Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Can Rahm Emanuel Flip the Script Again?
d8a347b41db1ddee634e2d67d08798c102ef09ac
By The New York Times
Published 6 days ago on
December 4, 2024

U.S. Ambassador to Japan Rahm Emanuel speaks to media after meeting with Japanese Foreign Minister Yoko Kamikawa at the foreign ministry in Tokyo, on Nov. 30, 2023. (AP File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Bret Stephens
Opinion
Opinion by Bret Stephens on Dec. 3, 2024.

There’s a buzz around Rahm Emanuel — the former Bill Clinton adviser, former Illinois congressman, former chief of staff to President Barack Obama, former mayor of Chicago — possibly becoming the next head of the Democratic National Committee. The progressive left despises his pragmatism and liberal centrism. He has a reputation for abrasiveness. And his current job, as ambassador to Japan, has traditionally served as a posting for high-level political has-beens like Walter Mondale and Howard Baker.

But he also has a gift for constructing winning coalitions with difficult, unexpected partners.

More on that in a moment. When I met him for breakfast this week at a New York City hotel, what he wanted to talk about is a looming crisis in Asia. “What started as two wars in two theaters is now one war in two separate theaters,” he said of the conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East. “We need to ensure that it does not expand into a third theater.”

How soon might that happen? I mention 2027, a year that’s often seen as China’s target date for reunification with Taiwan, if necessary by force.

“I think it’s actually 2025,” he said.

What Emanuel has in mind are Asia’s other flashpoints, including along the 38th parallel that divides North and South Korea, where Russia is “poking” Kim Jong Un, the North Korean leader, “to do something” and where South Korea’s president briefly declared martial law, and also in the South China Sea, where China and the Philippines are coming to blows over Beijing’s illegal maritime claims. Unlike with Taipei, to which America’s obligations are deliberately ambiguous, with Manila and Seoul our defense commitments are ironclad.

That could mean war for the United States on multiple unexpected fronts. Emanuel’s tenure as ambassador was distinguished by his role in engineering two historic rapprochements — last year between Japan and South Korea and this year between Japan and the Philippines — that, along with the AUKUS defense pact with Britain and Australia, form part of a broad diplomatic effort by the Biden administration to contain China.

The Chinese, Emanuel said, “have a theory of the case in the Indo-Pacific. We have a theory of the case. Their attempt is to isolate Australia, isolate the Philippines and put all the pressure on that country,” often through abusive trade practices. “Our job is to flip the script and isolate China through their actions.”

That seems like a tall order now that Donald Trump is returning to Washington promising to impose exactly the kinds of abusive trade practices that drive allies and potential allies away. That topic provides an opening for me to change the subject to how Democrats might repair their fortunes.

“I was waiting,” he wisecracks. “I knew that was foreplay.”

Emanuel recognizes the anti-incumbent mood along with missed messaging chances by Kamala Harris’ campaign. But there was a larger mistake by Democrats, he said, many years in the making. In 2006, when as a congressman Emanuel was recruiting veterans to help flip Congress to the Democrats, the party was “anti-Washington, anti-establishment.” It opposed the war in Iraq, and it later channeled some of the outrage Americans felt toward the bankers who never paid a price for the 2008 financial crisis. (Emanuel, who had his own stint in investment banking, said he argued for “Old Testament justice” for those bankers when he was in the Obama White House.)

Then came the pandemic. “In COVID, the Democrats put on the outfit of the establishment. ‘We’re going to close schools, you’re going to close these jobs, you listen to the scientists, listen to the science,’” he said. “As both a child of a doctor and a brother of a doctor, sometimes you need a second opinion.”

So how do Democrats reclaim their old advantages?

“From ’68 to ’88, a 20-year run, you had ‘law and order,’ ‘welfare queens,’ Willie Horton — that was the Republican message,” Emanuel recalls. “Bill Clinton comes around and takes the equation of crime, immigration, drugs, welfare, the whole basket of cultural issues, and gets them off the table.” All of these required Clinton to pick at least as many fights with his party’s left as he picked against Republicans, and even now there are parts of the Democratic Party that are still sore about it.

“As I always say to the left, what part of the peace and prosperity were you most upset with?” he asked. “Which part did you hate? Was it the income growth, the employment growth, the drop in welfare rolls, the drop in crime, the fact that America was respected around the world, peace in the Middle East? Which part did you hate most?”

Emanuel doesn’t think it’s impossible for Democrats to repeat Clinton’s feat, though whether it will take one bad election or more remains to be seen. As in his views about the geopolitics of Asia, where Chinese blundering and bullying should play to America’s advantage, so too in domestic politics. Trump “is going to turn the Oval Office into eBay,” he predicts. It will be the Democrats’ challenge to illuminate the fact. The trick in both cases is not to undermine your own side as you try to defeat the other.

“I think Democrats prefer losing and being morally right to winning,” he said. “Me, I’m not into moral victory speeches. I’m into winning.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
c. 2024 The New York Times Company

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

State Offers $2,000 Vouchers for E-Bikes. Will You Be Eligible?

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest 13 at DUI Checkpoint, Announce Holiday Patrols

DON'T MISS

Polygamous Sect Leader Gets 50 Years in Prison in Scheme to Orchestrate Sex Involving Children

DON'T MISS

California to Consider Requiring Mental Health Warnings on Social Media Sites

DON'T MISS

New California Sen. Adam Schiff Wants to Be More Than a Trump Antagonist

DON'T MISS

Did UC Merced Students Tip the US House Election for Democrat Adam Gray?

DON'T MISS

Bookstore Staffers Receive Holiday Bonuses From Author James Patterson

DON'T MISS

Trump Calls Trudeau the ‘Governor’ of ‘The Great State of Canada’

DON'T MISS

Taiwan Says China Has Deployed Largest Fleet of Ships in Decades

DON'T MISS

Californians Send Loud Message: The State Is a Mess

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest 13 at DUI Checkpoint, Announce Holiday Patrols

UP NEXT

Polygamous Sect Leader Gets 50 Years in Prison in Scheme to Orchestrate Sex Involving Children

UP NEXT

California to Consider Requiring Mental Health Warnings on Social Media Sites

UP NEXT

New California Sen. Adam Schiff Wants to Be More Than a Trump Antagonist

UP NEXT

Did UC Merced Students Tip the US House Election for Democrat Adam Gray?

UP NEXT

Bookstore Staffers Receive Holiday Bonuses From Author James Patterson

UP NEXT

Trump Calls Trudeau the ‘Governor’ of ‘The Great State of Canada’

UP NEXT

Taiwan Says China Has Deployed Largest Fleet of Ships in Decades

UP NEXT

Californians Send Loud Message: The State Is a Mess

UP NEXT

City of Fresno’s White-Collar Employees Say They’re Ready to Strike

California to Consider Requiring Mental Health Warnings on Social Media Sites

58 minutes ago

New California Sen. Adam Schiff Wants to Be More Than a Trump Antagonist

1 hour ago

Did UC Merced Students Tip the US House Election for Democrat Adam Gray?

1 hour ago

Bookstore Staffers Receive Holiday Bonuses From Author James Patterson

2 hours ago

Trump Calls Trudeau the ‘Governor’ of ‘The Great State of Canada’

2 hours ago

Taiwan Says China Has Deployed Largest Fleet of Ships in Decades

2 hours ago

Californians Send Loud Message: The State Is a Mess

2 hours ago

City of Fresno’s White-Collar Employees Say They’re Ready to Strike

2 hours ago

Man Is Charged With Burning American Flag During Washington Protest Over Netanyahu Visit

2 hours ago

OpenAI Releases AI Video Generator Sora but Limits How It Depicts People

2 hours ago

State Offers $2,000 Vouchers for E-Bikes. Will You Be Eligible?

California’s quest to improve its air quality will take a new turn on Dec. 18 with the launch of the E-Bike Incentive Project that wil...

7 minutes ago

7 minutes ago

State Offers $2,000 Vouchers for E-Bikes. Will You Be Eligible?

15 minutes ago

Fresno Police Arrest 13 at DUI Checkpoint, Announce Holiday Patrols

53 minutes ago

Polygamous Sect Leader Gets 50 Years in Prison in Scheme to Orchestrate Sex Involving Children

58 minutes ago

California to Consider Requiring Mental Health Warnings on Social Media Sites

1 hour ago

New California Sen. Adam Schiff Wants to Be More Than a Trump Antagonist

UC Merced Students register voters for Nov. 5, 2024 election
1 hour ago

Did UC Merced Students Tip the US House Election for Democrat Adam Gray?

2 hours ago

Bookstore Staffers Receive Holiday Bonuses From Author James Patterson

Photo of President Donald Trump, left, and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
2 hours ago

Trump Calls Trudeau the ‘Governor’ of ‘The Great State of Canada’

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend