Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Closer to First-in-US Rules on Police Shootings
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 6 years ago on
April 9, 2019

Share

SACRAMENTO โ€” A grieving mother choked up as she questioned why police didnโ€™t use other tactics instead of killing her son. A deputy recalled the terror of second-guessing herself as she traded fire with a suspect who killed her partner.

โ€œItโ€™s time to make clear that the sanctity of human life is policingโ€™s highest priority. [The proposal] is designed to change the culture of policing in California.โ€ โ€” Democratic Assemblywoman Shirley Weber of San Diego
The emotional testimony Tuesday came before California lawmakers advanced a first-in-the-nation measure restricting when police can use deadly force, one of two radically different legislative proposals seeking to cut down on deadly shootings in the nationโ€™s most populous state.
The measure faces a tougher fight in the full Assembly. Even some supporters on the public safety committee said it goes too far and will require changes as lawmakers try to balance the safety of officers and those theyโ€™re tasked with protecting.
Last yearโ€™s police shooting of unarmed vandalism suspect Stephon Clark in Sacramento inspired the legislation that would allow officers to kill only if there is no reasonable alternative, such as verbal persuasion or other non-lethal methods of resolution or de-escalation.
โ€œItโ€™s time to make clear that the sanctity of human life is policingโ€™s highest priority,โ€ said Democratic Assemblywoman Shirley Weber of San Diego, adding later that her proposal โ€œis designed to change the culture of policing in California.โ€
The committeeโ€™s chairman, Democratic Assemblyman Reggie Jones-Sawyer of Los Angeles, said a tougher standard will do little good without buy-in from law enforcement organizations.
Those groups are supporting a different plan, which is also before lawmakers, to require that every department have policies on when officers should use de-escalation tactics and other alternatives to deadly force.

Escobedo Says That Los Angeles Officers Could Have Used Other Tactics

Weberโ€™s measure got party-line support. The eight-member panelโ€™s two Republicans opposed the measure they said could make officers hesitate for a fatal second if they have to consider alternatives to lethal force.
Thatโ€™s what Sacramento County Deputy Sheriff Julie Robertson faced. She testified how her partner, Mark Stasyuk, died last fall during a gunfight and she hesitated as the suspect shot at her with only his back exposed.
โ€œI recall in that moment thinking that if I were to shoot him in the back, I would be the next officer in the news being scrutinized for my actions,โ€ Robertson said. โ€œThe thought of having to second-guess my actions in that moment is frightening. โ€ฆ This bill makes me wonder if sacrificing everything is worth it.โ€
Elizabeth Medrano Escobedo told lawmakers that Los Angeles officers could have used other tactics instead of killing her son, Christian Escobedo, last year. Police said he was sleeping behind a parked car with a loaded handgun.
โ€œThis bill can save mothers from grieving the loss of their children, which is what Iโ€™m experiencing right now,โ€ Medrano said, choking up.
Ciara Hamilton testified how Barstow police killed her cousin, Diante Yarber, last year after they said the car theft suspect hit two squad cars and nearly struck an officer. His family says the car was barely moving and that Yarber, who was black, might have lived had officers provided immediate medical attention.
โ€œWhat does that tell us about policing in California and America? Itโ€™s that black and brown people are not safe from state-sanctioned violence,โ€ Hamilton said.
The debate resonated personally for lawmakers.

Law Enforcement Groups Plan to Amend the Legislation

Democratic Assemblywoman Sydney Kamlager-Dove of Los Angeles tearfully recounted finding four officers in her home responding to a false burglar alarm last fall. They treated her respectfully, yet Kamlager-Dove, who is black, said she started shaking and crying.
โ€œAnd I realized I was crying because I was afraid. I didnโ€™t want to make any sudden movements,โ€ she said.

โ€œWhen peace officers are placed in a position to where they feel like they have to use deadly force, no one can really understand that unless youโ€™ve been in that position.โ€ โ€” Republican Assemblyman Tom Lackey of Palmdale
Kamlager-Dove broke down as she urged police organizations and reformers to reach consensus โ€œbecause this hurts. โ€ฆ I donโ€™t want any of us to live in fear.โ€
Republican Assemblyman Tom Lackey of Palmdale, who spent 28 years as a highway patrolman, recalled how a fellow officer killed someone in the line of duty and eventually ended his own life.
โ€œWhen peace officers are placed in a position to where they feel like they have to use deadly force, no one can really understand that unless youโ€™ve been in that position,โ€ Lackey said.
Plumas County Sheriffโ€™s Deputy Ed Obayashi, a use-of-force expert, called Weberโ€™s measure โ€œan exercise in legal futilityโ€ because he predicts judges will interpret the language the same way they do court rulings. Prosecutors would have to prove an officer was criminally negligent, which carries a high legal burden.
Weber acknowledges officers would have to egregiously violate a policy to face charges but expects the standard would deter shootings.
A Senate committee is expected to consider a police-backed alternative in two weeks. That measure would enshrine court standards into law, allowing officers to use deadly force when they have a reasonable fear of being harmed. The standard has made it rare for officers to be charged and rarer still to be convicted.
Law enforcement groups plan to amend the legislation โ€œto ensure that we are truly putting forward the most comprehensive legislative solution to effectively reduce the use of force in our state,โ€ California Police Chiefs Association president Ron Lawrence said.

DON'T MISS

California Just Blew Its First Deadline for Voter-Approved Healthcare Measure

UP NEXT

Lakers Hold Off Rockets With 6 3-Pointers Apiece From Dorian Finney-Smith, Gabe Vincent

A Palestinian From the West Bank Is First Detainee Under 18 to Die in Israeli Prison, Officials Say

2 hours ago

How Safe Is It to Walk to School? Fresno County Wants to Find Out

2 hours ago

California Just Blew Its First Deadline for Voter-Approved Healthcare Measure

This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters. California voters told lawmakers last fall that they wante...

30 minutes ago

30 minutes ago

California Just Blew Its First Deadline for Voter-Approved Healthcare Measure

Nassau Hall at Princeton University is in Princeton, N.J., Oct. 8, 2024. (AP File)
34 minutes ago

Trump Administration Halts Dozens of Research Grants at Princeton University

After 31 years of service, Fresno County Sheriffโ€™s Deputy IV and Pilot Michael Sill is retiring, having logged over 10,000 flight hours.
1 hour ago

Fresno County Sheriffโ€™s Pilot Takes His Last Flight as He Retires After 31 Years of Service

Khalid Ahmad holds a poster of his 17-year-old son, Waleed, who died in an Israeli prison, that reads in Arabic, "The hero prisoner Martyr, mercy and eternity for our righteous Martyrs," in the West Bank town of Silwad, northeast of Ramallah Wednesday, March 26, 2025. (AP/Nasser Nasser)
2 hours ago

A Palestinian From the West Bank Is First Detainee Under 18 to Die in Israeli Prison, Officials Say

2 hours ago

How Safe Is It to Walk to School? Fresno County Wants to Find Out

2 hours ago

Baseball Is Back! How to Listen to Your MLB Favorites and the Grizzlies

Vehicles at an Audi showroom in Miami, March 29, 2025. President Donald Trump has said that tariffs would encourage auto companies and their suppliers to move to the U.S. (Saul Martinez/The New York Times)
3 hours ago

Trump Says Heโ€™s Settled on a Tariff Plan That Is Set to Take Effect Wednesday

Vehicles are passed through final inspection at the end of the assembly line at the General Motors facility in Spring Hill, Tenn., Oct. 7, 2024. Sales of cars picked up recently partly as buyers rushed to lock in deals before President Trumpโ€™s 25 percent tariffs on cars and auto parts go into effect. (Brett Carlsen/The New York Times)
3 hours ago

Auto Sales Surged in Anticipation of Trumpโ€™s Tariffs

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend