Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Montana Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court Ruling That Allows Gender-Affirming Care for Minors
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 1 hour ago on
December 11, 2024

Demonstrators gather on the steps of the Montana state Capitol protesting anti-LGBTQ+ legislation in Helena, Mont., March 15, 2021. (AP File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

HELENA, Mont. — A Montana law banning gender-affirming medical care for transgender minors will remain temporarily blocked, the state Supreme Court ruled Wednesday, after justices agreed with a lower court judge who found the law likely violates the state’s constitutional right to privacy.

The case against the Montana law now goes to trial before District Court Judge Jason Marks in Missoula. The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in June, as well, after the Biden administration sought to block bans in more than half the states.

Legislative debate over Montana’s bill drew national attention in the spring of 2023 after Republicans punished Democratic Rep. Zooey Zephyr — the first transgender woman elected to the state’s Legislature — for admonishing lawmakers who supported the bill.

Marks blocked the law in late September 2023, just days before it was to take effect. He agreed with transgender youth, their families and health care providers that the law is likely unconstitutional and would harm the mental and physical health of minors with gender dysphoria, rather than protect them from experimental treatments, as supporters said it would.

The judge noted the same Republican-controlled Legislature passed a law saying patients, including minors, have a right to receive treatment with experimental drugs — as long as it’s recommended by a health care provider and they give consent.

Marks said he could only conclude the Legislature’s stated intent in passing the law was “disingenuous” and it seemed more likely its purpose is to “ban an outcome deemed undesirable by the Montana Legislature, veiled as protection for minors.”

Law Would Prohibit Puberty Blockers, Hormone Treatment, and Surgery

The law sought to prohibit the use of puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and surgical treatments for gender dysphoria. However, cisgender minors would still be able to receive puberty blockers to treat early puberty or surgical procedures to treat intersex conditions, the plaintiffs argued.

Montana is one of at least 26 states that have passed bans on gender-affirming medical care for minors and most face lawsuits. Some bans have been temporarily blocked by courts, while others have been allowed to take effect. Fifteen states have enacted protections for gender-affirming medical care for minors.

In Montana’s case, transgender youth argued the law would ban them from continuing to receive gender-affirming medical care, violating their constitutional rights to equal protection, the right to seek health care and the right to dignity.

Their parents said the law would violate their constitutional right to make medical decisions for their children and two medical providers said it would prevent them from providing effective and necessary care to their patients.

“Montana’s ban is a direct assault on the freedom and well-being of transgender youth, their families, and their medical providers,” Malita Picasso, staff attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union, has said.

Treatments for gender dysphoria meet standards of care approved by major medical organizations including the American Medical Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, the ACLU argued in its complaint.

One of the young plaintiffs was dismissed from the lawsuit in September 2024 after turning 18.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Is the Trump Administration Planning a Massive Increase in Legal Immigration?

DON'T MISS

Is Luigi Mangione a Hero? This Argument Shows a Glimpse Into an Unusual American Moment

DON'T MISS

FBI Director Wray Says He Intends to Resign at End of Biden’s Term in January

DON'T MISS

Will Resistant Marin County Change After a Pro-Housing Gov. Newsom Just Moved In?

DON'T MISS

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court Ruling That Allows Gender-Affirming Care for Minors

DON'T MISS

California Judges Say They’re Underpaid, and Their New Lawsuit Could Cost Taxpayers Millions

DON'T MISS

Many More Incorrect Fresno County Ballots Found, but Election Results Not Affected

DON'T MISS

6 Arrested in Tulare Gang-Related Fight, Investigation Continues

DON'T MISS

House Voting on $895B Defense Bill With Military Pay Raise, Ban on Transgender Care for Minors

DON'T MISS

Gastineau Confronts Favre in Documentary for His ‘Dive’ on Strahan’s Record-Breaking Sack

UP NEXT

Is Luigi Mangione a Hero? This Argument Shows a Glimpse Into an Unusual American Moment

UP NEXT

FBI Director Wray Says He Intends to Resign at End of Biden’s Term in January

UP NEXT

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court Ruling That Allows Gender-Affirming Care for Minors

UP NEXT

California Judges Say They’re Underpaid, and Their New Lawsuit Could Cost Taxpayers Millions

UP NEXT

Many More Incorrect Fresno County Ballots Found, but Election Results Not Affected

UP NEXT

6 Arrested in Tulare Gang-Related Fight, Investigation Continues

UP NEXT

House Voting on $895B Defense Bill With Military Pay Raise, Ban on Transgender Care for Minors

UP NEXT

Gastineau Confronts Favre in Documentary for His ‘Dive’ on Strahan’s Record-Breaking Sack

UP NEXT

High-Speed Rail Authority Breaks Ground on Fresno Four-Lane Grade Separation

UP NEXT

The Truth About Dry January: Does It Work?

Will Resistant Marin County Change After a Pro-Housing Gov. Newsom Just Moved In?

1 hour ago

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court Ruling That Allows Gender-Affirming Care for Minors

1 hour ago

California Judges Say They’re Underpaid, and Their New Lawsuit Could Cost Taxpayers Millions

1 hour ago

Many More Incorrect Fresno County Ballots Found, but Election Results Not Affected

2 hours ago

6 Arrested in Tulare Gang-Related Fight, Investigation Continues

2 hours ago

House Voting on $895B Defense Bill With Military Pay Raise, Ban on Transgender Care for Minors

2 hours ago

Gastineau Confronts Favre in Documentary for His ‘Dive’ on Strahan’s Record-Breaking Sack

2 hours ago

High-Speed Rail Authority Breaks Ground on Fresno Four-Lane Grade Separation

3 hours ago

The Truth About Dry January: Does It Work?

3 hours ago

Judge Rejects Sale of Infowars to The Onion

3 hours ago

Is the Trump Administration Planning a Massive Increase in Legal Immigration?

President-elect Donald Trump has promised a mass deportation effort that will remove all undocumented immigrants from the country. Margare...

46 minutes ago

46 minutes ago

Is the Trump Administration Planning a Massive Increase in Legal Immigration?

Luigi Nicholas Mangione is escorted into Blair County Courthouse, Tuesday, Dec. 10, 2024, in Hollidaysburg, Pa. (AP Photo/Gary M. Baranec)
53 minutes ago

Is Luigi Mangione a Hero? This Argument Shows a Glimpse Into an Unusual American Moment

1 hour ago

FBI Director Wray Says He Intends to Resign at End of Biden’s Term in January

Newsom
1 hour ago

Will Resistant Marin County Change After a Pro-Housing Gov. Newsom Just Moved In?

Demonstrators gather on the steps of the Montana state Capitol protesting anti-LGBTQ+ legislation in Helena, Mont., March 15, 2021. (AP File)
1 hour ago

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court Ruling That Allows Gender-Affirming Care for Minors

1 hour ago

California Judges Say They’re Underpaid, and Their New Lawsuit Could Cost Taxpayers Millions

2 hours ago

Many More Incorrect Fresno County Ballots Found, but Election Results Not Affected

2 hours ago

6 Arrested in Tulare Gang-Related Fight, Investigation Continues

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend