Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

7 hours ago

Trump Says He’s Committed to Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago

8 hours ago

Trump Dismisses Rumors He Is in Ill Health, Calls Them ‘Fake’

8 hours ago

Rubio Says US Military Conducted Lethal Strike Against Drug Vessel From Venezuela

9 hours ago

Trump Says He Is ‘Very Disappointed’ With Putin Over Ukraine

9 hours ago

Wall Street Hits Over One-Week Low on Tariff Uncertainty, Data in Focus

13 hours ago

US Judge Blocks Trump Administration’s Use of Troops in Los Angeles

14 hours ago

Garnet Fire in Fresno County Grows to 26,982 Acres, 12% Contained

14 hours ago
Tillerson's Firing and Pompeo's Rise Make Mideast War More Likely
The-Conversation
By The Conversation
Published 7 years ago on
March 16, 2018

Share

After U.S. president Donald Trump fired his secretary of state, Rex Tillerson, many analysts have focused on how this high-level ouster took place: unceremoniously, on Twitter, not in a face-to-face meeting.
As a former Middle East analyst at the State Department, though, I think the real drama of replacing America’s top diplomat lies in the foreign policy implications. Trump has tapped Mike Pompeo, the hawkish CIA director and former Kansas congressman, to replace Tillerson.


Opinion
Gregory Aftandilian
In 2015, Pompeo voted against a deal that the Obama administration negotiated to remove some international economic sanctions on Iran. In exchange, Iran would significantly scale back its nuclear program and submit to intrusive international inspections.
Tillerson’s departure means the Iran nuclear deal is in trouble.
And if Trump scraps it, I fear the whole Middle East could erupt in conflict.

Why Tillerson Had to Go

The outgoing secretary of state was fired for a host of reasons, some of them personal.
Tillerson and Trump did not know each other prior to the 2016 election, and it seems Tillerson never gained the president’s trust. The president reportedly found Tillerson arrogant, disrespectful and less compliant than other cabinet members.
Tillerson earned Trump’s ire by disagreeing with him on many substantive policy matters, including the president’s decisions to withdraw from the Paris climate accord, recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and cozy up to Russia. Tillerson also called his boss a “moron” after a July 2017 meeting at the Pentagon.
In short, as Trump suggested to reporters on the White House lawn, the two never developed good “chemistry.”

Iran Deal in Danger

Perhaps most importantly, though, Tillerson defied Trump on Iran. Trump has been highly critical of the international nuclear agreement since his 2016 presidential campaign, calling it “the worst deal ever negotiated.”
He wanted to scuttle it when it came up for recertification in July 2017, but his secretary of state advised against it on both diplomatic and security grounds.
Tillerson has been strongly critical of Iran, condemning its regional aggression and its meddling in the Syrian civil war. But I believe he understood, as many other policy analysts did, that backing out of the nuclear deal would destabilize the Middle East – and potentially put the world at risk – because Iran would likely react by restarting its nuclear program.
Tillerson, a former international business executive, was also more sensitive to the opinion of European allies than his boss. Rather than sour relations with the U.K., France, Germany and other key partners by terminating an agreement that they helped negotiate, he worked with the Europeans to come up with a compromise that Trump might find tolerable.
Secretary of Defense James Mattis agreed with Tillerson on Iran. The two of them periodically lobbied the president not to scrap the deal, and their influence got the agreement recertified in July 2017.
But Trump resented being pressured. Remember, this is a president who has openly stated that only his views matter when it comes to foreign policy.
Tillerson disagreed. As he said in his somber March 13 goodbye speech, he believed his job as secretary of state was to serve the nation and defend the U.S. Constitution.
To Trump, Tillerson’s stance on Iran wasn’t just a difference of opinion – it was, perhaps, an act of disloyalty.

Pompeo’s Dangerous Instincts

In October 2017, Trump finally decertified the Iran deal, which effectively opened the door for the U.S. Congress to reimpose sanctions. In his January 2018 State of the Union address, he was more direct, calling on lawmakers to “address the fundamental flaws in the terrible Iran nuclear deal.”
The newly nominated secretary of state shares the president’s dim view.
As a congressman, Pompeo opposed the Obama-era Iran agreement as “unconscionable,” and he said after Trump’s election that he was looking forward to “rolling it back.” Pompeo – with whom, Trump reports, he has very good chemistry – is also on record saying that Iran is “intent on destroying America.”
Congressional aides who’ve worked with him say that Pompeo is a smart guy, level-headed and reasonable. But if he eggs on Trump’s most belligerent instincts, I believe the Iran deal won’t last the year.

Destabilizing the Mideast

This could unleash a dangerous chain of events in the volatile Middle East.
If the U.S. reimposes sanctions on Iran, hard-liners there – who have always opposed the nuclear deal – would likely pressure Iranian President Hassan Rouhani to retaliate by restarting the country’s uranium enrichment program.
I believe Israel would then feel justified in taking military action against Iran, which has been threatening its national security for decades. In doing so, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu would have the behind-the-scenes backing of Saudia Arabia, a regional power and longtime rival of Iran, and possibly other states with a Sunni Muslim majority.
Iran is governed by conservative Shiite Muslim clerics. Sunni-majority countries like Saudi Arabia dislike Iran’s policy of financing violent Shiite militias to push its sectarian agenda in Arab states with significant, and sometimes restive, Shiite populations.
Israel and Saudi Arabia never supported the Iran nuclear deal. They feared that lifting sanctions on Iran would merely give Tehran more resources to foment strife in the Arab world.
Analysts agree that should some Sunni Arab countries team up with Israel against Iran, Iran would not limit itself to responding with missiles. It could also persuade its well-armed allies like Hezbollah and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad to launch rocket attacks on Israel, too.
The ConversationI doubt Mideast war is the outcome Pompeo and Trump would seek by ending the Iran deal, but it may be just the disaster they create.
Gregory Aftandilian, Lecturer, Pardee School of Global Studies, Boston University
This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Caught With 1,500 Fentanyl Pills Sentenced to Five Years

DON'T MISS

California Jury Clears Pop Star Cardi B of Assault Allegations in Civil Lawsuit

DON'T MISS

How the US Congressional Redistricting War is Playing Out State by State

DON'T MISS

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

DON'T MISS

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

DON'T MISS

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

DON'T MISS

They Were Convicted of Gang Crimes. New CA Supreme Court Rulings Trim Their Sentences

DON'T MISS

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

DON'T MISS

US Congress Returns, With One Month to Avert Government Shutdown

DON'T MISS

Trump Says His Administration Will Ask Supreme Court for Expedited Ruling on Tariffs

UP NEXT

US Congress Returns, With One Month to Avert Government Shutdown

UP NEXT

Trump Says His Administration Will Ask Supreme Court for Expedited Ruling on Tariffs

UP NEXT

Trump Says He’s Committed to Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago

UP NEXT

Trump Dismisses Rumors He Is in Ill Health, Calls Them ‘Fake’

UP NEXT

US Appeals Court Allows Trump’s EPA to Nix Climate Grants

UP NEXT

Rubio Says US Military Conducted Lethal Strike Against Drug Vessel From Venezuela

UP NEXT

Trump Says He Is ‘Very Disappointed’ With Putin Over Ukraine

UP NEXT

Letter to the Editor: CSU Chancellor’s Silence on Joe Castro’s Passing ‘Is Appalling’

UP NEXT

Trump Moves Space Command Headquarters to Alabama From Colorado

UP NEXT

What Could Nikki Henry’s $162,000 Buy for Fresno Unified? Let’s Ask AI

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

6 hours ago

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

6 hours ago

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

7 hours ago

They Were Convicted of Gang Crimes. New CA Supreme Court Rulings Trim Their Sentences

7 hours ago

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

7 hours ago

US Congress Returns, With One Month to Avert Government Shutdown

8 hours ago

Trump Says His Administration Will Ask Supreme Court for Expedited Ruling on Tariffs

8 hours ago

Trump Says He’s Committed to Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago

8 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Teen After Traffic Stop Leads to Foot Chase, Firearm Recovery

8 hours ago

Trump Dismisses Rumors He Is in Ill Health, Calls Them ‘Fake’

8 hours ago

Fresno Man Caught With 1,500 Fentanyl Pills Sentenced to Five Years

A Fresno man was sentenced Tuesday to five years in federal prison for possessing fentanyl with intent to distribute, prosecutors said. Ady ...

5 hours ago

The crest of the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) is seen at their headquarters in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 10, 2021. REUTERS/Andrew Kelly/File photo
5 hours ago

Fresno Man Caught With 1,500 Fentanyl Pills Sentenced to Five Years

Cardi B looks on during the presentation of designer Rousteing's Spring/Summer 2025 Women's ready-to-wear collection show for fashion house Balmain during Paris Fashion Week in Paris, France, September 25, 2024. (Reuters File)
5 hours ago

California Jury Clears Pop Star Cardi B of Assault Allegations in Civil Lawsuit

Democratic lawmakers in Texas
5 hours ago

How the US Congressional Redistricting War is Playing Out State by State

U.S. financier Jeffrey Epstein appears in a photograph taken for the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services' sex offender registry March 28, 2017 and obtained by Reuters July 10, 2019. New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services/Handout via REUTERS/File Photo
6 hours ago

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

6 hours ago

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

7 hours ago

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

The California Supreme Court (CalMatters/File)
7 hours ago

They Were Convicted of Gang Crimes. New CA Supreme Court Rulings Trim Their Sentences

Mike Briggs
7 hours ago

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

Search

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Send this to a friend