Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Dirty Political Tricks Aside, Top-Two Primary System Works
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
June 13, 2022

Share

 

By happenstance, last week’s “top two” primary election marked the 10th anniversary of the system that dramatically changed California’s political dynamics.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Prior to 2012, California had a closed primary system in which registered voters of the two major parties separately chose their parties’ candidates to face each other in the general election.

Critics said the system had a polarizing effect because candidates won their nominations by appealing to activist elements which tended to be very liberal in the Democratic Party and very conservative in the Republican Party. The rising numbers of independent voters, registered in neither party, were discouraged from participating in primary elections, which affected the outcomes of other issues, such as ballot measures.

In a top-two system, labeled a “jungle primary” by its opponents, all candidates for an office are listed on the same ballot and the two top finishers, regardless of party, then duel in the November general election.

It came about because in 2009, Democratic leaders of the state Senate desperately needed one more vote to pass a controversial budget and turned to moderate Republican Sen. Abel Maldonado to provide it. However, Maldonado — with the support of then-Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger — insisted that his vote hinged on placing the top-two primary before voters.

Democrats eventually agreed and Proposition 14, creating the top-two system, appeared on the June 2010 primary ballot with Maldonado and Schwarzenegger contending that it would give moderates and pragmatists in both parties better chances of winning legislative and congressional seats. The leaders of every political party opposed the measure but voters passed it handily.

Top-Two Primary Has Ushered in These Tactics

Has it worked as promised? Mostly, yes.

As Republicans became largely irrelevant in the Legislature, business groups such as the California Chamber of Commerce nurtured business-friendly Democrats, using the top-two system. Although Democrats have supermajorities in both legislative houses, the substantial blocs of moderates have blunted efforts by progressive groups to enact their left-leaning agendas — single-payer healthcare being the most obvious example.

The leaders of every political party opposed the top-two primary measure but voters passed it handily.

The system has its drawbacks, such as inviting mischievous tactics. For instance, operatives of one party sometimes clandestinely recruit multiple candidates in the other party to fragment the vote and help two candidates of the same party finish 1-2 in the primary. It’s happened a couple of times.

A variation of that trick, employed by Democrats in recent years, including this one, is encouraging voters of the opposing party to favor the most conservative Republican candidate, thereby making it easier for the Democrat to win.

Gavin Newsom’s 2018 campaign for governor devoted a lot of attention to Republican candidate John Cox, helping him finish second in the top-two primary, because Newsom did not want to face Democrat Antonio Villaraigosa, the former mayor of Los Angeles, in November.

This Year’s ‘Nightmare Scenario’ for GOP

The top-two system inadvertently allowed Republicans to shoot themselves in the foot this year when six of them ran in state Senate District 4, which sprawls through 13 mostly rural counties southeast of Sacramento and has a GOP voter registration plurality.

With so many running, they fragmented the GOP vote, thus allowing two Democrats, Tim Robertson and Marie Alvarado-Gil, to finish 1-2 and handing the seat to the other party.

“This is the nightmare scenario. … A lot of people thought that they would have a chance to win. So they jumped in, but they split the votes and that’s unfortunately what can happen,” Joseph Day, Stanislaus County’s Republican chairman, told GV Wire.

Notwithstanding those and other similar top-two outcomes, it remains a more democratic — with a small “d” — way of choosing candidates by forcing them to appeal to a wider array of voters.

Democrats Tim Robertson, right, and Marie Alvarado-Gil were the top vote-getters in the Republican majority state Senate District 4. (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall)

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Costco Tries Again at City Council for Big NW Fresno Move

DON'T MISS

Scheffler Turns the Masters Into Another Sunday Yawner With a Dominating Win

DON'T MISS

Ethiopia’s Lemma Wins, Fresno’s Albertson 7th in Boston Marathon. Kenya’s Obiri Retains Women Title.

DON'T MISS

Vegas, US Tour and More Signings: Wrexham Has Plenty of Fun and Work Ahead After Latest Promotion

DON'T MISS

This Week’s Weather Will Take Us from Fleece to Flip-Flops

DON'T MISS

NBA Play-in Game Preview: West Games on Tuesday, East Games on Wednesday, Eliminations on Friday

DON'T MISS

Palestinian Supporters Block Golden Gate Bridge, Chicago’s O’Hare Airport

DON'T MISS

Biden’s Embrace of Trump’s Tariffs Could Spell Trouble for His Reelection: Fareed Zakaria

DON'T MISS

Ship That Caused Bridge Collapse Had Apparent Electrical Issues While Still Docked, Source Says

DON'T MISS

Bureau of Prisons to Close California Women’s Prison Where Inmates Have Been Subjected to Sex Abuse

UP NEXT

‘Digital Democracy’ Project Penetrates California’s Opaque Political Processes

UP NEXT

While California Politicians Skirmish Over Housing, the Shortage Keeps Growing

UP NEXT

As PG&E Bills Skyrocket, Will California Lawmakers Hold Anyone Accountable?

UP NEXT

Trustees Owe a Nationwide Superintendent Search to Fresno’s Children

UP NEXT

Taxes Are on the November Ballot in Monumental CA Showdown

UP NEXT

California Progressives Forced to Play Defense as State Faces Huge Budget Deficits

UP NEXT

CA Labor Priorities and Business ‘Job Killers’ on a Collision Course

UP NEXT

California Water Wars Continue Despite Now Healthy H20 Supply

UP NEXT

How the Saga of California’s Contentious Income-Based Utility Charge Began

UP NEXT

Fresno County Lawsuit Against Political Candidates Stifles Free Speech, Wastes Taxpayers’ Money

Vegas, US Tour and More Signings: Wrexham Has Plenty of Fun and Work Ahead After Latest Promotion

51 mins ago

This Week’s Weather Will Take Us from Fleece to Flip-Flops

Weather /

58 mins ago

NBA Play-in Game Preview: West Games on Tuesday, East Games on Wednesday, Eliminations on Friday

1 hour ago

Palestinian Supporters Block Golden Gate Bridge, Chicago’s O’Hare Airport

1 hour ago

Biden’s Embrace of Trump’s Tariffs Could Spell Trouble for His Reelection: Fareed Zakaria

1 hour ago

Ship That Caused Bridge Collapse Had Apparent Electrical Issues While Still Docked, Source Says

2 hours ago

Bureau of Prisons to Close California Women’s Prison Where Inmates Have Been Subjected to Sex Abuse

3 hours ago

Rosario, Pinto Homer off Snell in His Return to Tropicana Field as Rays Beat Giants

3 hours ago

Are Americans Feeling Like They Get Enough Sleep? Dream On, a New Gallup Poll Says

4 hours ago

Profar’s Tiebreaking 3-Run Double in 7th Inning Lifts Padres Over Dodgers

4 hours ago

Costco Tries Again at City Council for Big NW Fresno Move

Costco wants to move its northwest Fresno location to a bigger, better facility. After roadblocks at a city council meeting last month, the ...

22 mins ago

22 mins ago

Costco Tries Again at City Council for Big NW Fresno Move

38 mins ago

Scheffler Turns the Masters Into Another Sunday Yawner With a Dominating Win

39 mins ago

Ethiopia’s Lemma Wins, Fresno’s Albertson 7th in Boston Marathon. Kenya’s Obiri Retains Women Title.

51 mins ago

Vegas, US Tour and More Signings: Wrexham Has Plenty of Fun and Work Ahead After Latest Promotion

Weather /
58 mins ago

This Week’s Weather Will Take Us from Fleece to Flip-Flops

1 hour ago

NBA Play-in Game Preview: West Games on Tuesday, East Games on Wednesday, Eliminations on Friday

1 hour ago

Palestinian Supporters Block Golden Gate Bridge, Chicago’s O’Hare Airport

1 hour ago

Biden’s Embrace of Trump’s Tariffs Could Spell Trouble for His Reelection: Fareed Zakaria

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend