Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fresno County Holds Off On PLA as City Sends Deal Back to Negotiating Table
Edward Smith updated website photo 2024
By Edward Smith
Published 9 seconds ago on
November 17, 2026

Construction workers install windows on a nearly completed office building in San Diego, California, U.S., October 9, 2024. (Reuters File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

With hundreds of millions of dollars in planned projects before them and a shrinking budget gap, Fresno County supervisors put off a decision on whether to require a project labor agreement for a new agricultural commissioner’s building, leaving it to the new board to decide in January.

Supervisors also said they want a better idea of what a PLA on that building would cost. Outgoing Supervisor Nathan Magsig said the county will likely have to “cannibalize” planned projects to pay for priority projects.

“The next board needs to figure out their priorities,” Magsig said.

The decision comes after the Fresno City Council sent labor groups and city administrators back to the negotiating table, demanding that they lower the proposed threshold for the renewed labor agreement to $2.75 million.

Both sides had said sticking with the $3.5 million figure would be best.

Fresno City Council member Miguel Arias, who initiated the decision to send the plan back to negotiations, said inflation doesn’t justify raising the threshold that far from the original $1 million agreed on in 2021.

“Going from $1 million to $3.5 million is a 250% increase, that, my friends, is not inflation,” Arias said.

PLAs Provide Opportunities to Apprentices, Riojas Says

At Tuesday’s board meeting, Supervisor Luis Chavez put forward a plan to begin negotiations on a PLA for the new agricultural commissioner’s building.

He said the plan would help workers getting their start in the construction field.

“I’ve seen firsthand what these apprenticeship programs do for our community,” Chavez said.

Chavez’s plan would have authorized Fresno County counsel and the county administrative office to begin negotiating with the Fresno Madera Tulare Kings Building Trades Council on a labor agreement for that building.

Chuck Riojas, secretary-treasurer of the trades council, said PLAs are tailored to the needs of each government that approves them. For instance, Fresno Unified prioritized graduates. The city of Fresno prioritized its residents, and Riojas said he imagined a county PLA would do the same for county residents.

He said the programs benefit underserved communities and help workers get their feet in the door.

“I don’t do it for union density, I don’t do it for contractors, I don’t do it for journeymen, it’s those apprenticeship opportunities,” Riojas said. “Those apprenticeship opportunities change people’s lives.”

County Faces Funding Uncertainty

The new agricultural commissioner’s building would be but one of many projects the county has to decide on soon. Over the past few months, staff have presented plans for a new sheriff’s headquarters, an administrative office and board chambers, and facilities for the public works departments and the public defender.

All told, the county has $426.5 million in projects before it, according to a September presentation. Already, however, supervisors are realizing they may be unable to complete all those projects.

The county is waiting to see how reductions in Medi-Cal coverage will affect budgets for the departments of public health, behavioral health, and social services.

Those costs could rise by hundreds of millions of dollars as the county picks up hospital bills for people cut off from Medi-Cal coverage.

Board Chair Garry Bredefeld said he prioritizes a new headquarters for the Fresno County Sheriff’s Department and a new boardroom for supervisors.

Supervisors agreed that the new board should decide its priorities because three of the five members are leaving. Supervisor Buddy Mendes is retiring, with former Sheriff Margaret Mims set to take his place at the beginning of the year.

Voters elected Supervisors Magsig and Brian Pacheco to the state Senate and Assembly, respectively.

Kerman Mayor Maria Pacheco will take Pacheco’s seat, and the county will have to hold a special election to fill Magsig’s seat.

PLAs Raise Costs and Exclude Workers, Opponents Say

Construction advocacy groups raised several objections to the PLA, saying such agreements increase project costs and exclude workers. Riojas said none of his PLAs are exclusive to union members.

Workers brought on to PLA projects have to pay union dues, said Fay Yassini, director of government affairs with the Associated Builders and Contractors Northern California Chapter.

“PLAs increase construction cost by 12% to 20%,” Yassini said.

Several groups opposed to PLAs said the agreements exclude too many workers.

Rex Hime, government relations director with Western Electrical Contractors, said PLAs would exclude apprentices in his program.

City Council Sends Trades and Administration Back to the Negotiating Table

The city of Fresno’s 2025-26 report shows the PLA fell short of its goals for apprentices and journeymen in all categories except for Fresno residents in the first year.

The PLA requires qualified Fresno residents to account for 50% of journeymen’s hours and 55% of apprentices’ hours. It sets a 30% target for new residents.

Because the trades council did not verify new apprentice hours, it listed 0% participation each year, according to Fresno data. The 2025 report showed the PLA fell short of journeymen targets in every prior year and missed apprentice targets in 2023-24 and 2024-25. It missed targets for new apprentices in 2023-24 but met them in 2022-23 and 2024-25.

Since initiating the PLA in 2021, Fresno has awarded 38 contracts and completed 19 of them. On Nov. 12, the Fresno City Council voted 6-1 to send the agreement back to negotiations, demanding that it apply to projects over $2.75 million.

Arias first proposed a $2.2 million threshold, while council members Nelson Esparza and Tyler Maxwell pushed for a $2.75 million floor.

Both Riojas and City Manager Georgeanne White said the parties were OK with the $3.5 million figure and that it took a year of negotiations to reach that agreement. White said most city projects that trigger PLA requirements exceed that figure anyway.

Maxwell thanked labor representatives for their willingness to negotiate.

“You guys have done so much to get people elected to City Council,” Maxwell said.

RELATED TOPICS:

Edward Smith,
Multimedia Journalist
Edward Smith began reporting for GV Wire in May 2023. His reporting career began at Fresno City College, graduating with an associate degree in journalism. After leaving school he spent the next six years with The Business Journal, doing research for the publication as well as covering the restaurant industry. Soon after, he took on real estate and agriculture beats, winning multiple awards at the local, state and national level. You can contact Edward at 559-440-8372 or at Edward.Smith@gvwire.com.
Send this to a friend