Supreme Court Case Could Give Dems Total Power Over CA House Seats
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 1 year ago on
December 5, 2022
(Illustration by Miguel Gutierrez Jr., CalMatters; iStock)

Share

Spread the love

If you want to identify a single reason for the new Republican House majority, it could be as simple as pointing to California’s independent redistricting.

Paul Mitchell portrait

Paul Mitchell

Special to CalMatters

Opinion

Thanks to this process, the state’s Democratic Legislature has been denied the opportunity to gerrymander districts and maximize the party’s advantage for the past two decades.

While good government types (myself among them) laud the work of the independent commission, Democratic partisan maximalists are aghast that the state is unilaterally disarming in the redistricting wars.

Meanwhile, Republicans in states like Florida and Texas passed egregious gerrymanders, with enough partisan gains to retake the U.S. House of Representatives and dozens of state houses.

Republicans Promote Obscure Theory

Ironically, Republicans are now promoting an obscure legal theory before the U.S. Supreme Court in Moore v. Harper, a case over redistricting in North Carolina that could give California Democrats the power to gerrymander. It relies on the “independent legislature theory,” and it interprets the constitution as giving legislatures the only say in how federal elections are run in their states — meaning they would have the ultimate authority on congressional maps. Voters would be unable to hand that power to a citizens commission and, potentially, courts could be barred from reviewing redistricting plans.

If Republicans are successful, California’s current commission-drawn districts would be invalidated, with the Legislature in charge of redrawing the state’s 52 congressional seats.

During the 2020 redistricting cycle, my firm, Redistricting Partners, performed an extensive analysis of California’s congressional maps and envisioned potential district configurations. We drew some maps by hand, using standard geographic information software; we drew some after incorporating maps submitted by other organizations; and we drew literally tens of thousands of maps using computer algorithms that created “ensembles” of potential plans.

Having an ensemble of 10,000 congressional maps is not going to create the perfect plan, but it does show you possibilities. It’s like having a statewide poll of 10,000 voters. But instead of asking thousands of voters about who they will vote for, you can ask the thousands of maps in the ensemble questions like “out of this sample, what’s the most likely number of Democratic seats?” or “out of this sample, what’s the fewest number of Republican seats that can be drawn?”

The answer to the first question was clear: the median number of Democratic seats was 40 – exactly what the commission plan has created, with 40 Democrats and 12 Republicans elected this year.

On the second question, the ensembles said that 6% of the time there were only six Republican seats, 5% of the time there were only five, and 2.6% of the time there were just four. These could be unfair but legally compliant maps.

It’d Be Easy for Dems to Carve up State in Their Favor

If California’s Legislature was to redraw the maps, Democratic staff would find it relatively easy to cut up the seats of the current 12 Republican congressional members into as few as four districts.

Two could be in Southern California, drawn by collapsing the most conservative parts of inland Orange County with the non-Latino portions of Riverside County and the conservative eastern portions of San Diego County.

The other two would comprise the Eastern portion of the Central Valley, from eastern Kern County up through Merced and into the foothills, including parts of Placer County and other conservative rural counties. GOP Leader Kevin McCarthy and Congressman Darrell Issa could both find themselves shoved into districts with two other Republican members.

Some Democrats may not like what this does to their districts, either. For example, the North Coast would likely have to be split up, spreading out the Democratic bases in Marin and Sonoma Counties to put more Democrats into the State of Jefferson counties. But if it was the difference between having the House majority or not, Democratic Party leaders would surely take it.

In redistricting, when a gerrymander backfires on its creators, it’s called a “dummymander.” And if Republicans are successful in convincing the Supreme Court of the independent legislature theory, they could have a huge one – of the legal variety.

A win in this case would give legislatures more control over laws around voter registration and election administration, allowing them to wreak havoc on a number of voting issues. But it would come at the immediate expense of their congressional majority as, given the pen, California would create a Democratic gerrymander which alone would flip the House back to Democratic control.

About the Author

Paul Mitchell is vice president of Political Data, a voter data firm based in California, and the owner of Redistricting Partners, a firm that does municipal redistricting and consulting nationally. He wrote this for CalMatters.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

How California’s Prized Solution for Methane Gas Is Backfiring on Farmers

DON'T MISS

Tech Lawyer and Philanthropist Nicole Shanahan Rumored as RFK Jr.’s VP Pick

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Seems Favorable to Biden Administration Over Efforts to Combat Social Media Posts

DON'T MISS

Trump: Some Migrants Are ‘Not People’, There’ll Be a ‘Bloodbath’ if I Lose

DON'T MISS

Bredefeld, Chavez Win Attorneys Fees from Fresno County. Court Gives Chavez Blvd. a Green Light.

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Lawyers Say It Is Impossible for Him to Post Bond Covering $454 Million Civil Fraud Judgment

DON'T MISS

Special Congressional Election Tuesday. How Many Have Voted Already?

DON'T MISS

Many Californians Rely on This Farmers Market Program. Newsom Wants to Cut It

DON'T MISS

Prosecutor Leaves Georgia Election Case Against Trump After Relationship With District Attorney

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Rules Public Officials Can Sometimes Be Sued for Blocking Critics on Social Media

No data was found

The 49ers Have Been Docked a 2025 Fifth-Round Draft Pick for an Accounting Error

10 hours ago

Fresno Bank Sued. It Allegedly Helped Bitwise Commit Fraud.

Bitwise /

10 hours ago

How California’s Prized Solution for Methane Gas Is Backfiring on Farmers

Environment /

13 hours ago

Supreme Court Seems Favorable to Biden Administration Over Efforts to Combat Social Media Posts

14 hours ago

Putin Extends Rule in Preordained Russian Election After Harshest Crackdown Since Soviet Era

14 hours ago

Ohtani to Begin Throwing Program Soon. Roberts Hints Dodgers Star Might Play in the Field

14 hours ago

Trump: Some Migrants Are ‘Not People’, There’ll Be a ‘Bloodbath’ if I Lose

14 hours ago

Tech Lawyer and Philanthropist Nicole Shanahan Rumored as RFK Jr.’s VP Pick

News /

14 hours ago

March Madness is Here. UConn, Purdue, Houston and North Carolina Get Top Seeding in NCAA Tournament

15 hours ago

Crafts Retailer Joann Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy as Consumers Cut Back on Pandemic-Era Hobbies

15 hours ago

Records Show That Valley Children’s Leader Suntrapak’s Pay Exceeds $5 Million

■Valley Children’s paid CEO Todd Suntrapak $5.2 million in 2021. The hospital also gave him a $5 million forgivable home loan. ■The Va...
Healthcare /

9 hours ago

4 days ago

Realtor Association Settles Lawsuit on Commission Rules. Fresno Broker Fears the End of Market Transparency

4 days ago

Prosecutor Leaves Georgia Election Case Against Trump After Relationship With District Attorney

4 days ago

Rory McIlroy’s 65: 10 Birdies, 2 Tee Shots in the Water, 1 Testy Dispute

4 days ago

Aaron Donald Announces His Retirement After a Standout 10-Year Career With the Rams

4 days ago

New Book Explores the Myths, Truths and Legacy of the Macho Man

4 days ago

Baseball Superstar Ohtani and His Wife Arrive in South Korea for Dodgers-Padres MLB Opener

4 days ago

India’s New Citizenship Law Excludes Muslims. Here’s What to Know

4 days ago

US, G-7 Allies Warn Iran to Back Off Deal to Provide Russia Ballistic Missiles or Face New Sanctions

Photo of San Francisco 49ers' Arik Armstead

4 days ago

Former 49ers DT Arik Armstead Agrees to a 3-Year, $51 Million Deal with the Jaguars, AP Source Says

4 days ago

Supreme Court Rules Public Officials Can Sometimes Be Sued for Blocking Critics on Social Media

Search