Google has reached an agreement with California lawmakers to contribute to a $250 million fund over five years to support news outlets in the state. This marks America’s first newsroom funding agreement, but it’s already facing criticism from various quarters.

The deal, which emerged from complex negotiations spanning over a year, aims to address the financial struggles of the news industry. Assemblymember Buffy Wicks, who spearheaded the effort, sees it as a positive step. “I think I’m dealing with the art of the possible,” Wicks said. “This represents, to me, the best case scenario for the moment we’re in.”

Journalist Union and Publishers Raise Concerns Over Google Deal

However, not everyone shares her optimism. The Media Guild of the West, a journalist union that had supported Wicks’ initial efforts, criticized the agreement. Matt Pearce, the union’s president, called it “a total rout,” arguing that it fails to challenge Google’s dominance over newsrooms.

The California News Publishers Association offered lukewarm support, describing the deal as a “first step” towards a sustainable business model for journalism. However, concerns persist about the adequacy of funding, particularly for local media outlets.

Related Story: Google Loses Massive Antitrust Case Over Its Search Dominance

Google Shifts Stance After Intense Negotiations

Google, which had previously spent over $1.1 million on an ad campaign against the proposed legislation, agreed to the terms after intense negotiations. The tech giant had even temporarily blocked news access for some California consumers earlier this year, mirroring tactics used in other countries considering similar policies.

The debate surrounding the bill highlighted the ongoing struggle to revitalize an industry that has lost thousands of jobs in recent years. While supporters argue that online platforms have contributed to the decline of newsrooms by siphoning off advertising revenue, tech companies maintain that they have already provided substantial assistance to the news industry.

As the dust settles on this landmark agreement, questions remain about its long-term impact on the future of journalism in California and beyond.

Read more at Politico