California prosecutors and the families of murder victims sued Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday over his move to commute all death sentences in the state, (Gabriela Bhaskar/The New York Times/File)
- Lawsuit asks the California Supreme Court to block Newsom’s mass commutation, allow time for the 548 death sentences to be reviewed individually.
- Some families of murder victims supported his decision and urged the court to move swiftly to approve commutations.
- Newsom has been a vocal opponent of the death penalty for decades. He called his decision a "righteous action."
Share
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
California prosecutors and the families of murder victims sued Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday over his move to commute all death sentences in the state, saying that it amounts to an abuse of power that must be stopped.
The lawsuit asks the California Supreme Court to block Newsom’s mass commutation and allow time for each of the state’s 548 death sentences to be reviewed individually.
This month, Newsom said he felt a moral obligation to convert all death sentences to life in prison, though he acknowledged that his decision would “anger and hurt some Californians.”
The suit, filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a nonprofit group focused on victims’ rights, alleges that Newsom violated laws requiring that prosecutors and victims’ survivors have input on whether a prisoner’s sentence should be reduced. The plaintiffs also argue that there are errors in some inmates’ criminal records that raise questions about whether the governor has the legal authority to reduce certain sentences.
Governor’s Power to Grant Clemency
Under California law, a governor may unilaterally commute the sentence of a prisoner who is convicted of a felony in a single case. However, the governor must seek approval from the state Supreme Court to reduce the sentences of inmates with convictions in multiple felony cases.
Newsom has sent a list of 382 prisoners with multiple convictions to the state Supreme Court, seeking approval to commute their sentences. The rest of the death sentences were for prisoners convicted in single cases, according to Newsom, allowing him to reduce sentences unilaterally.
But the lawsuit says that some of the prisoners on Newsom’s list of people with a single conviction might actually have more felony convictions and cannot have their sentences reduced without court approval. The plaintiffs asked the court to stop Newsom from granting clemency until the cases could be thoroughly vetted.
Everyone on California’s death row has been convicted of murder — and many of them committed especially grisly crimes. Some are serial killers, while others have kidnapped and murdered young children.
Some Families of Murder Victims Support Newsom
Surviving family members of murder victims held dueling news conferences last week over Newsom’s commutations. One group said that it supported his decision and urged the court to move swiftly to approve commutations. The relatives said that executions would not help them heal from their losses and said they would rather see the justice system deliver more support for survivors of violence.
The other group expressed deep anguish at the notion that their loved ones’ killers could receive mercy. The relatives blasted Newsom for disrespecting them and said his actions had opened up old wounds, causing them to lose faith in the finality they had sought from the justice system.
Associations representing district attorneys, police officers and crime survivors said in the lawsuit that California law does not allow a blanket commutation like the one Newsom is seeking. They say that one person does not have the power to overrule the judgment of thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges in one fell swoop.
“A mass clemency is inconsistent with a scheme designed to create a public process that ensures that all relevant information is considered regarding the individual crime and criminal,” the lawsuit says.
Other lawyers have argued that the governor has broad authority to grant clemency and that he may empty death row based on his moral opposition to capital punishment, regardless of the details of each case.
Newsom Opposes the Death Penalty
Newsom has been a vocal opponent of the death penalty for decades. In announcing his decision to commute all death sentences in the state, the governor said that he was taking a “righteous action” based on his personal beliefs.
“I am acting on my long and deeply held conviction that individually and collectively we are stronger as a society when we reject state-sanctioned killing,” Newsom wrote in a letter announcing his decision.
He said that the state constitution provided governors with clemency powers “for moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice.”
“For me, this is that moment,” he wrote.
Newsom’s request presents a novel situation for the state’s highest court.
When the court normally reviews a governor’s clemency request, it considers a specific prisoner’s fitness for clemency, including rehabilitation. This is the first time the California Supreme Court has been asked to approve hundreds of commutations at once based on a governor’s moral opposition to capital punishment, as opposed to the merits of an inmate’s specific circumstances.
The court has asked that opinions about Newsom’s commutation request be filed by Nov. 24. It must make a decision before he leaves office on Jan. 4.
—
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
By Laurel Rosenhall/Gabriela Bhaskar
c.2026 The New York Times Company





