Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: The Politics of Slow Population Growth
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
January 12, 2020

Share

During the first decade of the 21st century, demographers in California’s Department of Finance and those in the U.S. Census Bureau found themselves in a genteel conflict.
Years by year, the two agencies’ estimates of California’s population diverged, finally reaching a gap of about 1 million human beings.


Dan Walters
Opinion
It was officially resolved by the 2010 census, which declared that California had 37.3 million residents, close to the state’s pre-census estimates.
Of course, the number was wrong because it’s impossible to precisely count everyone, and could easily have been a million or two too low, given the state’s large number of homeless and undocumented immigrants. However, it was the official number used by the federal government, including its allocation of congressional seats.
After the 2010 census, California’s delegation was frozen at 53 seats, still by far the largest of any state but a culture shock for a state that had been accustomed to seeing its congressional allocation grow steadily ever since it had entered the union in 1850.
Another census is scheduled for this year and last month, the two demographic agencies released their final estimates of the state’s population (as of July 1, 2019) before the official count begins.

The 2020 Census Will Once Again Settle the Demographic Conflict

Once again, they are markedly different, although not by as much as they had been a decade earlier. And once again, the state’s number is higher than the Census Bureau’s — 39.96 million by the state’s calculation, 39.5 million in the federal estimate.
The state calculated population growth in the year ending July 1 at 141,300 or .35%, the lowest year-to-year rate ever recorded.
The feds, meanwhile, estimated that California’s population grew by just 50,635 people during the 12-month period ending July 1, which is very close to a statistical zero. California barely escaped joining New York and the nine other states deemed to have lost population.
The low growth in both estimates reflects a strong outflow of Californians to other states — a net loss, in fact — a declining birthrate, a rising death rate and slowing immigration from other nations.
The 2020 census will once again settle the demographic conflict, and California officials are very concerned that President Donald Trump’s administration will not try very hard to count everyone in politically blue states. They are especially concerned that relying on the internet as the primary vehicle for counting the population will undercount the poor.
California is spending millions of dollars to improve the count. However, what emerges from the census will be the official number and if the Census Bureau’s latest estimates are validated, it’s highly likely that California, for the first time since it became a state in 1850, would lose a congressional seat.

A Very Significant Effect in the Years Ahead

In contrast, the 1990 census found that during the 1980s, California’s population increased by a whopping 6 million or 25% and it gained seven new congressional seats. However, it added just one after the 2000 census.

A loss would have one concrete effect, decreasing the state’s presidential electoral votes by one.
If California does lose a seat, it’s more a symbolic event than one with practical effects, but it does give California’s critics new ammunition to argue that the Golden State is now tarnished as its accumulated flaws, such as rampant homelessness, income disparity and sky-high housing costs impel people to move elsewhere.
A loss would have one concrete effect, decreasing the state’s presidential electoral votes by one, joining the larger phenomenon of blue states such as California losing congressional seats and electoral votes to faster growing, conservative-voting states in the South and Southwest, such as arch-rival Texas.
Given the very close national political divide, that could have a very significant effect in the years ahead.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

Ex-Rivals Line Up to Make Trump’s Case at Convention

DON'T MISS

John Deere Reverses its Support of Pride Events

DON'T MISS

Republican Convention Turns to Immigration and the Border, Central Issues for Trump’s Campaign

DON'T MISS

Power Restored at Overcrowded California Prison Amid Heat Wave

DON'T MISS

Elon Musk Says He Will Move SpaceX, X HQ From California to Texas

DON'T MISS

California Seizes Over 5,200 Pounds of Illegal Cannabis at State Parks, One in Tulare County

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Weighs in on City’s Industrial Battle: Be Wary of University’s Data

DON'T MISS

July Could Be A Weather Record-Breaking Month. Please Pass The Ice.

DON'T MISS

GV Wire Honored With 5 Reporting Awards in CNPA Competition

DON'T MISS

Your Fresno Address Will Determine If a Yes Vote for a School Bond Raises Your Taxes

UP NEXT

What Polls Tell Us About Biden’s Chances

UP NEXT

Republicans Will Regret a Second Trump Term

UP NEXT

The Deep Source of Trump’s Appeal

UP NEXT

When Progressive Ideals Become a Luxury

UP NEXT

John Roberts Makes His Bid for Infamy

UP NEXT

Quiq Labs Ongoing Camps Transform Summer Learning for Fresno Unified Students

UP NEXT

End of the Roar: Porsche Bids Farewell to the 718 Internal Combustion Engine

UP NEXT

Does Joe Biden Realize How Angry These Michigan Voters Are?

UP NEXT

How California’s Bureaucracy Prevents Working-Class Transplants from Resuming Their Careers

UP NEXT

George Clooney: I Love Joe Biden. But We Need a New Nominee.

Power Restored at Overcrowded California Prison Amid Heat Wave

14 hours ago

Elon Musk Says He Will Move SpaceX, X HQ From California to Texas

15 hours ago

California Seizes Over 5,200 Pounds of Illegal Cannabis at State Parks, One in Tulare County

15 hours ago

Fresno State Weighs in on City’s Industrial Battle: Be Wary of University’s Data

16 hours ago

July Could Be A Weather Record-Breaking Month. Please Pass The Ice.

16 hours ago

GV Wire Honored With 5 Reporting Awards in CNPA Competition

16 hours ago

Your Fresno Address Will Determine If a Yes Vote for a School Bond Raises Your Taxes

18 hours ago

What Polls Tell Us About Biden’s Chances

18 hours ago

A Prison Union Is Spending Big on Gavin Newsom. Is It an ‘800 Pound Gorilla’ or a Threatened Species?

18 hours ago

Local Dems Outshine GOP in Latest Congressional Fundraising

18 hours ago

Ex-Rivals Line Up to Make Trump’s Case at Convention

A parade of vanquished foes who previously criticized Donald Trump are speaking on the second night of the Republican National Convention on...

12 hours ago

12 hours ago

Ex-Rivals Line Up to Make Trump’s Case at Convention

13 hours ago

John Deere Reverses its Support of Pride Events

13 hours ago

Republican Convention Turns to Immigration and the Border, Central Issues for Trump’s Campaign

14 hours ago

Power Restored at Overcrowded California Prison Amid Heat Wave

15 hours ago

Elon Musk Says He Will Move SpaceX, X HQ From California to Texas

15 hours ago

California Seizes Over 5,200 Pounds of Illegal Cannabis at State Parks, One in Tulare County

16 hours ago

Fresno State Weighs in on City’s Industrial Battle: Be Wary of University’s Data

16 hours ago

July Could Be A Weather Record-Breaking Month. Please Pass The Ice.

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend