Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Councilman Esparza's Legal Issues Cost Taxpayers at Least $113,000
gvw_david_taub
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 1 year ago on
April 17, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Taxpayers have paid more than $113,000 in legal expenses related to an attempted extortion charge that was later dropped against Fresno City Councilman Nelson Esparza.

Esparza fought and won in court after the Fresno County District Attorney’s Office dropped the case last December at a pre-trial hearing.

But the question of who covered Esparza’s six-figure legal expenses has always been shrouded in mystery. The Fresno City Council never held an open meeting discussion or vote about the matter.

Last year, GV Wire uncovered that votes, or “direction” was given in closed session, that was never publicly divulged, to cover Esparza’s legal expenses — as well as those of councilman Garry Bredefeld.

While items such as legal matters are allowed to be discussed in closed session, any votes or decisions to spend money should be publicly unveiled, legal experts said. Even advice given to the city council to reveal the votes went unheeded.

Most current councilmembers declined to comment on how or why they covered the costs.

“I’m just glad it’s over,” Councilman Mike Karbassi said.

GV Wire analyzed public records provided by the city, and overall costs provided by the City Attorney’s Office. The costs came from three main areas: Esparza’s criminal defense, attorney fees a judge ruled that Esparza owed Bredefeld’s attorneys, and a third-party attorney’s fees to advise the city council.

Criminal Costs: More Than $68,000

The criminal investigation was based on an April 22 private conversation between Esparza, then the city council president, and then-City Attorney Douglas Sloan.

In the criminal complaint, Esparza allegedly told Sloan to comply with the wishes of the council majority or risk losing his job.

Sloan felt that Esparza was threatening his job if he did not comply with Esparza and a majority of left-leaning councilmembers. Esparza contended that he never made such threats and that Sloan misinterpreted the conversation.

Smittcamp’s office charged Esparza in July 2022 with one felony attempted extortion count and a misdemeanor for violating the city charter. A judge later reduced the felony to a misdemeanor.

The city council agreed to cover Esparza’s criminal defense, handled by a third party. Prominent defense attorney Mark Coleman defended Esparza. The contract would pay Coleman $350 an hour, and his associates $250 an hour.

Coleman partnered with Margarita Martinez Baly and Scott Quinlan. The final invoice came to $68,174, the City Attorney’s Office said.

Charges Dropped

Prosecutor Victor Lai, head of the DA’s public integrity unit, agreed to drop charges after Esparza publicly told his side of the story at a preliminary hearing.

Esparza told the judge the conversation with Sloan was about concerns some councilmembers were using the city attorney to investigate others — “weaponizing” the office. The city council passed a resolution that any investigation into one of their own would require council consent.

“I did, in fact, imply to Mr. Sloan that if this happens and that the new resolution was not followed, that I would vote to terminate him. I never directed him not to comply with his legal and ethical obligations. I wish that he would have come to me to clarify before these allegations became public. This entire situation could have been avoided.,” Esparza said in court.

District Attorney Lisa Smittcamp, in media interviews after the court hearing, said that she wished Esparza would have come forward with his statement sooner.

City Covers $25,000 Payment to Bredefeld’s Attorneys

After Bredefeld learned about the conversation between Esparza and Sloan, he held a May 13 news conference at City Hall and accused Esparza of extortion.

Three days later, Esparza filed a civil defamation lawsuit against Bredefeld, arguing the extortion claims were lies.

Bredefeld filed an anti-SLAPP motion, that in essence asked a judge to dismiss the lawsuit because it infringed on free speech rights. Esparza dropped the lawsuit before there was even a hearing.

However, the consequence of an anti-SLAPP motion is the plaintiff has to cover the defense’s legal costs if successful. Bredefeld’s legal team won a ruling that even with the lawsuit dismissed, the anti-SLAPP legal costs provisions applied.

The city council agreed to cover Bredefeld’s legal costs, primarily because his news conference was in a councilmember’s scope and duties.

The city paid Bredefeld’s attorney, Walt Whalen, $25,101. Bredefeld went back to court to force Esparza to personally reimburse the city. The court ruled against that effort, essentially saying it didn’t care who paid Bredefeld’s attorneys, as long as payment was made.

[This story has been updated to clarify that Bredefeld sought Esparza to reimburse the city.]

Legal Advice: at Least $20,000

Because the City Attorney’s Office was directly involved in the Esparza and Bredefeld legal sagas, it had to recuse itself from the matters.

An outside firm, Lozano Smith, guided the city during several closed session items on the issues. Esparza and Bredefeld also recused themselves from participating in those discussions.

The City Attorney’s Office says Lozano Smith billed $20,153 for legal advice related to Bredefeld and Esparza.

James Sanchez, a one-time Fresno City Attorney, provided the bulk of the Lozano Smith advice.

The total for outside legal counsel could be higher. These numbers do not reflect a second firm hired by the city, Meyers Nave.

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Wired Wednesday: Downtown Fresno Revitalization and Affordable Housing

DON'T MISS

Six-Time DUI Offender Faces Murder Charges for Fatal Fresno Crash

DON'T MISS

CHP Seizes $400K of Cocaine in Fresno County I-5 Traffic Stop

DON'T MISS

Mendota Gets a New Big-Name Resident to Call Prison Home

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Faculty: Stop Diverting Money from Academics to Athletics

DON'T MISS

Fresno Needs More Grocery Stores. Would Change to Local Liquor Law Help It Happen?

DON'T MISS

First Disease Deaths Reported in Flooded Southern Brazil; Surge in Fatalities Expected

DON'T MISS

Cal Chamber Identifies Fewest ‘Job Killer’ Bills Since 2001

DON'T MISS

Fox’s Greg Olsen Wins Top Analyst at Sports Emmy Awards

DON'T MISS

Rookies Clark, Reese & Brink Send WNBA Ratings Soaring

UP NEXT

CHP Seizes $400K of Cocaine in Fresno County I-5 Traffic Stop

UP NEXT

Mendota Gets a New Big-Name Resident to Call Prison Home

UP NEXT

Fresno State Faculty: Stop Diverting Money from Academics to Athletics

UP NEXT

Fresno Needs More Grocery Stores. Would Change to Local Liquor Law Help It Happen?

UP NEXT

First Disease Deaths Reported in Flooded Southern Brazil; Surge in Fatalities Expected

UP NEXT

Cal Chamber Identifies Fewest ‘Job Killer’ Bills Since 2001

UP NEXT

Fox’s Greg Olsen Wins Top Analyst at Sports Emmy Awards

UP NEXT

Rookies Clark, Reese & Brink Send WNBA Ratings Soaring

UP NEXT

Asian American, Pacific Islander Latinos in the US See Exponential Growth, New Analysis Says

UP NEXT

Central Unified Gets $8 Million Grant to Bring Community Services to Schools

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Mendota Gets a New Big-Name Resident to Call Prison Home

2 hours ago

Fresno State Faculty: Stop Diverting Money from Academics to Athletics

2 hours ago

Fresno Needs More Grocery Stores. Would Change to Local Liquor Law Help It Happen?

3 hours ago

First Disease Deaths Reported in Flooded Southern Brazil; Surge in Fatalities Expected

3 hours ago

Cal Chamber Identifies Fewest ‘Job Killer’ Bills Since 2001

4 hours ago

Fox’s Greg Olsen Wins Top Analyst at Sports Emmy Awards

4 hours ago

Rookies Clark, Reese & Brink Send WNBA Ratings Soaring

5 hours ago

Asian American, Pacific Islander Latinos in the US See Exponential Growth, New Analysis Says

6 hours ago

Central Unified Gets $8 Million Grant to Bring Community Services to Schools

6 hours ago

RNC HQ Evacuated: Blood Vials Addressed to Trump Prompt Security Alert

6 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Downtown Fresno Revitalization and Affordable Housing

GV Wire senior reporter David Taub shares with KMPH Fox 26 “Great Day” anchor Jim De La Vega how revitalizing downtown Fresno involves an af...

19 mins ago

19 mins ago

Wired Wednesday: Downtown Fresno Revitalization and Affordable Housing

2 hours ago

Six-Time DUI Offender Faces Murder Charges for Fatal Fresno Crash

2 hours ago

CHP Seizes $400K of Cocaine in Fresno County I-5 Traffic Stop

2 hours ago

Mendota Gets a New Big-Name Resident to Call Prison Home

2 hours ago

Fresno State Faculty: Stop Diverting Money from Academics to Athletics

3 hours ago

Fresno Needs More Grocery Stores. Would Change to Local Liquor Law Help It Happen?

3 hours ago

First Disease Deaths Reported in Flooded Southern Brazil; Surge in Fatalities Expected

4 hours ago

Cal Chamber Identifies Fewest ‘Job Killer’ Bills Since 2001

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend