Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
The Supreme Court Upholds a Tax on Foreign Income Over a Challenge Backed by Business Interests
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 1 week ago on
June 20, 2024

The Supreme Court's recent decision on a tax law involving foreign income has left many wondering about its broader implications. (AP/Jose Luis Magana)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld a tax on foreign income over a challenge backed by business and anti-regulatory interests, declining their invitation to weigh in on a broader, never-enacted tax on wealth.

The justices, by a 7-2 vote, left in place a provision of a 2017 tax law that is expected to generate $340 billion, mainly from the foreign subsidiaries of domestic corporations that parked money abroad to shield it from U.S. taxes.

The law, passed by a Republican Congress and signed by then-President Donald Trump, includes a provision that applies to companies that are owned by Americans but do their business in foreign countries. It imposes a one-time tax on investors’ shares of profits that have not been passed along to them, to offset other tax benefits.

But the larger significance of the ruling is what it didn’t do. The case attracted outsize attention because some groups allied with the Washington couple who brought the case argued that the challenged provision is similar to a wealth tax, which would apply not to the incomes of the very richest Americans but to their assets, like stock holdings. Such assets now get taxed only when they are sold.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote in his majority opinion that “nothing in this opinion should be read to authorize any hypothetical congressional effort to tax both an entity and its shareholders or partners on the same undistributed income realized by the entity.”

Underscoring the limited nature of the court’s ruling, Kavanaugh said as he read a summary of his opinion in the courtroom, “the precise and very narrow question” of the 2017 law “is the only question we answer.”

The Case of Charles and Kathleen Moore

The court ruled in the case of Charles and Kathleen Moore, of Redmond, Washington. They challenged a $15,000 tax bill based on Charles Moore’s investment in an Indian company, arguing that the tax violates the 16th Amendment. Ratified in 1913, the amendment allows the federal government to impose an income tax on Americans. Moore said in a sworn statement that he never received any money from the company, KisanKraft Machine Tools Private Ltd.

Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch, wrote in dissent that the Moores paid taxes on an investment “that never yielded them a penny.” Under the 16th Amendment, Thomas wrote, the only income that can be taxed is “income realized by the taxpayer.”

A ruling for the Moores could have called into question other provisions of the tax code and threatened losses to the U.S. Treasury of several trillion dollars, Kavanaugh noted, echoing the argument made by the Biden administration.

Ethical Concerns and Questions

The case also had kicked up ethical concerns and raised questions about the story the Moores’ lawyers told in court filings. Justice Samuel Alito rejected calls from Senate Democrats to step away from the case because of his ties to David Rivkin, a lawyer who is representing the Moores.

Alito voted with the majority, but did not join Kavanaugh’s opinion. Instead, he joined a separate opinion written by Justice Amy Coney Barrett. Barrett wrote that the issues in the case are more complicated than Kavanaugh suggests.

Public documents show that Charles Moore’s involvement with the company, including serving as a director for five years, is far more extensive than court filings indicate.

The case is Moore v. U.S., 22-800.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Baby Cousin with Cancer Inspires Girls to Sew Hospital Gowns for Sick Kids Worldwide

DON'T MISS

High Interest Rates Are Hitting Poorer Americans the Hardest

DON'T MISS

Sunshine Found: A Tale of Two Furry Friends

DON'T MISS

Comedy Legend Martin Mull, Star of ‘Roseanne’ and ‘Arrested Development,’ Dies at 80

DON'T MISS

10,669 Acre Fresno June Lightning Complex Fires at 42% Containment, CalFire Reports

DON'T MISS

Urban Legends: The Creepiest Stories from Major Cities Around the World

DON'T MISS

Who Are the Wealthiest California Legislators? Good Question.

DON'T MISS

The Weirdest Pickle Combos You Have to Try

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Intensify Efforts Against Impaired Driving

DON'T MISS

New AD Garrett Klassy Aims to Brand the Bulldogs as the ‘Work & Grit’ Teams

UP NEXT

High Interest Rates Are Hitting Poorer Americans the Hardest

UP NEXT

Sunshine Found: A Tale of Two Furry Friends

UP NEXT

Comedy Legend Martin Mull, Star of ‘Roseanne’ and ‘Arrested Development,’ Dies at 80

UP NEXT

10,669 Acre Fresno June Lightning Complex Fires at 42% Containment, CalFire Reports

UP NEXT

Urban Legends: The Creepiest Stories from Major Cities Around the World

UP NEXT

The Weirdest Pickle Combos You Have to Try

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Intensify Efforts Against Impaired Driving

UP NEXT

New AD Garrett Klassy Aims to Brand the Bulldogs as the ‘Work & Grit’ Teams

UP NEXT

Fresno County Traffic Stop Leads to 262 Pound Crystal Meth Bust

UP NEXT

One of Fresno’s Biggest Names in Fighting Opioid Addiction Sued for $126K

Comedy Legend Martin Mull, Star of ‘Roseanne’ and ‘Arrested Development,’ Dies at 80

12 hours ago

10,669 Acre Fresno June Lightning Complex Fires at 42% Containment, CalFire Reports

12 hours ago

Urban Legends: The Creepiest Stories from Major Cities Around the World

15 hours ago

Who Are the Wealthiest California Legislators? Good Question.

16 hours ago

The Weirdest Pickle Combos You Have to Try

16 hours ago

Fresno Police Intensify Efforts Against Impaired Driving

1 day ago

New AD Garrett Klassy Aims to Brand the Bulldogs as the ‘Work & Grit’ Teams

1 day ago

Fresno County Traffic Stop Leads to 262 Pound Crystal Meth Bust

1 day ago

One of Fresno’s Biggest Names in Fighting Opioid Addiction Sued for $126K

1 day ago

Your Guide to July 4th Fireworks Displays Throughout the Valley

1 day ago

Baby Cousin with Cancer Inspires Girls to Sew Hospital Gowns for Sick Kids Worldwide

FREEHOLD, N.J. — Fighting brain cancer, little Giada Demma was lying in her pediatric hospital bed, her tiny body virtually swimming in a dr...

9 hours ago

9 hours ago

Baby Cousin with Cancer Inspires Girls to Sew Hospital Gowns for Sick Kids Worldwide

Photo of coins and % sign
12 hours ago

High Interest Rates Are Hitting Poorer Americans the Hardest

12 hours ago

Sunshine Found: A Tale of Two Furry Friends

12 hours ago

Comedy Legend Martin Mull, Star of ‘Roseanne’ and ‘Arrested Development,’ Dies at 80

12 hours ago

10,669 Acre Fresno June Lightning Complex Fires at 42% Containment, CalFire Reports

15 hours ago

Urban Legends: The Creepiest Stories from Major Cities Around the World

16 hours ago

Who Are the Wealthiest California Legislators? Good Question.

16 hours ago

The Weirdest Pickle Combos You Have to Try

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend