Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Judge: California Ride-Hailing Law Is Unconstitutional
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 3 years ago on
August 23, 2021

Share

LOS ANGELES — A judge Friday struck down a California ballot measure that exempted Uber and other app-based ride-hailing and delivery services from a state law requiring drivers to be classified as employees eligible for benefits and job protections.

Alameda County Superior Court Judge Frank Roesch ruled that Proposition 22 was unconstitutional.

Voters approved the measure in November after Uber, Lyft and other services spent $200 million in its favor, making it the most expensive ballot measure in state history.

Uber said it planned to appeal, setting up a fight that could likely end up in the California Supreme Court.

“This ruling ignores the will of the overwhelming majority of California voters and defies both logic and the law,” company spokesman Noah Edwardsen said. “You don’t have to take our word for it: California’s attorney general strongly defended Proposition 22’s constitutionality in this very case.”

He said the measure will remain in force pending the appeal.

Judge Sides with Drivers and SEIU Lawsuit

The judge sided with three drivers and the Service Employees International Union in a lawsuit that argued the measure improperly removed the state Legislature’s ability to grant workers the right to access to the state workers’ compensation program.

“For two years, drivers have been saying that democracy cannot be bought. And today’s decision shows they were right,” said Bob Schoonover, president of the SEIU California State Council.

Proposition 22 shielded app-based ride-hailing and delivery companies from a labor law that required such services to treat drivers as employees and not independent contractors, who don’t have to receive benefits such as paid sick leave or unemployment insurance.

Uber and Lyft threatened to leave the state if voters rejected the measure.

Labor spent about $20 million to challenge the proposition.

The state Supreme Court initially declined to hear the case in February — mainly on procedural grounds — but left open the possibility of a lower court challenge.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Yellen Says Threats to Democracy Risk US Economic Growth, an Indirect Jab at Trump

DON'T MISS

New Sea Route for Gaza Aid on Track. Treating Starving Children Is a Priority

DON'T MISS

At Time of Rising Antisemitism, Holocaust Survivors Take on Denial and Hate in New Digital Campaign

DON'T MISS

FUSD Trustees Name Misty Her as Interim Superintendent. National Search Yet to Start

DON'T MISS

Gov. Newsom Appoints Judges for Fresno, Merced Counties

DON'T MISS

Assemblymember Soria Dodges Questions About Defamation Lawsuit

DON'T MISS

Israel Briefs US on Evacuation Plan for Palestinians Ahead of Planned Rafah Assault

DON'T MISS

Canadian Police Make 3 Arrests in Sikh Separatist’s Slaying That Sparked a Spat with India

DON'T MISS

Three Arrested for Trespassing, Posting Flyers at Fresno Synagogue and Church

DON'T MISS

As They Search for a Superintendent, Fresno Trustees Flunk Econ 101

UP NEXT

Anchovy Feast Draws the Most Sea Lions to SF’s Fisherman’s Wharf in 15 Years

UP NEXT

Captain Sentenced to 4 Years for Criminal Negligence in Fiery Deaths of 34 Aboard Scuba Boat

UP NEXT

Two Months to Count Election Ballots? California’s Long Tallies Turn Election Day Into Weeks, Months

UP NEXT

DEA’s Marijuana Reclassification Could Revive California’s Struggling Pot Industry

UP NEXT

Californians Are Protecting Themselves from Wildfire. Why Is There an Insurance Crisis?

UP NEXT

Peloton Cutting About 400 Jobs Worldwide; CEO McCarthy Stepping Down

UP NEXT

Trump Awarded 36 Million More Trump Media Shares Worth $1.8 Billion

UP NEXT

Campaign to Build New California City Submits Signatures to Get on November Ballot

UP NEXT

Study Says California’s 2023 Snowy Megadrought Rescue Was a Freak Event

UP NEXT

California’s Population Grew in 2023, Halting 3 Years of Decline

FUSD Trustees Name Misty Her as Interim Superintendent. National Search Yet to Start

Local Education /

11 hours ago

Gov. Newsom Appoints Judges for Fresno, Merced Counties

13 hours ago

Assemblymember Soria Dodges Questions About Defamation Lawsuit

13 hours ago

Israel Briefs US on Evacuation Plan for Palestinians Ahead of Planned Rafah Assault

14 hours ago

Canadian Police Make 3 Arrests in Sikh Separatist’s Slaying That Sparked a Spat with India

14 hours ago

Three Arrested for Trespassing, Posting Flyers at Fresno Synagogue and Church

14 hours ago

As They Search for a Superintendent, Fresno Trustees Flunk Econ 101

15 hours ago

Universities Negotiate End to Protests, Open Dialogue on Investment Policies

15 hours ago

Fresno Approves Hydrogen Contract for New Buses. How Far is the Filling Station?

17 hours ago

Heavy Rains Over Texas Have Led to Water Rescues, School Cancellations and Orders to Evacuate

17 hours ago

Yellen Says Threats to Democracy Risk US Economic Growth, an Indirect Jab at Trump

WASHINGTON — Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen argues that a fractured democracy can have destructive effects on the economy — an indirect jab...

16 mins ago

16 mins ago

Yellen Says Threats to Democracy Risk US Economic Growth, an Indirect Jab at Trump

37 mins ago

New Sea Route for Gaza Aid on Track. Treating Starving Children Is a Priority

45 mins ago

At Time of Rising Antisemitism, Holocaust Survivors Take on Denial and Hate in New Digital Campaign

Local Education /
11 hours ago

FUSD Trustees Name Misty Her as Interim Superintendent. National Search Yet to Start

13 hours ago

Gov. Newsom Appoints Judges for Fresno, Merced Counties

13 hours ago

Assemblymember Soria Dodges Questions About Defamation Lawsuit

14 hours ago

Israel Briefs US on Evacuation Plan for Palestinians Ahead of Planned Rafah Assault

14 hours ago

Canadian Police Make 3 Arrests in Sikh Separatist’s Slaying That Sparked a Spat with India

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend