Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Should Google or Your Taxes Help Pay for Local News?
Joe-Mathews
By Joe Mathews
Published 6 years ago on
March 1, 2019

Share

Whose job it is to revive local journalism in California? Our state’s elites have a clear, if dubious answer: themselves.

Opinion

Joe Mathews

Philanthropists and foundations have invested in news nonprofits, like the Voice of San Diego. And billionaire Patrick Soon-Shiong is re-investing in the L.A. Times.

Last year, Google announced it was putting $300 million into supporting local news. A few weeks ago, Facebook announced its own $300 million local news initiative. Philanthropists and foundations have invested in news nonprofits, like the Voice of San Diego. And billionaire Patrick Soon-Shiong is re-investing in the L.A. Times.

Local news operations have been shrinking for years, so this is mostly good news. But philanthropic grants are temporary, and tech companies abandon strategies in the flash of an electron. So the long-term solution to funding local news lies not with the rich, with California’s local communities themselves.

And the most sustainable way to restore local media is to have local taxpayers to foot the bill.

Let me pause while you lose your mind.

I know you think this is a socialist plot, or at least a conflict of interest. But it’s not even a new idea. Other countries supported vital coverage with tax dollars, and America’s local newspapers have long been subsidized by government notices and by advertising from local businesses whose owners double as public officials.

Local Coverage Is as Essential as Other Public Services

Another reason for taxpayer-funded local media is simple politics. Local governments— and especially the people who work in them, as well as their critics—are the strongest potential supporters for any effort to revive local media.

As I travel this state of 500 cities and thousands more local governments, people complain constantly that they no longer have media that explain what local communities need. Studies show this lack of media coverage results in lower voter turnout, and more problematic local government finances.

Local coverage is as essential as any other public service that local governments provide. Local journalists hold wrongdoers accountable, as police do; respond in emergencies, like the fire department; and provide knowledge as certainly as the library does.

Since the free market won’t provide sufficient local media services, especially in small towns, it’s necessary for local governments step in and do so.

But how? Local governments should establish separate local media bureaus as nonprofit or quasi-governmental entities, with rules requiring independent decision-making, as they might do to manage a civic auditorium or pursue a special project.

The best way to fund such entities would be with a dedicated fee on all households (a media funding structure used in some countries), with a state match to boost coverage in smaller communities.

Taxes would ensure accountability. When local people know they themselves are paying for the local media, they are more likely to read it, and complain about it if it’s not really serving them. This struggle should make the local news livelier, more grounded in community and more interesting, because it will be fought over. That’s a very different vision than the elite attitude that news is like fiber, something that is good for you and must be provided from on high by credentialed people.

Facebook Says It Wants to Support Local Journalists and Newsrooms

Today’s philanthropic and technological plans to fund local media are similarly high-minded, and so they lack the connection to local communities and accountability that tax-supported local media might offer. Take Google and its $300 million local news initiative, which is focused not on the community level but rather on working with existing media and universities to advance technologies and new media models. In effect, the company is leading a search for innovations that advance the media business rather than meeting the needs of specific communities.

The fundamental principle is this: If there is going to be a real and sustained revival of local journalism, the journalists will need to work for the locals.

For its part, Facebook says it wants to support local journalists and newsrooms, but it is sending that money through national funds and non-profits, with the hope that the money will trickle down to the locals.

It’s also hard to trust Facebook’s word when it comes to media, given how it jerked the chains of publishers by promoting an expensive shift to video, then retreating from it. And since Google and Facebook took so much of the ad money that once supported local news, it’s hard to see them as the charitable saviors of local news they claim to be.

Philanthropic and corporate donations could still be useful if they were directed at the sort of publicly funded news operations that I’m suggesting. But, in such a system, those local journalists would not be begging for grants from philanthropic programs or rich people. Instead, the locals, with their base-funding in place from taxpayers, could resist donors with agendas.

The fundamental principle is this: If there is going to be a real and sustained revival of local journalism, the journalists will need to work for the locals.

About the Author

Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square.

[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

With or Without Lockridge, Can Bulldogs Get Out of Their Own Way to Become Bowl Eligible?

DON'T MISS

Classes for Cannabis? UC Merced Extension Launching Weed Workforce Training

DON'T MISS

This Kitty Seeks a Quiet Home to Call Her Own

DON'T MISS

‘Woke’ Terminology Not Commonly Used by Americans: YouGov Survey

DON'T MISS

FBI Arrested a Man Who’s Been Charged With Planning an Attack on the New York Stock Exchange

DON'T MISS

Shoppers Flock to Clovis for Vallarta’s Grand Opening

DON'T MISS

Thousands of University of California Workers Go on 2-Day Strike Over Wages, Staff Shortages

DON'T MISS

Madera County Shooting Strikes K-9, Investigation Ongoing

DON'T MISS

Republicans on House Ethics Reject for Now Releasing Report on Matt Gaetz

DON'T MISS

Demography Drives Destiny and Right Now California Is Losing

UP NEXT

Defining Deviancy Down. And Down. And Down.

UP NEXT

How Three Trump Policy Decrees Could Affect California Farmers

UP NEXT

Donald Trump Is Already Starting to Fail

UP NEXT

I Can’t Wait for Matt Gaetz’s Confirmation Hearings

UP NEXT

Let the Games Begin: 2026 Campaign for CA Governor Looms

UP NEXT

Why Trump’s Deportations Will Drive Up Your Grocery Bill

UP NEXT

Dems Still Dominate California, but Their Voters Have Drifted to the Right

UP NEXT

If You Thought Trump Wasn’t Serious About Deportations, Look at His First Appointments

UP NEXT

How Democrats Helped Trump

UP NEXT

Newsom Uses a Stunt to Position Himself as a Leader of Anti-Trump Resistance

‘Woke’ Terminology Not Commonly Used by Americans: YouGov Survey

4 hours ago

FBI Arrested a Man Who’s Been Charged With Planning an Attack on the New York Stock Exchange

14 hours ago

Shoppers Flock to Clovis for Vallarta’s Grand Opening

15 hours ago

Thousands of University of California Workers Go on 2-Day Strike Over Wages, Staff Shortages

15 hours ago

Madera County Shooting Strikes K-9, Investigation Ongoing

15 hours ago

Republicans on House Ethics Reject for Now Releasing Report on Matt Gaetz

15 hours ago

Demography Drives Destiny and Right Now California Is Losing

16 hours ago

Hate Your Instagram Feed? New Reset Feature Enhances User Control

17 hours ago

Senate to Vote on Sanders’ Resolution to Block Arms Sales to Israel

17 hours ago

Defining Deviancy Down. And Down. And Down.

17 hours ago

With or Without Lockridge, Can Bulldogs Get Out of Their Own Way to Become Bowl Eligible?

Steven Sanchez Sports The team that gave Fresno State the most problems this season wasn’t Michigan, Hawai’i, UNLV, or even Air...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

With or Without Lockridge, Can Bulldogs Get Out of Their Own Way to Become Bowl Eligible?

3 hours ago

Classes for Cannabis? UC Merced Extension Launching Weed Workforce Training

4 hours ago

This Kitty Seeks a Quiet Home to Call Her Own

4 hours ago

‘Woke’ Terminology Not Commonly Used by Americans: YouGov Survey

14 hours ago

FBI Arrested a Man Who’s Been Charged With Planning an Attack on the New York Stock Exchange

Vallarta Supermarkets in Clovis. November 20, 2024. (GV Wire/Jahz Tello)
15 hours ago

Shoppers Flock to Clovis for Vallarta’s Grand Opening

15 hours ago

Thousands of University of California Workers Go on 2-Day Strike Over Wages, Staff Shortages

A suspect and a Madera County Sheriff’s K-9 were injured in an officer-involved shooting during a hit-and-run investigation in Oakhurst. (GV Wire File)
15 hours ago

Madera County Shooting Strikes K-9, Investigation Ongoing

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend