Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
22 States Sue to Stop Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order
d8a347b41db1ddee634e2d67d08798c102ef09ac
By The New York Times
Published 2 weeks ago on
January 21, 2025

President Donald Trump holds up an executive order after signing it on stage at the Capitol One Arena, following his inauguration in Washington, Jan. 20, 2025. Attorneys general from 18 states sued Trump on Tuesday to block an executive order that refuses to recognize the U.S.-born children of unauthorized immigrants as citizens, contrary to the 14th Amendment. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

PHILADELPHIA — Attorneys general from 22 states sued President Donald Trump on Tuesday to block an executive order that refuses to recognize the U.S.-born children of immigrants who entered the country illegally as citizens, the opening salvo in what promises to be a long legal battle over the Trump administration’s immigration policies.

The complaint, filed in U.S. District Court in Massachusetts, was joined by the cities of San Francisco and Washington, D.C.

New Jersey, California and Massachusetts Lead the Charge

The states view Trump’s attempt to limit birthright citizenship as “extraordinary and extreme,” said New Jersey Attorney General Matthew J. Platkin, who led the legal effort along with the attorneys general from California and Massachusetts. “Presidents are powerful, but he is not a king. He cannot rewrite the Constitution with a stroke of the pen.”

On Monday, in the opening hours of his second term as president, Trump signed an order declaring that future children born to immigrants without permanent legal status would no longer be treated as citizens. The order would extend even to the children of some mothers in the country legally but temporarily, such as foreign students or tourists.

Trump’s executive order asserts that the children of such noncitizens are not “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States and thus aren’t covered by the 14th Amendment’s long-standing constitutional guarantee.

14th Amendment Guarantees Citizenship to Babies Born in the US

The order flew in the face of more than 100 years of legal precedent, when the courts and the executive branch interpreted the 14th Amendment as guaranteeing citizenship to every baby born in the United States, regardless of their parents’ legal status. The courts recognized only a narrow exception for the children of accredited diplomats.

But there are signs the judiciary could be divided on the issue. Judge James C. Ho, who Trump nominated to the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, has been more sympathetic to some of Trump’s arguments, likening immigrants who enter the U.S. illegally to an invading army. That comparison has also been made by lawyers for the state of Texas and another declaration by Trump that illegal crossings at the southern border amount to an “ongoing invasion.”

Still, that appeals court does not hear cases originating in Massachusetts, and other courts are unlikely to even consider the Trump administration’s arguments about constitutional interpretation without a new law from Congress, said Gerard Magliocca, a professor at the Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law. He cited recent cases in which the Supreme Court ruled that the executive branch can’t single-handedly address the biggest political controversies, known as “major questions.”

“If that’s true of student loans or COVID-19 rules or whatever, you’d think it would be true of citizenship as well,” he said. “The states are right, and the courts are probably going to agree with them.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

By Mattahias Schwartz/Doug Mills
c. 2025 The New York Times Company

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

San Diego Added to Southwest’s Nonstop Destinations From Fresno Airport

DON'T MISS

Clovis Man Gets 27 Years to Life for Attempted Murder of Estranged Wife

DON'T MISS

$3 Million Gift Will Mean Laptops, Solar Panels, Larger Chapel for This Fresno University

DON'T MISS

Ohtani’s Ex-Interpreter Is Sentenced to 4 Years and 9 Months in Sports Betting Case

DON'T MISS

NCAA Changes Transgender Policy to Limit Women’s Competition to Athletes Assigned Female at Birth

DON'T MISS

Israel Starts Planning for Palestinians to Leave Gaza Despite International Rejection

DON'T MISS

Mayor Says Fresno Needs High-Speed Rail Despite Cost Overruns

DON'T MISS

12 States to Sue Over DOGE Access to Government Payment Systems Containing Personal Data

DON'T MISS

Irv Gotti, Music Executive Who Created Murder Inc. Records, Dies at 54

DON'T MISS

ABC30 Has a New News Director. She’s a Familiar TV Face.

UP NEXT

Clovis Man Gets 27 Years to Life for Attempted Murder of Estranged Wife

UP NEXT

$3 Million Gift Will Mean Laptops, Solar Panels, Larger Chapel for This Fresno University

UP NEXT

Ohtani’s Ex-Interpreter Is Sentenced to 4 Years and 9 Months in Sports Betting Case

UP NEXT

NCAA Changes Transgender Policy to Limit Women’s Competition to Athletes Assigned Female at Birth

UP NEXT

Israel Starts Planning for Palestinians to Leave Gaza Despite International Rejection

UP NEXT

Mayor Says Fresno Needs High-Speed Rail Despite Cost Overruns

UP NEXT

12 States to Sue Over DOGE Access to Government Payment Systems Containing Personal Data

UP NEXT

Irv Gotti, Music Executive Who Created Murder Inc. Records, Dies at 54

UP NEXT

ABC30 Has a New News Director. She’s a Familiar TV Face.

UP NEXT

California’s EV Sales Stall. So What Happens to Landmark Mandate?

Ohtani’s Ex-Interpreter Is Sentenced to 4 Years and 9 Months in Sports Betting Case

5 hours ago

NCAA Changes Transgender Policy to Limit Women’s Competition to Athletes Assigned Female at Birth

5 hours ago

Israel Starts Planning for Palestinians to Leave Gaza Despite International Rejection

5 hours ago

Mayor Says Fresno Needs High-Speed Rail Despite Cost Overruns

5 hours ago

12 States to Sue Over DOGE Access to Government Payment Systems Containing Personal Data

5 hours ago

Irv Gotti, Music Executive Who Created Murder Inc. Records, Dies at 54

5 hours ago

ABC30 Has a New News Director. She’s a Familiar TV Face.

6 hours ago

California’s EV Sales Stall. So What Happens to Landmark Mandate?

6 hours ago

31 Arrested in Fresno Human Trafficking Operation

7 hours ago

Find Your Next Career Opportunity Today at FUSD Expo

7 hours ago

San Diego Added to Southwest’s Nonstop Destinations From Fresno Airport

Southwest Airlines added a fourth nonstop destination to routes to and from Fresno Yosemite International Airport. Beginning Oct. 2, travele...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

San Diego Added to Southwest’s Nonstop Destinations From Fresno Airport

3 hours ago

Clovis Man Gets 27 Years to Life for Attempted Murder of Estranged Wife

3 hours ago

$3 Million Gift Will Mean Laptops, Solar Panels, Larger Chapel for This Fresno University

Ippei Mizuhara, former interpreter for Los Angeles Dodgers baseball star Shohei Ohtani arrives at federal court for bank and tax fraud sentencing on Thursday, Feb. 6, 2025, in Santa Ana, Calif. (AP/Damian Dovarganes)
5 hours ago

Ohtani’s Ex-Interpreter Is Sentenced to 4 Years and 9 Months in Sports Betting Case

The San Jose State University Spartans line up for the playing of the national anthem and player introductions for their NCAA Mountain West women's volleyball game against the Colorado State University Rams in Fort Collins, Colo., on Oct. 3, 2024. (AP File)
5 hours ago

NCAA Changes Transgender Policy to Limit Women’s Competition to Athletes Assigned Female at Birth

5 hours ago

Israel Starts Planning for Palestinians to Leave Gaza Despite International Rejection

5 hours ago

Mayor Says Fresno Needs High-Speed Rail Despite Cost Overruns

5 hours ago

12 States to Sue Over DOGE Access to Government Payment Systems Containing Personal Data

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend