Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Conservative High Court Justices Seems Likely to Leave to Health Care Law in Place
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 4 years ago on
November 10, 2020

Share

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed likely Tuesday to leave in place the bulk of the Affordable Care Act, including key protections for pre-existing health conditions and subsidized insurance premiums that affect tens of millions of Americans.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh, among the conservative justices, appeared in two hours of arguments to be unwilling to strike down the entire law — a long-held Republican goal that has repeatedly failed in Congress and the courts — even if they were to find the law’s now-toothless mandate for obtaining health insurance to be unconstitutional.

The court’s three liberal justices are almost certain to vote to uphold the law in its entirety and presumably would form a majority by joining a decision that cut away only the mandate, which now has no financial penalty attached to it. Congress zeroed out the penalty in 2017, but left the rest of the law untouched.

“Would Congress want the rest of the law to survive if the unconstitutional provision were severed? Here, Congress left the rest of the law intact,” Roberts said. “That seems to be a compelling answer to the question.”

For his part, Kavanaugh said recent decisions by the court suggest “that the proper remedy would be to sever the mandate and leave the rest of the act in place.”

Kavanaugh Is One of Three Justices Appointed by President Donald Trump

A week after the 2020 election, the justices heard arguments by telephone in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic in the court’s third major case over the 10-year-old law, popularly known as “Obamacare.” Republican attorneys general in 18 states and the administration want the whole law to be struck down, which would threaten coverage for more than 23 million people.

California, leading a group of Democratic-controlled states, and the Democratic-controlled U.S. House of Representatives are urging the court to leave the law in place.

Kavanaugh is one of three justices appointed by President Donald Trump on a court that is more conservative than the ones that sustained the law in previous challenges in 2012 and 2015. The others are Neil Gorsuch and new Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who joined the court late last month following her hurried nomination and confirmation to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

The three Trump appointees have never ruled on the substance of the health care law. Barrett, though, has been critical of the court’s earlier major health care decisions sustaining the law, both written by Roberts.

The Supreme Court could have heard the case before the election, but set arguments for a week after. The timing could add a wrinkle to the case since President-elect Joe Biden strongly supports the health care law.

The U.S. Supreme Court is seen as arguments are heard about the Affordable Care Act Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

If the Mandate Goes, They Say, the Rest of the Law Should Go With It

The case turns on a change made by the Republican-controlled Congress in 2017 that reduced the penalty for not having health insurance to zero. Without the penalty, the law’s mandate to have health insurance is unconstitutional, the GOP-led states argue.

If the mandate goes, they say, the rest of the law should go with it because the mandate was central to the law’s passage.

However, enrollment in the law’s insurance markets has stayed relatively stable at more than 11 million people, even after the effective date of the penalty’s elimination in 2019. According to the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation, enrollment dropped by about 300,000 people from 2018 to 2019. Kaiser estimates 11.4 million people have coverage this year.

An additional 12 million people have coverage through the law’s Medicaid expansion.

The legal argument could well turn on the legal doctrine of severability, the idea that the court can excise a problematic provision from a law and allow the rest of it to remain in force. The justices have done just that in other rulings in recent years.

But in the first big ACA case in 2012, Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas voted to strike down the entire law. Roberts and Justices Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor have voted to uphold it.

A limited ruling would have little real-world consequence. The case could also be rendered irrelevant if the new Congress were to restore a modest penalty for not buying health insurance.

A decision is expected by late spring.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Cargill’s Fresno Plants to Lay Off Nearly 180 Workers

DON'T MISS

Brown Berets Rip, Stomp US and Israeli Flags in Fresno City Hall Chambers

DON'T MISS

Tyson Foods Heir Suspended as CFO After Second Alcohol-Related Arrest

DON'T MISS

Ex-US Customs Officer Convicted of Letting Drug-Filled Cars Enter from Mexico

DON'T MISS

Elon Musk Wins Back His $44.9 Billion Tesla Pay Package in Shareholder Vote

DON'T MISS

Dos Rios Ranch State Park Opens in Modesto After Nearly 20-Year Wait

DON'T MISS

Arias Asks the Big Question: Is Benching Chief Balderrama About Race?

DON'T MISS

Fresno’s Juneteenth Freedom Run/Walk Inspired by Legacy of Opal Lee

DON'T MISS

Fresno State’s Craig School Dean Honored with Humanitarian Award

DON'T MISS

What’s the Value of a Fresno Unified Diploma When These ‘Classes’ Are as Easy as A-B-C?

UP NEXT

Supreme Court, Siding With Starbucks, Makes It Harder for NLRB to Win Court Orders in Labor Disputes

UP NEXT

US Reporter Evan Gershkovich, Jailed in Russia on Espionage Charges, to Stand Trial, Officials Say

UP NEXT

Supreme Court Rules California Man Can’t Trademark ‘Trump Too Small’

UP NEXT

Drunk Driver Gets 15 Years to Life for Deadly Fresno Taco Truck Crash

UP NEXT

Rep. Costa Blasts GOP House For Holding AG Merrick Garland in Contempt

UP NEXT

AP Sources: 8 Individuals Possibly Linked to Islamic State Arrested in US

UP NEXT

NBA Legend and Logo Jerry West Dies at 86

UP NEXT

Shaver Lake Drowning Victim Identified by Sheriff’s Office

UP NEXT

Cold Stone Creamery Could Shell out Cash for Not Putting Pistachios in Pistachio Ice Cream

UP NEXT

Justice Alito Questions Possibility of Political Compromise in Secret Recording

Ex-US Customs Officer Convicted of Letting Drug-Filled Cars Enter from Mexico

4 hours ago

Elon Musk Wins Back His $44.9 Billion Tesla Pay Package in Shareholder Vote

4 hours ago

Dos Rios Ranch State Park Opens in Modesto After Nearly 20-Year Wait

5 hours ago

Arias Asks the Big Question: Is Benching Chief Balderrama About Race?

5 hours ago

Fresno’s Juneteenth Freedom Run/Walk Inspired by Legacy of Opal Lee

6 hours ago

Fresno State’s Craig School Dean Honored with Humanitarian Award

7 hours ago

What’s the Value of a Fresno Unified Diploma When These ‘Classes’ Are as Easy as A-B-C?

7 hours ago

Trustees OK Bullard High Security Fence, Deny Charter School’s Independent Study Bid

7 hours ago

Fresno Dutch Bros, Other Businesses Will Have to Make Way for Railroad Project

8 hours ago

Attraction Starring Disney’s First Black Princess Replaces Ride Based on Film Many Viewed as Racist

8 hours ago

Cargill’s Fresno Plants to Lay Off Nearly 180 Workers

Nearly 180 workers will be laid off from a national meat processing giant as a local company looks to purchase its facilities. Minnesota-bas...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Cargill’s Fresno Plants to Lay Off Nearly 180 Workers

3 hours ago

Brown Berets Rip, Stomp US and Israeli Flags in Fresno City Hall Chambers

4 hours ago

Tyson Foods Heir Suspended as CFO After Second Alcohol-Related Arrest

4 hours ago

Ex-US Customs Officer Convicted of Letting Drug-Filled Cars Enter from Mexico

4 hours ago

Elon Musk Wins Back His $44.9 Billion Tesla Pay Package in Shareholder Vote

5 hours ago

Dos Rios Ranch State Park Opens in Modesto After Nearly 20-Year Wait

5 hours ago

Arias Asks the Big Question: Is Benching Chief Balderrama About Race?

6 hours ago

Fresno’s Juneteenth Freedom Run/Walk Inspired by Legacy of Opal Lee

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend