Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Kings County Growers Celebrate 'Monumental Win' in Water Fight With State
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 2 months ago on
September 17, 2024

Judge blasts state water officials for overreach in penalizing Kings County managers over groundwater protection. (CalMatters/CatchLight Local/Larry Valenzuela)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

In a scathing ruling, a Superior Court judge has lambasted state water officials for going too far and invoking “underground regulations” when they penalized Kings County water managers for failing to protect overpumped groundwater in the San Joaquin Valley.

Author Profile Picture

Rachel Becker

CalMatters

Kings County Superior Court Judge Kathy Ciuffini last week granted a preliminary injunction that bars the State Water Resources Control Board from requiring growers to pay fees and report how much water they pump from the county’s severely overdrawn aquifers. The injunction could last through a trial, which has not yet been scheduled.

“Clearly the actions of this state agency have not been transparent, are only known to the (water board), and there has been no review, analysis, or ability to challenge their conduct,” Ciuffini wrote in her decision. She added that the agency failed to show how an injunction from the court “would cause specific, identifiable harm to the public.”

Brought by the Kings County Farm Bureau and other growers, the lawsuit challenges the state’s decision to designate the severely depleted basin as “probationary,” which triggers fees and monitoring requirements.

Judge Says Regulations ‘Unlawful’

The judge sided with growers’ claims that the board relied on “unlawful” and “underground” regulations when it placed the basin on probation. The state water board “had over 10 years to adopt regulations for state intervention but failed to do so. As to this unlawful regulation, the plaintiffs will prevail on the merits of their claim,” she wrote.

The groundwater basin, located in the San Joaquin Valley, serves a vast expanse of dairies, ranches and farms — including those controlled by agricultural giants J.G. Boswell Company and Bay Area developer John Vidovich — as well as disadvantaged communities.

Edward Ortiz, a spokesperson for the water board, said the agency is “considering further legal options,” noting that the state needs to protect its oversight over “critically overdrafted basins.”

“All Californians benefit when groundwater is managed sustainably. Groundwater makes up a significant portion of the state’s water supply and serves as a critical buffer against the impacts of drought and climate change,” said Ortiz. He said the law is clear and that the board has the authority it needs to protect groundwater.

The decision grants a substantial respite for growers in the basin, who were facing a state mandate to install meters on their wells and pay fees of $300 per well and $20 for every acre foot of groundwater they pump.

10th Anniversary of SGMA

This week marks the 10th anniversary of the state’s landmark Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, which aims to stop dry wells, sinking earth and other consequences of over-pumping groundwater.

“Clearly the actions of this state agency have not been transparent, are only known to the (water board), and there has been no review, analysis, or ability to challenge their conduct.”

KATHY CIUFFINI, Kings County Superior Court Judge

Under the law, local groundwater agencies must develop a plan to rein in groundwater depletion by 2040 in the state’s most severely overtapped basins. But state officials said the Kings County agencies failed to submit revisions to its plan by an April deadline, despite multiple warnings that the plan had serious deficiencies and would “allow substantial impacts to people who rely on domestic wells for drinking, bathing, food preparation, and cleaning.”

A staff analysis reported that hundreds of groundwater wells could go dry, groundwater contamination could increase and that roads, canals and more would be damaged as the land continues to sink from overpumping.

So, in an unprecedented decision, the water board put the Kings County groundwater managers on probation — which imposes new fees and requirements to monitor pumping in a first step toward taking control of the basin.

The Kings County Farm Bureau and local growers sued, calling the decision unlawful. They said that the agency was slow to notify landowners of the new requirements and that the board’s deadlines for installing meters on their wells were hitting them during peak irrigation season.

This injunction reinforces and extends a temporary restraining order issued in July.

“Unmonitored groundwater pumping causes all kinds of harms, and stopping those harms is the reason why (the law) got enacted.”

DAVE OWEN, University of California College of the Law, San Francisco

Farm Bureau Director: a ‘Monumental Win’

Dusty Ference, executive director of the farm bureau, called the decision a “monumental win” that “highlights the validity of our claims.”

Karrigan Börk, a law professor and interim director of the UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences, said that the injunction is “likely to be a small speed bump” in the implementation of the state’s groundwater law.

Legal experts noted that the 33-page decision sides heavily with the growers.

“There’s a striking contrast between the court’s detailed and sympathetic repetition of the plaintiffs’ claimed facts and its cursory dismissals of the (state water board’s) factual claims,” said Dave Owen, a professor at the University of California College of the Law, San Francisco.

“Those arguments weren’t crazy. Unmonitored groundwater pumping causes all kinds of harms, and stopping those harms is the reason why (the law) got enacted,” Owen said.

The injunction comes as state water officials are considering probation for another San Joaquin Valley basin tomorrow.

But Karrigan Börk, a law professor and interim director of the UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences, said that the injunction is “likely to be a small speed bump” in the implementation of the state’s groundwater law.

“Ultimately, this lawsuit is just pushing off the inevitable,” he said. “It’s impossible to argue that the subbasin isn’t critically overdrafted, and ultimately that has to end.”

About the Author

Rachel Becker is a journalist reporting on California’s complex water challenges and water policy issues for CalMatters. She’s covered drought, water standoffs, groundwater depletion, water quality and the world’s biggest dam removal.

About CalMatters

CalMatters is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom committed to explaining California policy and politics.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

As Atmospheric River Soaks California, Farmworkers Await Flood Aid Promised in 2023

DON'T MISS

Sacramento Region Gained People but Flubbed Economic Opportunities Over 50 Years

DON'T MISS

Nations at UN Climate Talks Agree on $300B a Year for Poor Countries in a Compromise Deal

DON'T MISS

What to Know About Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Trump’s Pick for Labor Secretary

DON'T MISS

What to Know About Scott Turner, Trump’s Pick for Housing Secretary

DON'T MISS

Trump Taps Investor Scott Bessent as Treasury Secretary

DON'T MISS

NATO Head and Trump Meet in Florida for Talks on Global Security

DON'T MISS

Why Cranberry Sauce Is America’s Least Favorite Thanksgiving Dish – and 5 Creative Ways to Use It

DON'T MISS

‘Get Somebody Else to Do It’: Trump Resistance Encounters Fatigue

DON'T MISS

Anti-Vax Activists Dominate RFK Jr.’s HHS Transition Team

UP NEXT

Sacramento Region Gained People but Flubbed Economic Opportunities Over 50 Years

UP NEXT

Nations at UN Climate Talks Agree on $300B a Year for Poor Countries in a Compromise Deal

UP NEXT

What to Know About Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Trump’s Pick for Labor Secretary

UP NEXT

What to Know About Scott Turner, Trump’s Pick for Housing Secretary

UP NEXT

Trump Taps Investor Scott Bessent as Treasury Secretary

UP NEXT

NATO Head and Trump Meet in Florida for Talks on Global Security

UP NEXT

Why Cranberry Sauce Is America’s Least Favorite Thanksgiving Dish – and 5 Creative Ways to Use It

UP NEXT

‘Get Somebody Else to Do It’: Trump Resistance Encounters Fatigue

UP NEXT

Anti-Vax Activists Dominate RFK Jr.’s HHS Transition Team

UP NEXT

Wing ‘Wizard’ Harry Potter to Play for Australia’s Rugby Team. Let the Puns Begin.

What to Know About Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Trump’s Pick for Labor Secretary

15 hours ago

What to Know About Scott Turner, Trump’s Pick for Housing Secretary

20 hours ago

Trump Taps Investor Scott Bessent as Treasury Secretary

20 hours ago

NATO Head and Trump Meet in Florida for Talks on Global Security

21 hours ago

Why Cranberry Sauce Is America’s Least Favorite Thanksgiving Dish – and 5 Creative Ways to Use It

1 day ago

‘Get Somebody Else to Do It’: Trump Resistance Encounters Fatigue

1 day ago

Anti-Vax Activists Dominate RFK Jr.’s HHS Transition Team

1 day ago

Wing ‘Wizard’ Harry Potter to Play for Australia’s Rugby Team. Let the Puns Begin.

1 day ago

Tulare County Man Arrested After Allegedly Threatening to Kill Middle School Girls, Staff

1 day ago

Two Fresno, Clovis Trustee Races Remain Tight. Bond Measures Passing with Growing Margins

1 day ago

As Atmospheric River Soaks California, Farmworkers Await Flood Aid Promised in 2023

Floodwaters devastated the small communities of Pajaro and Planada in early 2023. California gave each town $20 million to recover – but as ...

43 minutes ago

43 minutes ago

As Atmospheric River Soaks California, Farmworkers Await Flood Aid Promised in 2023

1 hour ago

Sacramento Region Gained People but Flubbed Economic Opportunities Over 50 Years

13 hours ago

Nations at UN Climate Talks Agree on $300B a Year for Poor Countries in a Compromise Deal

15 hours ago

What to Know About Lori Chavez-DeRemer, Trump’s Pick for Labor Secretary

20 hours ago

What to Know About Scott Turner, Trump’s Pick for Housing Secretary

20 hours ago

Trump Taps Investor Scott Bessent as Treasury Secretary

21 hours ago

NATO Head and Trump Meet in Florida for Talks on Global Security

1 day ago

Why Cranberry Sauce Is America’s Least Favorite Thanksgiving Dish – and 5 Creative Ways to Use It

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend