Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
'Nothing-Burger': US-China Truce Leaves Big Issues for Later
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
October 14, 2019

Share

WASHINGTON โ€” President Donald Trump heralded a breakthrough in U.S.-China trade talks, and markets rallied in relief over a de-escalation in tensions between the worldโ€™s two biggest economies.

โ€œWe made substantial progress last week in the negotiations. We have a fundamental agreement. It is subject to documentation, and thereโ€™s a lot of work to be done on that front.โ€ โ€” Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin
But closer inspection suggests there isnโ€™t much substance, at least not yet, to the temporary truce Trump announced Friday at the White House after the U.S. and China wrapped up their 13th round of trade talks.
Yes, Trump agreed to suspend a tariff hike scheduled for Tuesday on $250 billion worth of Chinese imports. And the president said the Chinese agreed to buy $40 billion to $50 billion in U.S. farm products.
But nothingโ€™s on paper and details are scarce. Chinaโ€™s state-run media hasnโ€™t even mentioned the promise to buy all those soybeans and other agricultural products.
And the negotiators have delayed dealing with the toughest issues for future talks. Meanwhile, the U.S. is still scheduled to target another $160 billion in Chinese goods Dec. 15, a move that would extend Trumpโ€™s tariffs to virtually everything China ships to the United States.
Fridayโ€™s announcement was โ€œa nothing-burger,โ€ said Scott Kennedy, who analyzes Chinaโ€™s economy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. โ€œI call it the โ€˜Invisible Deal.โ€™โ€ฆ The only thing that happened Friday was that the U.S. delayed the tariff increase.โ€
The Trump administration acknowledges that work remains to be done on what it calls โ€œphase oneโ€ of ongoing talks with China.
โ€œWe made substantial progress last week in the negotiations,โ€ Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said Monday on CNBC. โ€œWe have a fundamental agreement. It is subject to documentation, and thereโ€™s a lot of work to be done on that front.โ€

U.S. Farm Sales to China Have Never Exceeded $26 Billion a Year

Mnuchin said he expected that he and U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer will meet with Chinaโ€™s lead negotiator, Vice Premier Liu He, before a November Asia-Pacific summit in Chile. At that gathering, Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping could officially sign off on a phase one agreement.
โ€œItโ€™s curious that Washington and Beijing have not yet put this โ€˜dealโ€™ in writing,โ€ said Wendy Cutler, a former U.S. trade negotiator now at the Asia Society Policy Institute. โ€œThat suggests that the details may not be worked out yet. If thatโ€™s the case, we should expect more bumps in the road in the lead up to a mid-November meeting between Trump and Xi.โ€
Trump emphasized the agricultural purchases he says China has agreed to. If China ultimately buys $40 billion to $50 billion a year, as Mnuchin said, it would mark a significant win for American farmers, who have been hit hard by the presidentโ€™s trade wars.
U.S. farm sales to China have never exceeded $26 billion a year, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
China already is a major food importer as rising incomes boost its appetite for meat, vegetables and higher-quality grains. The communist government has tried to promote self-sufficiency in rice, wheat, dairy and some other commodities. But with a population of 1.4 billion, it cannot meet all its own needs.
Jeff Moon, a former U.S. diplomat and trade official specializing in China who is now president of the China Moon Strategies consultancy, noted that Trump had reason to delay Tuesdayโ€™s planned tariff increase. Trade hostilities are weighing on the U.S. and world economies. Tariffs have pushed up costs for U.S. manufacturers and created uncertainty about when and how the trade wars will end.

 

The Two Countries Are Deadlocked Primarily Over U.S. Allegations That China Deploys Predatory Tactics

โ€œThe bottom line is that both sides (on Friday) gave themselves permission to do what they wanted to do,โ€ Moon said. โ€œChina really needs the food, and Trump doesnโ€™t want to impose the (increase in) tariffs. Thatโ€™s the bottom line.โ€

โ€œThe bottom line is that both sides (on Friday) gave themselves permission to do what they wanted to do. China really needs the food, and Trump doesnโ€™t want to impose the (increase in) tariffs. Thatโ€™s the bottom line.โ€ โ€” Jeff Moon, a former U.S. diplomat and trade official specializing in China who is now president of the China Moon Strategies consultancy
โ€œItโ€™s in the two countriesโ€™ interests to dial down the hostilities,โ€ agreed David Dollar, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and a former official at the World Bank and U.S. Treasury.
The two countries are deadlocked primarily over U.S. allegations that China deploys predatory tactics โ€” including outright theft โ€” in a sharp-elbowed drive to become the global leader in robotics, self-driving cars and other advanced technology.
Beijing has been reluctant to make the kind of substantive policy reforms that would satisfy the Trump administration. Doing so would likely require scaling back Chinaโ€™s aspirations for technological supremacy, which it sees as crucial to its prosperity. โ€œI donโ€™t think China is willing to fundamentally change its system,โ€ Dollar said.
Resolving those issues is largely being pushed to future talks.
Over the past 15 months, the two countries have imposed tariffs on hundreds of billions of dollarsโ€™ worth of each otherโ€™s goods. Beijing has targeted farm products in a shot at Trump supporters in rural America.
Itโ€™s taken a toll.

