Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Inside Trump’s Search for a Health Threat to Justify His Immigration Crackdown
d8a347b41db1ddee634e2d67d08798c102ef09ac
By The New York Times
Published 4 weeks ago on
January 9, 2025

President-Elect Donald Trump speaks to members of the press after paying his respects to former president Jimmy Carter and meeting with Senate GOP leadership iat the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Jan. 8, 2025. Trump’s advisers have spent months trying to find the right disease to build their case for closing the border. (Eric Lee/The New York Times)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

WASHINGTON — President-elect Donald Trump is likely to justify his plans to seal off the border with Mexico by citing a public health emergency from immigrants bringing disease into the United States.

Now he just has to find one.

Trump last invoked public health restrictions, known as Title 42, in the early days of the pandemic in 2020, when the coronavirus was tearing across the globe. As he prepares to enter office again, Trump has no such public health disaster to point to.

Still, his advisers have spent recent months trying to find the right disease to build their case, according to four people familiar with the discussions. They have looked at tuberculosis and other respiratory diseases as options and have asked allies inside the Border Patrol for examples of illnesses that are being detected among migrants.

Trying to Rationalize Title 42

They also have considered trying to rationalize Title 42 by arguing broadly that migrants at the border come from various countries and may carry unfamiliar disease — an assertion that echoes a racist notion with a long history in the United States that minorities transmit infections. Trump’s team did not respond to a request for comment.

The plan to invoke the border restrictions based on sporadic cases of illness or even a vague fear of illness — rather than a major disease outbreak or pandemic — would amount to a radical use of the public health measure in pursuit of an immigration crackdown. Even when the coronavirus was spreading, the use of the health authority to turn away migrants prompted scrutiny from the courts and public health officials.

But Trump’s immigration advisers, led by Stephen Miller, his pick to be deputy chief of staff, believe they are entering a political environment that will welcome more aggressive border enforcement, particularly after some Democrats embraced using restrictions like Title 42, according to people familiar with the planning. President Joe Biden used it to turn away thousands of migrants before eventually deciding to lift it, well after his public health advisers said the restrictions were no longer useful for the purpose of stopping the spread of disease.

Title 42, which is part of the Public Service Act of 1944, grants power to health authorities to block people from entering the United States when it is necessary to avert a “serious danger” posed by the presence of a communicable disease in foreign countries.

Miller has long considered Title 42 a key tool for his goal of shuttering the border to migration. He has essentially been on a yearslong quest to find enough examples of diseases among migrants to justify the use of the law.

Miller Asked Aides to Monitor COVID Spread

Even before the spread of the coronavirus, Miller asked aides to keep tabs on American communities that welcomed migrants to see if diseases broke out there. He seized on an outbreak of mumps in immigration detention facilities in 2019 to push for using the public health law to seal the border. He was talked down in most of the cases by Cabinet secretaries and lawyers — until the advent of the coronavirus.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, not the White House, is responsible for assessing whether the public health rule is necessary at the border. And even when the pandemic spread throughout the United States, CDC officials pushed back on the Trump White House’s position that turning away migrants was an effective way to prevent the spread of diseases.

Martin Cetron, director of the agency’s Division of Global Migration and Quarantine, told a House committee that the implementation of the border restrictions “came from outside the CDC subject matter experts” and was “handed to us” by the White House.

When Biden came into office, he initially kept the public health rule in place at the border, even when CDC officials told his top aides there was no clear public health rationale for keeping the border shut to asylum-seekers. Both the Biden and Trump administrations argued the rule was needed to prevent the spread of diseases in detention facilities at the border. But Biden’s top White House aides were privately concerned that lifting the rule would lead to a surge in migration.

Trump’s attempt to deter migration based on public health, even without a clear disease to justify its use, is just one expected piece of a flurry of Day 1 executive actions that his team is developing to crack down on immigration.

Trump’s Advisers Discussed Declaring National Emergency

Trump’s advisers have also discussed declaring a national emergency to free up Department of Defense funds and move military personnel, aircraft and other resources to the border. They also want to revive a policy that forced migrants to wait in Mexico, rather than the United States, until their immigration court date — although they would need Mexico to agree to such a deal.

Trump’s immigration advisers received a briefing on such border restrictions — as well as the use of the public health emergency restrictions — during a recent meeting with homeland security officials as a part of the transition between administrations, according to a person familiar with the matter. After exiting a meeting with Senate Republicans on Wednesday evening, Trump said he would close the border on his first day in office.

Some immigration experts have questioned how effective the public health rule was in driving down border crossings.

From the time Title 42 was enacted in 2020 until it was lifted in 2023, border officials expelled people more than 2.5 million times. Biden administration officials have publicly argued that the use of Title 42 at the southern border drove an increase in migrants attempting to cross the border multiple times, a practice known as recidivism.

Blas Nuñez-Neto, a White House official, said that in that way, Title 42 “may have” actually led to an increase in border crossings that the administration struggled to handle.

The current state at the border has been particularly calm, especially when compared with the numbers seen a year ago. Border agents made more than 47,000 arrests in December, according to a senior U.S. Customs and Border Protection official, a major drop from the previous year when nearly 250,000 such arrests were made.

Biden officials put into a place a measure banning asylum for those who crossed the southern border starting this summer. It can only be lifted if crossing numbers drop to a certain threshold for several weeks, something that still has yet to happen.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

By Zolan Kanno-Youngs and Hamed Aleaziz/Eric Lee
c. 2025 The New York Times Company

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Alaska Legislature Asks Trump to Retain Denali’s Name

DON'T MISS

Driver Facing DUI, Drug, and Gun Charges After Pursuit in Visalia

DON'T MISS

Flu Season in the US Is the Most Intense It’s Been in at Least 15 Years

DON'T MISS

Visalia Woman Sentenced to 5 Years for High-Speed Chase That Injured Officer

DON'T MISS

More Active Duty Troops Will Head to US-Mexico Border, Bringing the Total to 3,600

DON'T MISS

Police Search for Missing Fresno Man Last Seen in Bay Area

DON'T MISS

Martin, Pardoned for Jan. 6, Sent to Lompoc Prison on Gun Charge Conviction

DON'T MISS

Spring Training Preview: Dodgers Are Favored to Be MLB’s First Repeat Champion

DON'T MISS

With Immigrant Backgrounds, Vang, Leon Barraza Seek Fresno Council Seat

DON'T MISS

Justice Department Won’t Release Names of FBI Agents Who Worked on Jan. 6 Riot Cases

UP NEXT

Driver Facing DUI, Drug, and Gun Charges After Pursuit in Visalia

UP NEXT

Flu Season in the US Is the Most Intense It’s Been in at Least 15 Years

UP NEXT

Visalia Woman Sentenced to 5 Years for High-Speed Chase That Injured Officer

UP NEXT

More Active Duty Troops Will Head to US-Mexico Border, Bringing the Total to 3,600

UP NEXT

Police Search for Missing Fresno Man Last Seen in Bay Area

UP NEXT

Martin, Pardoned for Jan. 6, Sent to Lompoc Prison on Gun Charge Conviction

UP NEXT

Spring Training Preview: Dodgers Are Favored to Be MLB’s First Repeat Champion

UP NEXT

With Immigrant Backgrounds, Vang, Leon Barraza Seek Fresno Council Seat

UP NEXT

Justice Department Won’t Release Names of FBI Agents Who Worked on Jan. 6 Riot Cases

UP NEXT

Aliens, Sloths and Silliness: Super Bowl Ads Offer Laughs, Celebs and Surprises to Win Over Viewers

Visalia Woman Sentenced to 5 Years for High-Speed Chase That Injured Officer

1 hour ago

More Active Duty Troops Will Head to US-Mexico Border, Bringing the Total to 3,600

2 hours ago

Police Search for Missing Fresno Man Last Seen in Bay Area

2 hours ago

Martin, Pardoned for Jan. 6, Sent to Lompoc Prison on Gun Charge Conviction

2 hours ago

Spring Training Preview: Dodgers Are Favored to Be MLB’s First Repeat Champion

2 hours ago

With Immigrant Backgrounds, Vang, Leon Barraza Seek Fresno Council Seat

3 hours ago

Justice Department Won’t Release Names of FBI Agents Who Worked on Jan. 6 Riot Cases

4 hours ago

Aliens, Sloths and Silliness: Super Bowl Ads Offer Laughs, Celebs and Surprises to Win Over Viewers

4 hours ago

Mother Pleads for Britain’s Help in Freeing Son From Egyptian Prison

4 hours ago

Clean Energy Interests Shift Focus to Money and Jobs

4 hours ago

Alaska Legislature Asks Trump to Retain Denali’s Name

JUNEAU, Alaska  — The Alaska Legislature passed a resolution Friday urging President Donald Trump to reverse course and retain the name of N...

12 minutes ago

People stand at the Eielson Visitor Center with a view of North America's tallest peak, Denali, in the background, Sept. 2, 2015, in Denali National Park and Preserve, Alaska. (AP File)
12 minutes ago

Alaska Legislature Asks Trump to Retain Denali’s Name

A driver on probation was arrested for DUI, drug possession, and firearm charges following a pursuit that started on State Route 198 and ended in Visalia. (CHP)
40 minutes ago

Driver Facing DUI, Drug, and Gun Charges After Pursuit in Visalia

A flu vaccine is displayed at a pharmacy in New York, on Tuesday, Sept. 24, 2024. (AP File)
1 hour ago

Flu Season in the US Is the Most Intense It’s Been in at Least 15 Years

The damage to the Tulare police officer's vehicle during the incident. (Tulare County DA)
1 hour ago

Visalia Woman Sentenced to 5 Years for High-Speed Chase That Injured Officer

President Donald Trump listens during a news conference with Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba in the East Room of the White House, Friday, Feb. 7, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
2 hours ago

More Active Duty Troops Will Head to US-Mexico Border, Bringing the Total to 3,600

Authorities are searching for Hussein Ali, 65, of Fresno, last seen in Millbrae on Jan. 17, driving a black Kia Sorento. (Fresno PD)
2 hours ago

Police Search for Missing Fresno Man Last Seen in Bay Area

2 hours ago

Martin, Pardoned for Jan. 6, Sent to Lompoc Prison on Gun Charge Conviction

New Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Roki Sasaki poses during a a baseball news conference at Dodger Stadium Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2025 in Los Angeles. (AP File)
2 hours ago

Spring Training Preview: Dodgers Are Favored to Be MLB’s First Repeat Champion

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend