Humane Enforcement of U.S. Border Laws is Possible
Share
The Trump administration’s reversal of its family separation policy for immigrants crossing the border illegally is less than meets the eye, according to a June 22 opinion published in the New York Times.

— Sonia Nazario
“Most immigrant children apprehended with their families on our southern border are from Honduras, El Salvador or Guatemala, three of the most violent countries on earth.”
Nazario continues, “prisons are bad for kids, even if they have their parents with them.” More humane and cost-effective options for enforcing immigration laws are available when families are involved, she argues.Research shows that the effect of detention can be especially damaging to kids who have previously experienced violence in their lives, Nazario says. Incarceration retraumatizes those who are already suffering.
“About six in 10 girls are raped on the journey north. Thousands upon thousands of Central Americans are kidnapped each year in Mexico; girls are prostituted, boys are enslaved, migrants are killed, their organs are harvested.”
“Most immigrant children apprehended with their families on our southern border are from Honduras, El Salvador or Guatemala, three of the most violent countries on earth,” she says. “Many children know of, or have witnessed, a family member or friend murdered by the gangs that control their neighborhoods. They force boys to join them or be killed. They force girls to have sex with them or be killed.”Even as they flee violence in their home countries, the dangers do not abate, Nazario says.
“About six in 10 girls are raped on the journey north. Thousands upon thousands of Central Americans are kidnapped each year in Mexico; girls are prostituted, boys are enslaved, migrants are killed, their organs are harvested. (This is the journey that President Trump on Thursday said was like “walking through Central Park.”)”
Nazario says the conditions migrant families face in American detention centers are harsh. “These are not places where we should want more children to go.”
“Law and order can go hand in hand with humanity. It’s the American way.”
Instead, she says the government should expand on the success of a 2016 pilot project that used caseworkers to monitor immigrant families, under supervised release, while their cases were pending. Utilizing that approach, Nazario says, nearly 99 percent of immigrants showed up for their hearings.Other alternatives to prison confinement include the use of ankle monitors, voice-recognition software, unannounced home visits, telephone reporting and GPS tracking. All of these approaches, Nazario says, are more cost-effective solutions and less harmful options.
“Law and order can go hand in hand with humanity,” she says. It’s the American way.”
You can read the full commentary, There’s a Better, Cheaper Way to Handle Immigration, at The New York Times.
California Voters Say State Is Off Course. Housing Emerges as Top Concern
Politics /
2 hours ago
What’s Fresno County Worth? Property Tax Roll Grows by Billions of Dollars
Economy /
3 hours ago
Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Justin Louis Flournoy
Local /
3 hours ago
NPR’s Top Editor Edith Chapin to Step Down
News /
1 hour ago
Trump Says US, Philippines ‘Very Close’ to Finalizing Trade Deal
World /
2 hours ago
US to Mediate Israel-Syria Meeting on Thursday, Axios Reports
World /
2 hours ago
Students Protest in Bangladesh After Air Force Jet Crash Kills 31, Mostly Children
World /
2 hours ago
Trump Blames Obama for What He Calls 2016 Attempt to Tie Him to Russia
Politics /
2 hours ago
Less Than 400 EV Charging Ports Built Under $7.5 Billion US Infrastructure Program
News /
2 hours ago
California Voters Say State Is Off Course. Housing Emerges as Top Concern
Politics /
2 hours ago
What’s Fresno County Worth? Property Tax Roll Grows by Billions of Dollars
Economy /
3 hours ago
Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Justin Louis Flournoy
Local /
3 hours ago
NPR’s Top Editor Edith Chapin to Step Down
News /
1 hour ago
Trump Says US, Philippines ‘Very Close’ to Finalizing Trade Deal
World /
2 hours ago
US to Mediate Israel-Syria Meeting on Thursday, Axios Reports
World /
2 hours ago
Students Protest in Bangladesh After Air Force Jet Crash Kills 31, Mostly Children
World /
2 hours ago
Trump Blames Obama for What He Calls 2016 Attempt to Tie Him to Russia
Politics /
2 hours ago
Less Than 400 EV Charging Ports Built Under $7.5 Billion US Infrastructure Program
News /
2 hours ago
California Voters Say State Is Off Course. Housing Emerges as Top Concern
Politics /
2 hours ago
What’s Fresno County Worth? Property Tax Roll Grows by Billions of Dollars
Economy /
3 hours ago
Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Justin Louis Flournoy
Local /
3 hours ago
What Do Fresno Families Pay in Taxes? Study Says 11th Lowest Rate in Nation
You would not be wrong to assume what Californians pay in taxes far exceed the national average, but considering Fresno’s lower cost o...
Economy /
3 minutes ago
Categories
Latest
Videos

Economy /
3 minutes ago
What Do Fresno Families Pay in Taxes? Study Says 11th Lowest Rate in Nation

Latest /
18 minutes ago
Trump Says Received $16 Million Payment After Paramount Lawsuit Settlement

Latest /
31 minutes ago
Farming Giant Boswell Silent as It Plans to Sink Tulare Lake Bed Another 10 feet

News /
1 hour ago
NPR’s Top Editor Edith Chapin to Step Down

World /
2 hours ago
Trump Says US, Philippines ‘Very Close’ to Finalizing Trade Deal

World /
2 hours ago
US to Mediate Israel-Syria Meeting on Thursday, Axios Reports

World /
2 hours ago
Students Protest in Bangladesh After Air Force Jet Crash Kills 31, Mostly Children

World /
2 hours ago