โ€˜Weโ€™ve Heard This Beforeโ€™

Tim Garrett, 63, shares a 5,000-acre farm with his brother in eastern North Dakota, where they grow mostly soybeans and corn. He voted for Trump and said he supports a better trade deal with China. But heโ€™s โ€œnot sure itโ€™s coming about.โ€
โ€œIโ€™m not a huge political guy to start with, but China has been ripping us off for years,โ€ Garrett said. โ€œI believe something had to be done. I donโ€™t think it should all be on the backs of agriculture.โ€
Bob Metz, a fifth-generation farmer from Peever, South Dakota, and a past president of the American Soybean Association, said heโ€™s hopeful for a deal but until that time โ€œthe American farmer is getting hurt.โ€
โ€œWeโ€™ve heard this before,โ€ Metz said. โ€œI donโ€™t think anything has really changed with China, has it?โ€
The few times China has agreed to buy soybeans, they are getting them at up to $2 a bushel cheaper than when the trade war started, Metz said.
โ€œSo whoโ€™s the winner here?โ€ he said. โ€œIt seems that China buys a few beans going into the talks, but is the goal to get rid of them or is the goal to sell them at a good price? The Chinese have done very well on this.โ€
U.S. Sen. Chuck Grassley, Republican of Iowa, a state hard hit by loss of soybean and pork sales to China, said he welcomes news that progress may have been made in some areas of the trade dispute with China but he said a final deal must address the full scope of structural issues and include strong enforcement mechanisms.
โ€œAfter so much has been sacrificed, Americans will settle for nothing less than a full, enforceable and fair deal with China,โ€ Grassley said.

DON'T MISS

Khalil Sues Columbia and Lawmakers to Keep Activistsโ€™ Names Secret

UP NEXT

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

Johns Hopkins to Cut More Than 2,000 Workers Funded by Federal Aid

20 minutes ago

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

34 minutes ago

Khalil Sues Columbia and Lawmakers to Keep Activistsโ€™ Names Secret

Mahmoud Khalil, the Columbia University graduate detained by the Trump administration last weekend, and seven current students asked a feder...

8 minutes ago

Demonstrators rally with the flag of Palestine outside the federal courthouse in lower Manhattan to protest the detention and potential deportation of Mahmoud Khalil in New York, Wednesday, March 12, 2025. Mahmoud, 30, a pro-Palestinian student activist at Columbia University, was detained by immigration agents at Columbia student housing, despite his status as a legal resident of the United States. (Juan Arredondo/The New York Times)
8 minutes ago

Khalil Sues Columbia and Lawmakers to Keep Activistsโ€™ Names Secret

President Donald Trump walks with Elon Musk and his son X AE A-Xii, after looking at Tesla vehicles on the South Grounds of the White House in Washington, March 11, 2025. A federal judge in Washington ordered Musk and operatives involved with his Department of Government Efficiency to hand over an assortment of documents and written answers addressing its role in the government, a perch from which the unit has effected mass firings of federal workers and a dramatic dismantling of federal programs. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
12 minutes ago

Judge Orders Musk and His Team to Turn Over Records and Answer Questions

13 minutes ago

Peach Pits? No Name for SE Fresno Sports Complex for Now

The campus of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Nov. 1, 2017. Johns Hopkins University, a leader in scientific research, has been hard hit by the Trump administrationโ€™s spending cuts, which will slash at least $800 million from its budget. (Andrew Mangum/The New York Times)
20 minutes ago

Johns Hopkins to Cut More Than 2,000 Workers Funded by Federal Aid

Food is passed out to residents in Beit Lahia, north of the Gaza Strip on March 10, 2025. (Saher Alghorra/The New York Times)
34 minutes ago

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

48 minutes ago

Atmospheric River Soaks Fresno With 1.5 Inches of Rain and More Ahead

A powerful March storm is set to bring extreme weather, including fires, blizzards, tornadoes, and flooding, affecting millions across the U.S.
2 hours ago

March Megastorm May Bring Blizzards, Tornadoes, Flooding and Even Fires Across Much of US

House Natural Resources Committee Chairman Raul Grijalva, D-Ariz., speaks at Capitol in Washington, March 28, 2022. (AP File)
2 hours ago

Democratic Rep. Raรบl M. Grijalva Dies From Complications From Cancer Treatment

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend