Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Mad About Joe Rogan? Be Madder at Streaming Monopolies
Inside-Sources
By InsideSources.com
Published 2 years ago on
February 5, 2022

Share

 

The recent controversy about Spotify with Joe Rogan and Neil Young is only partly about disinformation and offensive content. It also illustrates how streaming monopolies are using market power to lock in consumers and artists by making it difficult to leave their platforms. And it shows the inherent problems that arise when distributors own and control exclusive content.

Alex Harman portrait

Alex Harman

InsideSources.com

Opinion

Let’s address the distribution issue first. Podcasts have long been essentially an open format. Anyone can create them, and anyone can distribute them. For as long as they’ve been around, people have been able to listen to pretty much any podcast through Apple, Spotify, or any number of podcast apps.

Spotify challenged this open standard by bringing in Joe Rogan as exclusive content to attract more subscribers and lock in existing ones. The problem is that Joe Rogan’s show is no longer a generally available podcast. It’s now a Spotify-only streaming talk show.

In other words, Spotify removed Rogan’s show from an open and democratized way of sharing ideas and viewpoints, and restricted access to only Spotify customers. The issue is not whether users have to pay; it’s that the show is only available from a single, dominant corporate distributor.

Problematic Model for Video Streaming

It’s an expansion of the already problematic model for video streaming, where content is now owned by distributors exclusively and in perpetuity — the way Netflix owns “House of Cards” and Disney+ owns the “Star Wars” and Marvel movies. And the long-term consequences of this are not great for podcasts.

If Joe Rogan’s show was still an open format podcast, Neil Young wouldn’t have anything to complain about to Spotify, because the streaming service would just be a pass-through for a podcast available anywhere. That Joe Rogan’s show is exclusive content is why Spotify has suddenly found itself in the uncomfortable position of having to navigate ultimatums about removing music from its service.

The problem boils down to market power. Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, Nils Young, India. Arie, and Crosby, Stills and Nash are among the rare artists who have the fame, financial success, and freedom to say they do not need to be on Spotify. But most artists don’t have this luxury. They are totally dependent on Spotify and a few other platforms to reach listeners.

On the other end is users. It’s understandable why people don’t want to pay those who spread deadly misinformation. Users, arguably more easily than artists, can walk away from Spotify to another service in protest.

Spotify Locks in Its Users

But walking away means users lose their favorite songs, artists, albums, and playlists, as well as any other customizations they’ve created. While user data can be downloaded into a spreadsheet, it’s still quite difficult to export one’s music collection and listening preferences to another service. Good luck figuring out how to play Rihanna in Microsoft Excel!

In this way, Spotify has users locked in just like artists. For both, streaming services are designed to be anticompetitive — making it that much harder for new competitors to emerge.

User data on platforms like Spotify should be portable to other services. Exclusively produced content should not be owned and controlled by a single streaming platform with gatekeeping power — whether it’s Spotify, Netflix, Disney+, or any of the rest.

Competition for subscribers should be around the user experience. If Spotify provides users with an interface they enjoy, sound quality and audio enhancements they like, suggested content they find relevant, and a price they find acceptable, then people will choose Spotify. Those are the terms on which streaming services should compete.

Locking in users by making it difficult, cumbersome, or painful to leave and locking in content that is not available elsewhere are both exactly the wrong way to compete. This can and should be prohibited by law.

Legislation that would establish data portability and interoperability requirements has been introduced in Congress and could be made applicable to platforms like Spotify to make it easier for users to pick the service of their choice without giving up their data.

If users were easily able to walk away from Spotify, they could join Neil Young in opposition to Joe Rogan. If Joe Rogan was just another open format podcast, Spotify would not be the target of outrage over his content. And if both were true, consumers, artists, and podcast creators all would be better off.

About the Author

Alex Harman is the competition policy advocate for Public Citizen. He wrote this for InsideSources.com.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

NATO Strengthens Defense Against Russia with 500K Troops Ready to Deploy

DON'T MISS

Harris Claims Most of the Delegates She Needs for the Nomination, Raises $81 Million in 24 Hours

DON'T MISS

Kamala Harris Turns to Selecting a Possible Vice President

DON'T MISS

Israel Orders Evacuation of Part of Humanitarian Zone as War’s Toll Passes 39,000 Palestinians

DON'T MISS

Merced County Employees Vote to Authorize Strike Amid Budget Crisis

DON'T MISS

CHSU Students Build Book Exchange Libraries for Underserved Communities

DON'T MISS

The Cybertruck: A Culture War on Wheels

DON'T MISS

Cal State Trustees Weigh Bid to Merge Cal Maritime, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo

DON'T MISS

A ‘Token’ Officer? Ex-Black Female Cop Files Discrimination Lawsuit Against Fresno PD

DON'T MISS

Biden Shepherded Europe on Ukraine and NATO. What Happens Now?

UP NEXT

Harris Claims Most of the Delegates She Needs for the Nomination, Raises $81 Million in 24 Hours

UP NEXT

Kamala Harris Turns to Selecting a Possible Vice President

UP NEXT

Israel Orders Evacuation of Part of Humanitarian Zone as War’s Toll Passes 39,000 Palestinians

UP NEXT

Merced County Employees Vote to Authorize Strike Amid Budget Crisis

UP NEXT

CHSU Students Build Book Exchange Libraries for Underserved Communities

UP NEXT

The Cybertruck: A Culture War on Wheels

UP NEXT

Cal State Trustees Weigh Bid to Merge Cal Maritime, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo

UP NEXT

A ‘Token’ Officer? Ex-Black Female Cop Files Discrimination Lawsuit Against Fresno PD

UP NEXT

Biden Shepherded Europe on Ukraine and NATO. What Happens Now?

UP NEXT

Ukraine Strikes Preliminary $20 Billion Debt Restructuring Deal

Israel Orders Evacuation of Part of Humanitarian Zone as War’s Toll Passes 39,000 Palestinians

2 hours ago

Merced County Employees Vote to Authorize Strike Amid Budget Crisis

2 hours ago

CHSU Students Build Book Exchange Libraries for Underserved Communities

3 hours ago

The Cybertruck: A Culture War on Wheels

3 hours ago

Cal State Trustees Weigh Bid to Merge Cal Maritime, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo

4 hours ago

A ‘Token’ Officer? Ex-Black Female Cop Files Discrimination Lawsuit Against Fresno PD

4 hours ago

Biden Shepherded Europe on Ukraine and NATO. What Happens Now?

4 hours ago

Ukraine Strikes Preliminary $20 Billion Debt Restructuring Deal

4 hours ago

Summer Yo-Yo Brings Extreme Heat Back to Fresno. Will There Be a Weekend Cooldown?

4 hours ago

JD Vance Makes Solo Debut as GOP Vice Presidential Nominee With Monday Rallies in Ohio and Virginia

5 hours ago

NATO Strengthens Defense Against Russia with 500K Troops Ready to Deploy

In response to the escalating threat from Russia, NATO has undergone a significant transformation in its collective defense strategy. Accord...

23 mins ago

23 mins ago

NATO Strengthens Defense Against Russia with 500K Troops Ready to Deploy

24 mins ago

Harris Claims Most of the Delegates She Needs for the Nomination, Raises $81 Million in 24 Hours

31 mins ago

Kamala Harris Turns to Selecting a Possible Vice President

2 hours ago

Israel Orders Evacuation of Part of Humanitarian Zone as War’s Toll Passes 39,000 Palestinians

2 hours ago

Merced County Employees Vote to Authorize Strike Amid Budget Crisis

3 hours ago

CHSU Students Build Book Exchange Libraries for Underserved Communities

3 hours ago

The Cybertruck: A Culture War on Wheels

4 hours ago

Cal State Trustees Weigh Bid to Merge Cal Maritime, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend