Opinion

Did Newsom Dig a New Hole With Appointment of Senate Replacement for Feinstein?

Published

2 months ago

October 3, 2023

Gov. Gavin Newsom said he chose Laphonza Butler with “no constraints, no expectations” about her running for a full U.S. Senate term. (CalMatters Photo by Miguel Gutierrez Jr.)

Share with friends

Did Gavin Newsom dig himself out of a political hole Sunday when he announced that he had named veteran labor leader and political operative Laphonza Butler to succeed the late Dianne Feinstein in the U.S. Senate?

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Or did he dig himself into a new hole by not extracting a promise from Butler that she would not seek a full six-year Senate term next year?

Were she to run for a full term, it would completely change the dynamics of what has been a three-way duel for the Senate seat. Congressional members Katie Porter, Adam Schiff and Barbara Lee have been skirmishing for months, following Feinstein’s announcement that she would not be seeking another term in 2024.

Two-plus years ago, after Newsom appointed Alex Padilla, then secretary of state, to fill out the remainder of Kamala Harris’ Senate term after her election as vice president, Newsom came under fire for not appointing another Black woman.

Pressed in a national television interview about whether he would appoint a Black woman to a future Senate vacancy, Newsom replied, “I have multiple names in mind. We have multiple names in mind – and the answer is yes.”

As Feinstein’s health deteriorated, the issue arose again and in early September, appearing on NBC’s Meet the Press, Newsom said that he would honor his pledge but only as an “interim appointment.”

“Yes. Interim appointment,” Newsom told interviewer Chuck Todd. “I don’t want to get involved in the primary. It would be completely unfair to the Democrats that have worked their tail off. That primary is just a matter of months away. I don’t want to tip the balance of that.”

That statement appeared to declare that his appointee would not run for a full term, and Lee, a Black woman, called it “insulting.”

“I am troubled by the governor’s remarks,” Lee said on X, formerly known as Twitter. “The idea that a Black woman should be appointed only as a caretaker to simply check a box is insulting to countless Black women across this country who have carried the Democratic Party to victory election after election.”

‘No Constraints’ on Running for Full Term

The hypothetical became real when Feinstein died 18 days later, and three days after her death, Newsom announced his selection of Butler. On Monday, Newsom said he chose Butler with “no constraints, no expectations” about her running for a full-term in the 2024 election.”

Were she to run, it would insert a completely new – and powerful – player into the contest, and thus violate Newsom’s assertion just weeks ago that he didn’t want to “tip the balance” of the Senate contest.

Butler heads EMILY’s List, which helps women win political office, and everything hinges on her intentions after she is sworn in later this week.

Even if Butler intends only to serve the remaining 15 months of Feinstein’s term, she must win voter approval next year. In fact, that’s how Feinstein first gained her Senate seat in 1992, defeating Republican John Seymour, whom Gov. Pete Wilson had chosen as his successor in the Senate.

Were Butler to seek a full term, the other Senate hopefuls might be forced to also run against her for the rest of Feinstein’s term, which could be extremely confusing for voters.

California’ top-two system would add even more complexity to a head-spinning scenario. As it stands, it’s likely that two of the three Democrats running for the Senate would finish 1-2 in the March primary and face each other in November.

Were Butler to run, four Democrats would be seeking voter approval and splitting the Democratic vote four ways might allow a Republican to sneak into the November runoff.

Let the fun begin.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.

GV Wire – Explore. Explain. Expose

Did Newsom Dig a New Hole With Appointment of Senate Replacement for Feinstein?

About the Author

You may like

Palestine Flag Raising At Eaton Plaza

Merced Mall Renovations Still Moving Forward, Developer Says. Here’s What to Expect in 2024.

Palestinian Flag Flies in Downtown Fresno Following Weeks of Controversy

Federal Judge Prohibits Separating Migrant Families at US Border for 8 Years

Jon Rahm Joins LIV Golf. Here’s What It Means for LIV and the PGA Tour.

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Isn’t Rare, Says New CDC Survey. It Affects 3.3 Million US Adults

Fresno City Council Going to Court to Stop Closure of Mobile Home Park

Former Bitwise Leaders Make Court Appearance for Bond Review Hearing

Actor Ryan O’Neal, Star of ‘Love Story,’ ‘Paper Moon’ and ‘Barry Lyndon,’ Dies at 82

News Minute: Adventist Health Drops Blue Shield, 18 Year Old Criminal Prosecutor Makes History, and More!

Landmark Ruling on Gun Control: Court Supports New York’s Firearm Restrictions

Fresno Council Votes Down Affordable Housing Project in North Fresno

Zakaria: Another Casualty of War: Free Speech on Campus

Ian Bremmer: US CEOs Too Influential on China Policy, Says Rahm Emanuel

Ian Bremmer: Is an Israel-Palestine Two-State Solution Possible?

Successful Reading Skills Upgrade, Rooted in Phonics, Offers a Lesson for California Politicians

Economic Reality Bites as Newsom Faces a Big Budget Problem

Newsom Chides GOP for Trying to Change Voting Rules yet Adopts the Same Tactics

Cowboys vs. Seahawks Game Was a Better Show Than Newsom vs. DeSantis

Newsom vs. DeSantis: A Real Debate on the Issues or Just More Mudslinging?

California’s Utilities Commission, Other Consumer Watchdogs, Often Protect Big Companies

Closed-off Interstate 10 Is No Stranger to Major Damage or Political Attention

California Keeps Expanding School Curricula. What About Improving Key Subjects?

Political and Economic Stakes Are High for San Francisco This Week

Palestine Flag Raising At Eaton Plaza

Palestinian Flag Flies in Downtown Fresno Following Weeks of Controversy

News Minute: Adventist Health Drops Blue Shield, 18 Year Old Criminal Prosecutor Makes History, and More!

Fresno Councilmembers Clash Over Palestinian Flag Raising at City Park

Analyst Breaks Down Heated TV Clash Over Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

Wired Wednesday: Farms, Food, and Future of the Valley

Crafting Automotive Dreams: Caliber Customs of Madera

GV Wire News Minute: Check Out the Trending Stories of the Week

The DeSantis-Newsom Debate in Less Than 60 Seconds, Including the Poop Map

Wired Wednesday: The Latest on Income-Based PG&E Charges

You Can Find ‘This n’ That’ at Fresno Collectibles Shop

Actress Cynthia Nixon Leads Hunger Strike Outside White House, Demanding Gaza Ceasefire