Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fresno County Lawsuit Against Political Candidates Stifles Free Speech, Wastes Taxpayers' Money
Opinion
By Opinion
Published 1 year ago on
April 2, 2024

Will Fresno County continue to pursue what so far has been a losing court battle to limit how much Garry Bredefeld, left, and Luis Chavez can spend on their supervisorial election campaigns? (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Ethically challenged politicians often prioritize their job security above all else. Yet, even with this focus on self-preservation, many resist the temptation to misuse taxpayer dollars to stifle political opposition. However, Fresno County stands as a recent notable exception to this general restraint.

Garry Bredefeld

Opinion

A year ago, the Fresno County Board of Supervisors filed a lawsuit to limit what Councilmember Luis Chavez and I could spend to talk to voters in our campaigns for the Board of Supervisors. The Board authorized its taxpayer-funded in-house county lawyers and paid a 250-attorney Los Angeles law firm to sue us with the goal of preventing us from using funds from earlier campaigns to challenge Board of Supervisors incumbents.

Using funds from prior elections is completely legal, constitutionally protected, and happens all the time when candidates run for a different office. The county’s lawsuit against us is something never seen before – incumbents using taxpayer funds (your funds) to sue their challengers to limit their ability to speak to voters.

When the case went to trial, Fresno County Superior Court Judge Jonathan Skiles rejected the County’s lawsuit, explaining that for 50 years the U.S. Supreme Court has held that campaign funds are the equivalent of speech (because those funds are the only way for candidates to effectively communicate with voters). In other words, candidate spending is protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Judge Skiles’ Order reads like a primer on First Amendment constitutional law, with a half-dozen federal and state judicial opinions and authorities backing up his ruling against the county. The county has appealed the ruling, but unless it plans on overturning longstanding U.S. Supreme Court precedent (unlikely), the county’s appeal looks dead on arrival at the appellate court.

In a turn of justice, Judge Skiles recently mandated the county to cover our legal expenses which is more than $70,000. This may protect against the county recklessly continuing its ongoing lawfare war against us, while the county has already lost the battle over constitutional law.

Fresno County’s ‘Incumbent Protection Scheme’

What has been particularly troubling about this case is the funding for the county’s legal pursuits, including the fees for its own lawyers, the Los Angeles-based law firm, and now the fees for our attorneys, comes directly from the pocket of county taxpayers.

This questionable and irresponsible use of public funds is particularly egregious for supporters of free speech and fair elections because, while the county sought to silence challengers like myself and Councilmember Chavez, it openly permits incumbent county supervisors to spend unlimited amounts on their own elections. This entire misadventure has the unmistakable smell of what I called from the outset, an “Incumbent Protection Scheme.”

Looking ahead, the county now faces critical decisions.

First and foremost, it must come clean to taxpayers. It must transparently disclose the financial impact of its legal battle against myself and Councilmember Chavez. What are the actual costs to county taxpayers? How much has the L.A. law firm cost taxpayers?

Second, the county has appealed Judge Skiles’ ruling. If they decide to pursue the appeal, the county must reassure taxpayers that it possesses a plausible legal strategy on appeal to overturn a half-century of established constitutional law. Taxpayers need to know that the county is not continuing to pursue this litigation merely because it already has wasted significant amounts from the public treasury, that it is not throwing good money after bad.

Third, taxpayers deserve to know who within the county was responsible for green-lighting the lawsuit against two political opponents of incumbent supervisors. Were county leaders aware they could have sought free advice from the California Attorney General, who is on record as rejecting similar attempts from other counties to restrain candidate spending? Were they simply given poor advice from the county counsel? Or did they pursue this case knowing it was a fraught legal strategy with little chance of success?

Voters are being asked this year whether to retain or replace two incumbent members of the Board of Supervisors. Yet, until the county comes clean on the complete costs and true motivations of this reckless lawsuit, voters will not have the transparency and accountability they deserve on this and many other issues.

About the Author

Garry Bredefeld represents northeast neighborhoods on the Fresno City Council. He is challenging incumbent Fresno County Supervisor Steve Brandau.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

US FDA to Shorten Review Time for Drug Developers Under New Voucher Program

DON'T MISS

Physician Warns Fresno County Supervisors About Jail’s Medical Provider, Private Equity Co.

DON'T MISS

Houthi Official Says Group Will Intervene to Support Iran Against Israel

DON'T MISS

How Trump Shifted on Iran Under Pressure From Israel

DON'T MISS

Trump Calls for Iran’s ‘Unconditional Surrender’ as Israel-Iran Air War Rages On

DON'T MISS

US Supreme Court Justices Disclose Income From Book Deals and Teaching

DON'T MISS

Fresno Approves $2.4 Billion Budget. What’s In, What’s Out?

DON'T MISS

The S&P 500 Is Nearing a Record. Really.

DON'T MISS

Only Nonviolence Will Beat Trump

DON'T MISS

Kaweah Health CEO Says He’s Ready to Retire After 34 Years at Hospital

UP NEXT

Physician Warns Fresno County Supervisors About Jail’s Medical Provider, Private Equity Co.

UP NEXT

Houthi Official Says Group Will Intervene to Support Iran Against Israel

UP NEXT

How Trump Shifted on Iran Under Pressure From Israel

UP NEXT

Trump Calls for Iran’s ‘Unconditional Surrender’ as Israel-Iran Air War Rages On

UP NEXT

US Supreme Court Justices Disclose Income From Book Deals and Teaching

UP NEXT

Fresno Approves $2.4 Billion Budget. What’s In, What’s Out?

UP NEXT

The S&P 500 Is Nearing a Record. Really.

UP NEXT

Only Nonviolence Will Beat Trump

UP NEXT

Kaweah Health CEO Says He’s Ready to Retire After 34 Years at Hospital

UP NEXT

Obama Steps Back Into Public Eye at a Stormy Political Moment

How Trump Shifted on Iran Under Pressure From Israel

2 hours ago

Trump Calls for Iran’s ‘Unconditional Surrender’ as Israel-Iran Air War Rages On

3 hours ago

US Supreme Court Justices Disclose Income From Book Deals and Teaching

3 hours ago

Fresno Approves $2.4 Billion Budget. What’s In, What’s Out?

4 hours ago

The S&P 500 Is Nearing a Record. Really.

4 hours ago

Only Nonviolence Will Beat Trump

4 hours ago

Kaweah Health CEO Says He’s Ready to Retire After 34 Years at Hospital

4 hours ago

Obama Steps Back Into Public Eye at a Stormy Political Moment

4 hours ago

Remains of 796 Babies Feared Buried at Former Irish Catholic Home

4 hours ago

Newsom Gave Political Rival a $380K Job. See the Special Interests Who Paid for It

4 hours ago

US FDA to Shorten Review Time for Drug Developers Under New Voucher Program

(Reuters) -The U.S. FDA is launching a program under which its commissioner can issue vouchers to companies he finds are aligned with nation...

17 minutes ago

17 minutes ago

US FDA to Shorten Review Time for Drug Developers Under New Voucher Program

23 minutes ago

Physician Warns Fresno County Supervisors About Jail’s Medical Provider, Private Equity Co.

24 minutes ago

Houthi Official Says Group Will Intervene to Support Iran Against Israel

President Donald Trump speaks during an Invest America Roundtable in the State Dining room, at the White House, in Washington, U.S., June 9, 2025. REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein
2 hours ago

How Trump Shifted on Iran Under Pressure From Israel

A firefighter works to extinguish a fire on a bus following a missile attack from Iran, in Herzliya, Israel, June 17, 2025. (Reuters/Ronen Zvulun)
3 hours ago

Trump Calls for Iran’s ‘Unconditional Surrender’ as Israel-Iran Air War Rages On

Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson speaks to the 2025 Supreme Court Fellows Program, Thursday, Feb. 13, 2025, at the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

US Supreme Court Justices Disclose Income From Book Deals and Teaching

4 hours ago

Fresno Approves $2.4 Billion Budget. What’s In, What’s Out?

4 hours ago

The S&P 500 Is Nearing a Record. Really.

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend