snake Oil for Children

Beyond the failure of government preschool programs to increase student achievement, Gray emphasized the emotional and mental damage done to children who are put in a classroom environment too early.

State-funded preschool programs that expect very young children to “march in step to the same drummer” fail to understand that is “just not the way children are built.”  While many children at age six may conform to a particular curriculum, some youngsters cannot and are then “singled out as ‘bad’ or, more common today, ‘disordered,’ and are either punished or drugged.”

“If this happens at age six,” warned Gray, “it is going to happen even more at ages three and four” and that is why “a curriculum for little children is cruel.”

Thus, when politicians like Gavin Newsom and Joe Biden, who is proposing massive federal funding of pre-K, claim that government preschool is an educational panacea, parents need to understand that it is more like snake oil for their children.

About the Author

Lance Izumi is senior director of the Center for Education at the Pacific Research Institute.  He is the author of the 2020 book A Kite in a Hurricane No More: The Journey of One Young Woman Who Overcame Learning Disabilities through Science and Educational Choice.

[activecampaign form=19]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Walberg Era Begins With a Charge to ‘Revolutionize’ Bulldogs Basketball

DON'T MISS

California Man Sentenced to 40 Years to Life for Fatal Freeway Shooting of 6-Year-Old Boy

DON'T MISS

16 Clovis Students Rewarded With Scholarships for Their Resilience

DON'T MISS

Dr. Green Thumb’s Is Open. Sweet Flower Debuts Saturday in Fresno Cannabis Rollout.

DON'T MISS

Reacher Star Alan Ritchson Calls Donald Trump a ‘Rapist’

DON'T MISS

Community Leaders Call for Transparency in Fresno Superintendent Search

DON'T MISS

Israeli Settlers Rampage Through a West Bank Village, Killing 1 Palestinian and Wounding 25

DON'T MISS

US Intelligence Finding Shows China Surging Equipment Sales to Russia to Help War Effort in Ukraine

DON'T MISS

From Tragedy to Triumph: The Land Before Time Litter’s Journey

DON'T MISS

Oakland Officials Vote to Include ‘San Francisco’ in Airport’s Name

UP NEXT

California Man Sentenced to 40 Years to Life for Fatal Freeway Shooting of 6-Year-Old Boy

UP NEXT

16 Clovis Students Rewarded With Scholarships for Their Resilience

UP NEXT

Dr. Green Thumb’s Is Open. Sweet Flower Debuts Saturday in Fresno Cannabis Rollout.

UP NEXT

Reacher Star Alan Ritchson Calls Donald Trump a ‘Rapist’

UP NEXT

Community Leaders Call for Transparency in Fresno Superintendent Search

UP NEXT

Israeli Settlers Rampage Through a West Bank Village, Killing 1 Palestinian and Wounding 25

UP NEXT

US Intelligence Finding Shows China Surging Equipment Sales to Russia to Help War Effort in Ukraine

UP NEXT

From Tragedy to Triumph: The Land Before Time Litter’s Journey

UP NEXT

Oakland Officials Vote to Include ‘San Francisco’ in Airport’s Name

UP NEXT

Several Writers Decline Recognition From PEN America in Protest Over Its Israel-Hamas War Stance

Dr. Green Thumb’s Is Open. Sweet Flower Debuts Saturday in Fresno Cannabis Rollout.

8 hours ago

Reacher Star Alan Ritchson Calls Donald Trump a ‘Rapist’

9 hours ago

Community Leaders Call for Transparency in Fresno Superintendent Search

9 hours ago

Israeli Settlers Rampage Through a West Bank Village, Killing 1 Palestinian and Wounding 25

11 hours ago

US Intelligence Finding Shows China Surging Equipment Sales to Russia to Help War Effort in Ukraine

11 hours ago

From Tragedy to Triumph: The Land Before Time Litter’s Journey

13 hours ago

Oakland Officials Vote to Include ‘San Francisco’ in Airport’s Name

13 hours ago

Several Writers Decline Recognition From PEN America in Protest Over Its Israel-Hamas War Stance

14 hours ago

US Consumer Sentiment Falls Slightly as Outlook for Inflation Worsens

14 hours ago

A Near-Total Ban on Abortion Has Supercharged the Political Dynamics of Arizona, a Key Swing State

14 hours ago

Walberg Era Begins With a Charge to ‘Revolutionize’ Bulldogs Basketball

A new era of Fresno State men’s basketball is here. The Red Wave came out strong and welcomed Vance Walberg as coach with a Bulldog pa...

6 hours ago

6 hours ago

Walberg Era Begins With a Charge to ‘Revolutionize’ Bulldogs Basketball

7 hours ago

California Man Sentenced to 40 Years to Life for Fatal Freeway Shooting of 6-Year-Old Boy

8 hours ago

16 Clovis Students Rewarded With Scholarships for Their Resilience

8 hours ago

Dr. Green Thumb’s Is Open. Sweet Flower Debuts Saturday in Fresno Cannabis Rollout.

9 hours ago

Reacher Star Alan Ritchson Calls Donald Trump a ‘Rapist’

9 hours ago

Community Leaders Call for Transparency in Fresno Superintendent Search

11 hours ago

Israeli Settlers Rampage Through a West Bank Village, Killing 1 Palestinian and Wounding 25

11 hours ago

US Intelligence Finding Shows China Surging Equipment Sales to Russia to Help War Effort in Ukraine

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend