Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Still Need Your Landline? California Just Stopped AT&T from Pulling the Plug
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 4 weeks ago on
June 21, 2024

California’s Public Utilities Commission stands firm on AT&T’s obligation to provide landlines in underserved areas despite company pushback. (Shutterstock)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

California’s Public Utilities Commission this week rejected AT&T’s application to stop providing landlines and other services in areas where there is no other option.

Author Profile Picture

Khari Johnson

CalMatters

Its 4-0 vote came after a judge determined the application by AT&T California was “fatally flawed.”

AT&T is the “carrier of last resort” for California, an official designation that means it covers most major cities, rural communities, and the land of more than 100 tribal governments. The commission first labeled AT&T a carrier of last resort nearly three decades ago.

More than a dozen speakers during the public comment period at today’s meeting supported keeping AT&T’s carrier-of-last resort designation and landlines. Previously, more than 5,000 public comments were written in response to AT&T’s application and nearly 6,000 people attended eight public forums held earlier this year. Numerous commenters said that, due to inconsistent cell coverage in their area, their landline is their primary means of communication with family, medical providers, and the outside world in the event of an emergency. Those concerns are particularly important for senior citizens, people with disabilities, and people who say they are sensitive to electromagnetic activity.

AT&T has argued that the people its landlines are now serving in the areas in question can turn to voice over internet service offered by cable providers or to mobile phone service offered by wireless providers like Verizon.

Steve Hogle lives in rural Sonoma County and told the commission today that spotty cell phone coverage was a danger to his family during the 2019 Kincade wildfire.

“If we didn’t have a copper landline we would’ve not known about the evacuation and the extremely serious fire that went through here and most of our property,” he said. “I don’t want (voice over internet service) because if there’s no power, there’s no internet, and all these things are of extreme importance to the safety of this community.”

AT&T’s Controversial Attempts to End Carrier-of-Last-Resort Designation

The company has attempted to end carrier-of-last-resort designation obligations in roughly half of U.S. states, but those efforts don’t always stay within the confines of the law, according to federal prosecutors. In 2022, AT&T Illinois agreed to pay a $23 million fine to resolve charges it attempted to influence former Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan.

“If we didn’t have a copper landline we would’ve not known about the extremely serious fire.”

Steve Hogle, Sonoma County

The commission’s decision does not bring an end to the carrier-of-last-resort debates in California. AT&T and roughly a dozen members of the California Legislature have publicly expressed support for Assembly Bill 2797, which would effectively bring an end to some carrier-of-last-resort obligations. The California State Association of Counties, Rural County Representatives of California, and Urban Counties of California said last week that they oppose the bill, adding in a letter to the bill’s author that it would “leave large swaths of the most vulnerable Californians without reliable and affordable access to basic telephone service.”

The Public Utilities Commission also voted 5-0 today to begin proceedings to change rules for companies that are designated a carrier of last resort. It’s time to modernize those rules, said commission president Alice Reynolds, because a lot has changed in the past 30 years, including a shift toward cell phones and away from landlines, and it’s now part of the commission’s mandate to make high-speed internet access universally available.

“I’m hopeful that through this new rulemaking, we can really modernize these programs and move towards the future to meet our broadband for all objectives,” she said ahead of the vote.

About the Author

Khari Johnson is part of the economy team and is CalMatters’ first tech reporter.

About CalMatters

CalMatters is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom committed to explaining California policy and politics.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Obama, Pelosi and Democrats Make a Fresh Push for Biden to Reconsider 2024 Race

DON'T MISS

The Last Cards Have Been Dealt as the Iconic Mirage Closes Its Doors on the Las Vegas Strip

DON'T MISS

Visalia Man Faces Third Strike for Serial Burglary

DON'T MISS

American Who Made Social Media Threats Against Taylor Swift Detained Ahead of German Concert

DON'T MISS

Netanyahu Makes Surprise Visit to Troops in Gaza Days Before Speech to US Congress

DON'T MISS

The Grateful Dead and Francis Ford Coppola Are Among the Newest Kennedy Center Honors Recipients

DON'T MISS

Magic Co-Founder Pat Williams, Who Helped Bring Team to Orlando, Dies at 84

DON'T MISS

US Army Honors Nisei Combat Unit That Helped Liberate Tuscany From Nazi-Fascist Forces in WWII

DON'T MISS

Greenhouses Are Becoming More Popular, but There’s Little Research on How to Protect Workers

DON'T MISS

European Leaders Discuss Migration and Ukraine at a UK Summit as Concern Grows About Direction of US

UP NEXT

Visalia Man Faces Third Strike for Serial Burglary

UP NEXT

Majority of Americans, Including Republicans, Back Biden’s Supreme Court Term Limit Plan

UP NEXT

Gambling Interests Gave $1M to California Lawmakers. Did It Influence Their Votes?

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in 2023 Shooting Death

UP NEXT

Trump Credits Chart for Saving His Life, His Former White House Doctor Says

UP NEXT

Schiff Calls on Biden to Drop Out of Presidential Race

UP NEXT

After Reshaping Las Vegas, the Mirage to Be Reinvented as Part of a Massive Hard Rock Makeover

UP NEXT

Former Mayor Known for Guaranteed Income Programs Launches Bid for California Lieutenant Governor

UP NEXT

Power Restored at Overcrowded California Prison Amid Heat Wave

UP NEXT

California Seizes Over 5,200 Pounds of Illegal Cannabis at State Parks, One in Tulare County

American Who Made Social Media Threats Against Taylor Swift Detained Ahead of German Concert

39 mins ago

Netanyahu Makes Surprise Visit to Troops in Gaza Days Before Speech to US Congress

41 mins ago

The Grateful Dead and Francis Ford Coppola Are Among the Newest Kennedy Center Honors Recipients

57 mins ago

Magic Co-Founder Pat Williams, Who Helped Bring Team to Orlando, Dies at 84

1 hour ago

US Army Honors Nisei Combat Unit That Helped Liberate Tuscany From Nazi-Fascist Forces in WWII

1 hour ago

Greenhouses Are Becoming More Popular, but There’s Little Research on How to Protect Workers

1 hour ago

European Leaders Discuss Migration and Ukraine at a UK Summit as Concern Grows About Direction of US

2 hours ago

Newly Arrived Migrants Encounter Hazards of Food Delivery on the Streets of NYC: Robbers

2 hours ago

WNBA Players’ Union Head Concerned League Is Being Undervalued in New Media Deal

2 hours ago

What the Main Characters at the RNC Say About the Party

2 hours ago

Obama, Pelosi and Democrats Make a Fresh Push for Biden to Reconsider 2024 Race

WASHINGTON — Former president Barack Obama has privately expressed concerns to Democrats about President Joe Biden’s candidacy, and Speaker ...

7 mins ago

7 mins ago

Obama, Pelosi and Democrats Make a Fresh Push for Biden to Reconsider 2024 Race

9 mins ago

The Last Cards Have Been Dealt as the Iconic Mirage Closes Its Doors on the Las Vegas Strip

27 mins ago

Visalia Man Faces Third Strike for Serial Burglary

39 mins ago

American Who Made Social Media Threats Against Taylor Swift Detained Ahead of German Concert

41 mins ago

Netanyahu Makes Surprise Visit to Troops in Gaza Days Before Speech to US Congress

57 mins ago

The Grateful Dead and Francis Ford Coppola Are Among the Newest Kennedy Center Honors Recipients

1 hour ago

Magic Co-Founder Pat Williams, Who Helped Bring Team to Orlando, Dies at 84

1 hour ago

US Army Honors Nisei Combat Unit That Helped Liberate Tuscany From Nazi-Fascist Forces in WWII

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend