Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Here's the Conclusive Evidence That the Media Casts Muslims in a Negative Light
The-Conversation
By The Conversation
Published 3 years ago on
May 31, 2022

Share

The warm welcome Americans and Europeans have given Ukrainians in 2022 contrasts sharply with the uneven — and frequently hostile — policies toward Syrian refugees in the mid-2010s.

Political scientist David Laitin has highlighted the role that religious identities play in this dynamic. As he pointed out in a recent interview, Syrian refugees were “mostly Muslim and faced higher degrees of discrimination than will the Ukrainians, who are largely of Christian heritage.”

The media provide information that shapes such attitudes toward Muslims. A 2007 Pew Research Center survey of Americans found that people’s negative opinions on Muslims were mostly influenced by what they heard and read in the media. Communications scholar Muniba Saleem and colleagues have demonstrated the link between media information and “stereotypic beliefs, negative emotions and support for harmful policies” toward Muslim Americans.

To better grasp the evolution of media portrayals of Muslims and Islam, our 2022 book, “Covering Muslims: American Newspapers in Comparative Perspective,” tracked the tone of hundreds of thousands of articles over decades.

We found overwhelmingly negative coverage, not only in the United States but also in the United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia.

Negative Coverage of Muslims

Previous research has identified widespread negative media representations of Muslims. An overview of studies undertaken from 2000 to 2015 by communications scholars Saifuddin Ahmed and Jörg Matthes concluded that Muslims were negatively framed in the media and that Islam was frequently cast as a violent religion.

But the studies they reviewed leave open two pressing questions that we address through our research.

First, do articles touching on Muslims and Islam include more negative representations than the average newspaper article? Second, are media portrayals of Muslims more negative than articles touching on other minority religions?

If stories about minority religious groups made it to the news only when they were involved in conflict in one way or another, then they may be negative for reasons that are not specific to Muslims.

What We Found

To answer these questions, we used media databases such as LexisNexis, Nexis Uni, ProQuest, and Factiva to download 256,963 articles mentioning Muslims or Islam — for which we use the shorthand “Muslim articles” — from 17 national, regional, and tabloid newspapers in the United States over the 21-year period from Jan. 1, 1996, to Dec. 31, 2016.

We developed a reliable method for measuring the positivity or negativity of stories by comparing them to the tone of a random sample of 48,283 articles about topics drawn from a wide range of newspapers. A negative value on this scale means that a story is negative relative to the average newspaper article.

Crucially, this approach also provided a baseline for additional comparisons. We collected sets of articles from U.S. newspapers relating not only to Muslims, but also separately to Catholics, Jews, and Hindus, three minority religious groups of varying size and status in the United States. We then assembled stories linked to Muslims from a broad array of newspapers in the U.K., Canada, and Australia.

Our central finding is that the average article mentioning Muslims or Islam in the United States is more negative than 84% of articles in our random sample. This means that one would likely have to read six articles in U.S. newspapers to find even one that was as negative as the average article touching on Muslims.

To give a concrete sense of how negative typical Muslim articles are, consider the following sentence that has the tone of the average Muslim article: “The Russian was made to believe by undercover agents that the radioactive material was to be delivered to a Muslim organization.” This contains two highly negative words (“undercover” and “radioactive”) and implies that the “Muslim organization” has nefarious goals.

Articles that mentioned Muslims were also much more likely to be negative than stories touching on any other group we examined. For Catholics, Jews, and Hindus, the proportion of positive and negative articles was close to 50-50. By contrast, 80% of all articles related to Muslims were negative.

The divergence is striking. Our work shows that the media are not prone to publishing negative stories when they write about other minority religions, but they are very likely to do so when they write about Muslims.

Beyond comparing coverage across groups, we were also interested in coverage across countries. Perhaps the United States is unique in its intensely negative coverage of Muslims. To find out, we collected 528,444 articles mentioning Muslims or Islam from the same time period from a range of newspapers in the U.K., Canada, and Australia. We found that the proportion of negative to positive articles in these countries was almost exactly the same as that in the United States.

Implications of Negative Coverage

Multiple scholars have shown that negative stories generate less favorable attitudes toward Muslims. Other studies that looked at the impact of negative information about Muslims also found an increase in support for policies that harm Muslims, such as secret surveillance of Muslim Americans or the use of drone attacks in Muslim countries.

In addition, surveys of young American Muslims have found that negative media coverage resulted in weaker identification as American and in lower trust in the U.S. government.

We believe acknowledging and addressing the systemic negativity in media coverage of Muslims and Islam is vital for countering widespread stigmatization. This may, in turn, create opportunities for more humane policies that are fair to everyone regardless of their faith.The Conversation

About the Authors

Erik Bleich is the Charles A. Dana Professor of Political Science at Middlebury College. A. Maurits van der Veen is an associate professor of government at William & Mary. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

An Anti-War Movement Is Stirring in Israel

DON'T MISS

David Greenwood, Former UCLA Star and NBA Champion, Dies at 68 After Cancer Battle

DON'T MISS

Is the Trump-Musk Spat Really Over? Judging From Wall Street Trading, It’s a Fragile Peace

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Inmate Found Unresponsive in Cell, Autopsy Pending

DON'T MISS

A Look at Boeing’s Recent Troubles After Air India Crash

DON'T MISS

Gavin Newsom Changes His Tune on Running for President

DON'T MISS

McConnell, Mathurin Lead Pacers’ Bench Charge in Game 3, Fueling 2-1 NBA Finals Lead Over Thunder

DON'T MISS

US Sen. Alex Padilla Was Forcibly Removed After Interrupting News Conference by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem

DON'T MISS

Fresno Joins Nationwide ‘No Kings Day’ Movement at Multiple Locations

DON'T MISS

JetBlue Flight Rolls off Runway at Boston Airport, No Injuries Reported

UP NEXT

David Greenwood, Former UCLA Star and NBA Champion, Dies at 68 After Cancer Battle

UP NEXT

Is the Trump-Musk Spat Really Over? Judging From Wall Street Trading, It’s a Fragile Peace

UP NEXT

Tulare County Inmate Found Unresponsive in Cell, Autopsy Pending

UP NEXT

A Look at Boeing’s Recent Troubles After Air India Crash

UP NEXT

Gavin Newsom Changes His Tune on Running for President

UP NEXT

McConnell, Mathurin Lead Pacers’ Bench Charge in Game 3, Fueling 2-1 NBA Finals Lead Over Thunder

UP NEXT

US Sen. Alex Padilla Was Forcibly Removed After Interrupting News Conference by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem

UP NEXT

Fresno Joins Nationwide ‘No Kings Day’ Movement at Multiple Locations

UP NEXT

JetBlue Flight Rolls off Runway at Boston Airport, No Injuries Reported

UP NEXT

Teoscar Hernández Hits a 3-Run Homer and the Dodgers Beat the Padres to Win the Series

Tulare County Inmate Found Unresponsive in Cell, Autopsy Pending

50 minutes ago

A Look at Boeing’s Recent Troubles After Air India Crash

52 minutes ago

Gavin Newsom Changes His Tune on Running for President

53 minutes ago

McConnell, Mathurin Lead Pacers’ Bench Charge in Game 3, Fueling 2-1 NBA Finals Lead Over Thunder

57 minutes ago

US Sen. Alex Padilla Was Forcibly Removed After Interrupting News Conference by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem

59 minutes ago

Fresno Joins Nationwide ‘No Kings Day’ Movement at Multiple Locations

60 minutes ago

JetBlue Flight Rolls off Runway at Boston Airport, No Injuries Reported

1 hour ago

Teoscar Hernández Hits a 3-Run Homer and the Dodgers Beat the Padres to Win the Series

1 hour ago

Giants Rally Again to Beat Lowly Rockies for 7th Straight Win

1 hour ago

Wildfire Burns in Madera County With No Containment

1 hour ago

An Anti-War Movement Is Stirring in Israel

I just spent a week in Israel and, while it may not look as if much has changed — the grinding war in the Gaza Strip continues to grind — I ...

19 minutes ago

19 minutes ago

An Anti-War Movement Is Stirring in Israel

35 minutes ago

David Greenwood, Former UCLA Star and NBA Champion, Dies at 68 After Cancer Battle

46 minutes ago

Is the Trump-Musk Spat Really Over? Judging From Wall Street Trading, It’s a Fragile Peace

Tulare County Sheriff's Office detectives are investigating a shooting in Strathmore that left a man wounded late night on Wednesday, Feb. 26, 2025. (Tulare County SO)
50 minutes ago

Tulare County Inmate Found Unresponsive in Cell, Autopsy Pending

52 minutes ago

A Look at Boeing’s Recent Troubles After Air India Crash

53 minutes ago

Gavin Newsom Changes His Tune on Running for President

57 minutes ago

McConnell, Mathurin Lead Pacers’ Bench Charge in Game 3, Fueling 2-1 NBA Finals Lead Over Thunder

59 minutes ago

US Sen. Alex Padilla Was Forcibly Removed After Interrupting News Conference by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend