Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Did Silencing Snoop Dogg Lyrics at City Council Violate Speaker's Rights?
David Website Replacement
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 7 years ago on
February 13, 2018

Share


Politics 101
David Taub
Grizzly Fest is a go at Woodward Park.
Council voted 5-2 last week to allow the promoters of the two-day event to use the north Fresno park for a price of $100,000. The music and entertainment festival is scheduled for May 18-19.
By the city clerk’s count, 19 public speakers spoke, nearly evenly divided.
The most interesting moment during the 90-minute debate came when Dana Scott Schilperoort spoke — or more accurately, rapped — lyrics (see video above; Note: GV Wire buzzed out the naughty words; the silence is from the original video; listen to the Dr. Dre/Snoop Dogg version NSFW) from the headline act: Snoop Dogg.
The lyrics were crude and contained a series of four-letter words improper for print. Council president Esmeralda Soria shut down Schilperoort .
“Sir, sir, sir, sir, we are not going to allow that. …” Soria told Schilperoort.
“Oh, but we are going to allow Snoop Dogg to be in our community?” Schilperoort responded, facing the audience.
When Schilperoort attempted to continue with more of Snoop Dogg’s greatest hits, his microphone went silent.
“Sir, if you can to continue to … you blocked him?” Soria can be heard saying.
It is not clear who shut off Schilperoort’s mic or if it was done because of language or because he had turned away from the council to speak directly to the audience. Councilman Oliver Baines reminded the speaker to address the council, not the crowd (as dictated by Rule 12(b) of council procedures and Sec. 2-312 of the Municipal Code). Baines told GV Wire that council members do not have access to a switch to cut off the lectern microphone.
As Schilperoort continued again with an open mic, Soria reminded him his two minutes of speaking time had expired and asked him to step away. The audio again went silent, as a security guard ushered Schilperoort away, to the applause of the crowd.
But did Soria’s actions violate council policies and the First Amendment?
According to the Rules of Procedure for the City Council of the City of Fresno, 12(f), regarding order and decorum:
Any person who willfully engages in conduct which is designed to or is likely to provoke others to violent or riotous behavior, disturbs the peace of the meeting by loud and unreasonable noise, engages in other disruptive conduct which substantially interferes with the orderly conduct of business before the Council, and who fails, upon request of the Presiding Officer to cease such activity, shall be forthwith barred from further attendance at such meeting unless permission to and/or address the Council is granted by a majority vote of the Council. A person violating this subsection shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
There is no specific language in the rules or the Fresno Municipal Code as to whether foul language is considered disruptive conduct.  The First Amendment limits the government’s right to restrict speech.
However, one government accountability group said that Soria may have been within her rights.
“Council does have the authority to restrict language used by a speaker, in terms of civility. A city council does not have to put up with profanity and obscenity, Terry Francke, general counsel with Californians Aware, told GV Wire.
Soria did not respond to GV Wire’s request for comment by time of publication.

Council Fundraising Now Open

Today (Feb. 12), is the first day Fresno city council candidates can officially file to run for office and fundraise.
According to the city clerk’s website, four candidates have filed paperwork to run for District 3: Tate Hill, Daren Miller, Kimberly Tapscott-Munson and Sean Sanchez. Other candidates who have expressed interest but have yet to officially file include Barigye McCoy and Craig Scharton.
Current councilman Oliver Baines is termed out.
In District 7, Nelson Esparza, Veva Islas and Brian Whelan have turned in their paperwork. Councilman Clint Olivier is termed out.
For District 1 and 5, incumbents Esmeralda Soria and Luis Chavez (respectively) have filed.
The county clerk also has a role in accepting nomination papers, and sometimes the county and city lists do not match up. For example, the county list also has Rebecca Wardwell filing paperwork to run in District 3. Her name is not on the city clerk’s list.
The filing period ends March 9.

Perdue to Visit Farms

U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue will visit a number of farms during a three-day tour of the Golden State.
Starting Tuesday (Feb. 13), Perdue will visit the opening day of the World Ag Expo in Tulare.
On Wednesday, Perdue will tour Porterville Citrus, and Giacomazzi Orchard in Visalia. He then heads to Hanford to visit Fowler Packing, and DeGroot Dairy. From there, it is off to the Harris Woolf Almond Company in Coalinga. He’ll round out the busy day with stops in Gustine, Hollister and Tres Pinos.
Thursday morning, Perdue visits Uesugi Farms in Gilroy.

Bessinger Added to Air Board

Drew Bessinger is now officially a member of the Valley air board.
In a complicated selection method (described here), the Clovis city councilman won approval from the San Joaquin Valley Special City Selection Committee on Jan. 31, by a unanimous 35-0 vote.
Bessinger occupies the seat that was held by Fresno City Councilman Oliver Baines. His term on the air board expired at the end of 2017.
Bessinger’s first meeting is this Thursday (Feb. 15), 9 a.m. at the district office in Fresno.

Vasquez Finishes on Planning Commission

Roy Vasquez is moving on from the Fresno Planning Commission — and from Fresno. The longtime commissioner has accepted a position at Oxnard College in Ventura County.
The city honored him at the Feb. 8 council meeting.
Mayor Lee Brand has not announced an appointment to fill the vacancy.

Armstrong Remembered

The family of the late Harry Armstrong will hold a memorial service this Thursday, Feb. 15 at 12:30 p.m. The longtime Clovis city councilman passed away Jan. 18 at the age of 87. He retired from the council last year after four decades of public service.
The memorial and dedication of a Highway 168 interchange will be preceded by a lunch buffet at 11:30 a.m. at the Clovis Veterans Memorial District building. The public is welcome.

Brown Appoints Two from Valley

Gov. Jerry Brown appointed two Valley residents to a high-tech advisory board. Jose Gonzalez of Atwater and Janell Miller of Clovis will join the Computer Science Strategic Implementation Advisory Panel.
The new 23-member group, formed by a state law that went into effect last year, will help the state Dept. of Education develop guidelines to teach computer science in schools. The first meeting is March 1 in Sacramento.
Both Valley members are involved in education: Gonzalez is the superintendent of the Planada Elementary School District; Miller teaches at Washington Academic Middle School in the Sanger Unified School District.
Gonzalez is a Democrat; Miler is a Republican. There is no compensation for board members.

Give Credit Where Credit Is Due

Kudos to Valley Public Radio (KVPR-FM 89.3) for last week’s scoop on an immigration detention facility in downtown Fresno hidden in plain sight. They first ran the story Feb. 6.
In the copycat nature of media, other local TV stations picked up on the story as well. ABC 30 reported about it on Feb. 7; CBS 47 on Feb. 8. Neither group credited KVPR for first reporting the story. The TV stations also interviewed immigration attorney Camille Cook; KVPR talked to her first.
Neither news director replied to GV Wire’s request for comment.

DON'T MISS

Pope Francis in Critical Condition After Long Respiratory Crisis

DON'T MISS

Musk Gives All Federal Workers 48 Hours to Explain What They Did Last Week

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Suspends 2 Players, Removes Another Amid Gambling Investigation

DON'T MISS

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

DON'T MISS

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

DON'T MISS

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

DON'T MISS

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

DON'T MISS

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

DON'T MISS

Trump Fires Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Two Other Military Officers

DON'T MISS

Less Is More: 5 Ingredient Dinners Are Easier Than You Think

UP NEXT

Musk Gives All Federal Workers 48 Hours to Explain What They Did Last Week

UP NEXT

Fresno State Suspends 2 Players, Removes Another Amid Gambling Investigation

UP NEXT

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

UP NEXT

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

UP NEXT

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

UP NEXT

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

UP NEXT

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

UP NEXT

Trump Fires Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Two Other Military Officers

UP NEXT

Less Is More: 5 Ingredient Dinners Are Easier Than You Think

UP NEXT

Trump-Putin Summit Preparations Are Underway, Russia Says

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

4 hours ago

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

4 hours ago

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

10 hours ago

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

10 hours ago

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

10 hours ago

Trump Fires Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Two Other Military Officers

10 hours ago

Less Is More: 5 Ingredient Dinners Are Easier Than You Think

10 hours ago

Trump-Putin Summit Preparations Are Underway, Russia Says

10 hours ago

Warren Buffett Offers Trump Some Advice While Celebrating Berkshire’s Success

11 hours ago

Hungarians Will Decide Whether Ukraine Can Join the European Union, Orbán Says

11 hours ago

Pope Francis in Critical Condition After Long Respiratory Crisis

ROME — Pope Francis was in critical condition Saturday after he suffered a prolonged asthmatic respiratory crisis while being treated for pn...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Pope Francis in Critical Condition After Long Respiratory Crisis

4 hours ago

Musk Gives All Federal Workers 48 Hours to Explain What They Did Last Week

4 hours ago

Fresno State Suspends 2 Players, Removes Another Amid Gambling Investigation

4 hours ago

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

4 hours ago

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

10 hours ago

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

10 hours ago

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

10 hours ago

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend