Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
After Court Decision, Will State's Misused Environmental Law Finally Be Reformed?
By admin
Published 1 year ago on
February 28, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

“Everybody talks about the weather but nobody does anything about it” is an old quip attributed – probably erroneously – to Mark Twain.

It could be legitimately applied to the California Environmental Quality Act, a 53-year-old law originally meant to prevent government agencies from ignoring the impacts of their public works projects but later expanded, mostly by judicial decisions, to private developments as well.

CEQA’s use, or misuse, as a weapon in the state’s perpetual battles over housing has been well documented. Opponents of housing projects in their neighborhoods use it to stall construction and labor unions use it to leverage developers into agreements to use union workers.

Former Gov. Jerry Brown decried such uses and said reforming CEQA is “the Lord’s work” but was an agnostic about doing it, apparently convinced that opposition from environmental groups and unions, two of the Democratic Party’s most influential allies, would make reform impossible.

Dan Walters with a serious expression

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

The Legislature has been willing to exempt specific projects, such as sports arenas, from the CEQA process, as well as some narrow categories of housing. But the broad reform that CEQA’s critics say is necessary has long been a non-starter.

The politics of CEQA may be changing.

Last year, the state Supreme Court decreed in a suit against the University of California, that expanding the number of students admitted to UC Berkeley was an environmental impact that had to be considered under CEQA. The decision would effectively have forced the university to turn away thousands of students it had planned to admit for the 2022-23 school year.

Powerful New CEQA Weapon

Moreover, the underlying concept of people as an impact would hand opponents of housing projects throughout the state a potentially powerful weapon.

The plaintiff in that suit was a local organization calling itself Save Berkeley’s Neighborhoods, which alleged that having more students would degrade the community’s ambiance – very similar to the opposition of local groups to state-imposed housing quotas.

The Legislature reacted with lightning speedpassing legislation declaring that college enrollment is not a “project” requiring mitigation under CEQA.

However, another group, Make UC a Good Neighbor, had also filed a CEQA suit challenging both UC Berkeley’s long-range development plan and a UC housing project in UC-owned People’s Park, the site of numerous anti-war demonstrations in the 1960s that today is mostly covered by homeless encampments.

Last week, a state appellate court rejected the challenge to UC’s development plan but declared that the People’s Park project needed more work and – more importantly – decreed that UC “failed to assess potential noise impacts from loud student parties in residential neighborhoods near the campus, a longstanding problem that the EIR improperly dismissed as speculative.”

If upheld by the state Supreme Court, the latter declaration would once again give NIMBY opponents to housing developments a powerful weapon. They could contend that housing for low-income families would bring noise or other undesirable impacts to their neighborhoods.

In a statement, Gov. Gavin Newsom tweeted, “A few wealthy Berkeley homeowners should not be able to block desperately needed student housing for years and even decades. CEQA needs to change and we are committed to working with the legislature so California can build more housing.”

It raises this question: How far are Newsom and the Legislature willing to go on CEQA reform?

They could write a narrow exemption as they did on the previous UC Berkeley case, they could make a wider change affecting CEQA’s effect on housing, or they could go whole hog and do a top-to-bottom overhaul of the law to return it to its original purpose before it was weaponized.

Words are cheap. Only actions count.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Provides Immunizations, Sports Physicals for Students

DON'T MISS

Who Is Carrying the Olympic Torch Through Paris? A BTS Star, a Garbage Collector and More

DON'T MISS

Sen. Bob Menendez Convicted in Trial That Featured Tales of Bribes Paid in Cash, Gold and a Car

DON'T MISS

Global Music Streams Are up in 2024. Latin Music Dominates and Multiple Releases of Same Album Sell

DON'T MISS

Gareth Southgate Says He Will Step Down as England Manager

DON'T MISS

At Least 70 People Killed in a Militia Attack in Western Congo

DON'T MISS

Bronny James Finishes With 2 Points, Lakers Lose to Celtics at Summer League

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Economic Plans Include Tariffs, Tax Cuts and No Taxes on Tips. Details Scarce.

DON'T MISS

5 Killed and Dozens Injured in Bangladesh in Violent Clashes Over Government Jobs Quota Scheme

DON'T MISS

Microsoft Faces UK Competition Investigation Over Hiring of AI Startup’s Founder and Key Staff

UP NEXT

Steve Garvey Visited Israel, but Will It Win Over California Voters in Senate Race Against Schiff?

UP NEXT

CA Lawmakers’ Safety Gets New Attention After Trump Shooting

UP NEXT

Republicans Will Regret a Second Trump Term

UP NEXT

The Deep Source of Trump’s Appeal

UP NEXT

When Progressive Ideals Become a Luxury

UP NEXT

John Roberts Makes His Bid for Infamy

UP NEXT

In Fire-Prone Mariposa, Residents Don’t Lose Sight of What Keeps Them There

UP NEXT

Smoking Laptop in Passenger’s Bag Prompts Evacuation on American Airlines Flight in San Francisco

UP NEXT

Quiq Labs Ongoing Camps Transform Summer Learning for Fresno Unified Students

UP NEXT

End of the Roar: Porsche Bids Farewell to the 718 Internal Combustion Engine

Global Music Streams Are up in 2024. Latin Music Dominates and Multiple Releases of Same Album Sell

17 mins ago

Gareth Southgate Says He Will Step Down as England Manager

60 mins ago

At Least 70 People Killed in a Militia Attack in Western Congo

1 hour ago

Bronny James Finishes With 2 Points, Lakers Lose to Celtics at Summer League

1 hour ago

Trump’s Economic Plans Include Tariffs, Tax Cuts and No Taxes on Tips. Details Scarce.

1 hour ago

5 Killed and Dozens Injured in Bangladesh in Violent Clashes Over Government Jobs Quota Scheme

1 hour ago

Microsoft Faces UK Competition Investigation Over Hiring of AI Startup’s Founder and Key Staff

1 hour ago

Israeli Military Says It Will Begin Drafting Ultra-Orthodox Men. That Could Rattle the Government

2 hours ago

Dodgers’ Teoscar Hernández Wins the Home Run Derby

2 hours ago

Border Arrests Plunge 29% in June to the Lowest of Biden’s Presidency as Asylum Halt Takes Hold

2 hours ago

Fresno Unified Provides Immunizations, Sports Physicals for Students

Fresno Unified has scheduled clinics this month and in August for parents to bring their children for immunizations and sports physicals. Al...

7 seconds ago

8 seconds ago

Fresno Unified Provides Immunizations, Sports Physicals for Students

21 seconds ago

Who Is Carrying the Olympic Torch Through Paris? A BTS Star, a Garbage Collector and More

15 mins ago

Sen. Bob Menendez Convicted in Trial That Featured Tales of Bribes Paid in Cash, Gold and a Car

17 mins ago

Global Music Streams Are up in 2024. Latin Music Dominates and Multiple Releases of Same Album Sell

60 mins ago

Gareth Southgate Says He Will Step Down as England Manager

1 hour ago

At Least 70 People Killed in a Militia Attack in Western Congo

1 hour ago

Bronny James Finishes With 2 Points, Lakers Lose to Celtics at Summer League

1 hour ago

Trump’s Economic Plans Include Tariffs, Tax Cuts and No Taxes on Tips. Details Scarce.

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend