Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Judge Clears Major Hurdle in T-Mobile's $26.5B Sprint Bid
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 4 years ago on
February 11, 2020

Share

NEW YORK — A federal judge has cleared a major path to T-Mobile’s $26.5 billion takeover of Sprint, as he rejected claims by more than a dozen states that the deal would mean less competition and higher phone bills.

Judge Victor Marrero in New York said Tuesday that the companies’ insistence that the deal would cut prices and the states’ insistence that the deal would raise prices “essentially cancel each other out.”
Though the deal still needs a few more approvals, T-Mobile expects to close it as early as April 1.
Once that happens, the number of major U.S. wireless companies would shrink from four to three. T-Mobile says the deal would benefit consumers as it becomes a fiercer competitor to the larger Verizon and AT&T. The deal would also create a new, but smaller competitor as satellite TV company Dish pledges to build a next-generation, 5G cellular network.
A group of state attorneys general tried to block the deal, arguing that having one fewer phone company would cost Americans billions of dollars in higher bills. Consumer Reports said the three remaining companies would have fewer incentives to compete on prices and quality.
Judge Victor Marrero in New York said Tuesday that the companies’ insistence that the deal would cut prices and the states’ insistence that the deal would raise prices “essentially cancel each other out.” Instead, he chose to rely on what wireless executives have done in the past and what they commit to doing in the future in an industry that is changing rapidly.
T-Mobile has pushed in recent years such consumer-friendly changes as restoring unlimited data plans. Marrero said he found that T-Mobile executives were credible at trial in promising to continue competing aggressively with AT&T and Verizon.
Photo of T-Mobile chief executive John Legere
FILE – In this Jan. 15, 2020, file photo T-Mobile chief executive John Legere speaks to reporters as he leaves the courthouse in New York. A federal judge has removed a major obstacle to T-Mobile’s $26.5 billion takeover of Sprint, as he rejected claims by a group of states that the deal would mean less competition and higher phone bills. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File)

Marrero’s Decision Comes After the Justice Department Already Approved the Deal

The judge also agreed with the companies that Sprint was “at best struggling to even tread water” and would not last as a national wireless competitor. He also said that he is persuaded that the U.S. Justice Department’s side deal with Dish, which sets up the satellite TV provider as a new wireless company, would reduce the threat to competition.
Marrero’s decision comes after the Justice Department already approved the deal. Another judge still needs to approve the Dish settlement, a process that is usually straightforward but has taken longer than expected. A utility board in California also has to approve the deal.
New York Attorney General Letitia James, one of the leading attorneys general in the case, said her office was considering an appeal. She said Tuesday’s ruling “marks a loss for every American who relies on their cell phone for work, to care for a family member, and to communicate with friends.”
Gigi Sohn, a fellow at the Georgetown Law Institute for Technology Law & Policy, said that while consumers are often promised benefits from mergers, “what they are left with each time are corporate behemoths” that can raise prices and destroy competition.
Sprint shares jumped $3.42, or 71%, to $8.22 in midday trading after the ruling came out. T-Mobile shares rose $8.64, or 10%, to $93.17. Verizon shares fell nearly 3% and AT&T nearly 1%.

The Deal Got the Nod From Both the Justice Department and the Federal Communications Commission

T-Mobile launched its bid for Sprint in 2018, after having been rebuffed by Obama-era regulators. T-Mobile CEO John Legere had seen President Donald Trump’s election and his appointed regulators as a good opportunity to try again to combine, according to evidence during the trial.

T-Mobile, which promised not to raise prices for three years, repeated previous arguments that the combined T-Mobile and Sprint will be able to build a better 5G network — a priority for the Trump administration — than either company could alone.
T-Mobile, which promised not to raise prices for three years, repeated previous arguments that the combined T-Mobile and Sprint will be able to build a better 5G network — a priority for the Trump administration — than either company could alone.
In his ruling, Marrero said that while both Sprint and T-Mobile will provide 5G service without the combination, their standalone networks would be more limited in scope and take longer to build.
The deal got the nod from both the Justice Department and the Federal Communications Commission, thanks to an unusual commitment to create a new wireless player in Dish. T-Mobile agreed to sell millions of Sprint’s prepaid customers to Dish. T-Mobile also has to rent its network to Dish while the fledgling rival built its own. Dish is also required to build a 5G network over the next several years.
Dish co-founder Charlie Ergen said in a statement that the ruling will accelerate its ability to deploy 5G and that its growth as a new competitor will bring “lower prices, greater choice and more innovation to consumers.”
Photo of Sprint CEO Marcelo Claure
FILE – In this Jan. 15, 2020, file photo Sprint CEO Marcelo Claure speaks to reporters as he leaves the courthouse in New York. A federal judge has removed a major obstacle to T-Mobile’s $26.5 billion takeover of Sprint, as he rejected claims by a group of states that the deal would mean less competition and higher phone bills. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File)

Some Analysts Have Said That Dish Has Potential as a Viable Competitor

The states had said that Dish wasn’t certain to succeed as a wireless company and was far smaller than Sprint, and the resulting wireless market would still be worse for consumers.
Dish has spent about $21 billion over a decade buying wireless spectrum, the airwaves for transmitting data and calls, although Dish hasn’t done much with it. Analysts have long been skeptical of whether Dish intends to build its own network or sell the spectrum to others. Now Dish faces up to $2.2 billion in fines if it fails to create a 5G network that serves 70% of the country by 2023.
Some analysts have said that Dish has potential as a viable competitor, but a big question is when. Even if it meets the 2023 government-imposed deadline, it still won’t reach as many potential customers as Sprint’s current-generation 4G network does today.
George Slover, senior policy counsel for Consumer Reports, said Sprint was an established carrier with a track record of spurring competition, while Dish is an unproven newcomer that will have to build its mobile phone network and services from scratch.
The coalition of state attorneys general that brought the case were led by New York and California and were joined by Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Wisconsin and the District of Columbia.
T-Mobile, based in Bellevue, Washington, is owned by the German telecommunications company Deutsche Telekom. Sprint is based in Overland Park, Kansas, and is owned by Japan’s SoftBank.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

UC Merced Begins NCAA Division II Sports Competition in 2025-26 Season

DON'T MISS

Bill Belichick Joining ‘Inside the NFL’ for Upcoming Season

DON'T MISS

Alec Baldwin Trial Halted as Judge Reviews Defense Motion to Dismiss Due to Ammo Dispute

DON'T MISS

A Packed Fresno City Hall Witnesses Badhesha’s Historic Moment for Sikhs

DON'T MISS

The Embattled Biden Campaign Tests Kamala Harris’ Strength vs. Trump

DON'T MISS

Emergency Workers Uncover Dozens of Bodies in a Gaza City District After Israeli Assault

DON'T MISS

Destination Paris: Swimmer Ryan Murphy Longs to Reclaim Top Spot on Medal Podium at the Olympics

DON'T MISS

These Picassos Prompted a Gender War at an Australian Gallery. Now the Curator Says She Painted Them

DON'T MISS

Russian Passenger Jet Crashes Flying Empty Near Moscow, Killing Its Crew of 3

DON'T MISS

Republicans Are Gathering in Milwaukee to Nominate Donald Trump Again. Here’s What to Expect

UP NEXT

Dinuba Man Faces Sexual Assault Charges, More Victims Possible

UP NEXT

A Trump Ally Is Training 75 Armed Citizens. Is That a Militia?

UP NEXT

House Passes GOP Bill Requiring Proof of Citizenship to Vote, Boosting Election-Year Talking Point

UP NEXT

His Brother Was Found Dead, His Mother Was Arrested Before This Baby Was Found Crawling by a Highway

UP NEXT

NATO Leaders Are Descending on Washington. Here’s What to Know

UP NEXT

Texas Residents Told to Expect Power Outages, Flooding as Beryl Moves Closer to Landfall

UP NEXT

To Save Spotted Owls, US Officials Plan to Kill Hundreds of Thousands of Another Owl Species

UP NEXT

Defense Secretary Austin Says the US Will Provide $2.3 Billion More in Military Aid to Ukraine

UP NEXT

Hunter Biden Sues Fox News Over Explicit Images Featured in a Streaming Series

UP NEXT

Officers Shoot 3 Coyotes at SF Botanical Garden Following Attack on 5-Year-Old Girl

A Packed Fresno City Hall Witnesses Badhesha’s Historic Moment for Sikhs

34 mins ago

The Embattled Biden Campaign Tests Kamala Harris’ Strength vs. Trump

39 mins ago

Emergency Workers Uncover Dozens of Bodies in a Gaza City District After Israeli Assault

56 mins ago

Destination Paris: Swimmer Ryan Murphy Longs to Reclaim Top Spot on Medal Podium at the Olympics

59 mins ago

These Picassos Prompted a Gender War at an Australian Gallery. Now the Curator Says She Painted Them

1 hour ago

Russian Passenger Jet Crashes Flying Empty Near Moscow, Killing Its Crew of 3

1 hour ago

Republicans Are Gathering in Milwaukee to Nominate Donald Trump Again. Here’s What to Expect

1 hour ago

Spain and England Meet in Euro 2024 Final but It Isn’t a Classic, Deep-Rooted International Rivalry

2 hours ago

Phillies Back Nola With 3 HRs, Finish 3-Game Sweep of Dodgers

2 hours ago

Father and Son Arrested in Connection with Mendota Homicide

2 hours ago

UC Merced Begins NCAA Division II Sports Competition in 2025-26 Season

UC Merced will commence NCAA Division II sports competition during the 2025-26 academic year and will be eligible for the postseason in 2026...

7 mins ago

7 mins ago

UC Merced Begins NCAA Division II Sports Competition in 2025-26 Season

18 mins ago

Bill Belichick Joining ‘Inside the NFL’ for Upcoming Season

19 mins ago

Alec Baldwin Trial Halted as Judge Reviews Defense Motion to Dismiss Due to Ammo Dispute

34 mins ago

A Packed Fresno City Hall Witnesses Badhesha’s Historic Moment for Sikhs

39 mins ago

The Embattled Biden Campaign Tests Kamala Harris’ Strength vs. Trump

56 mins ago

Emergency Workers Uncover Dozens of Bodies in a Gaza City District After Israeli Assault

59 mins ago

Destination Paris: Swimmer Ryan Murphy Longs to Reclaim Top Spot on Medal Podium at the Olympics

1 hour ago

These Picassos Prompted a Gender War at an Australian Gallery. Now the Curator Says She Painted Them

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend