Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Why California Regulators Have to Protect Both Consumers and Company Profits
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 11 months ago on
June 4, 2024

California's Public Utilities Commission grapples with balancing consumer protection and utility profitability, a delicate act with far-reaching implications. (CalMatters/Ted Soqui)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Southern Pacific Railroad wielded almost total control over California’s politics, angering farmers who believed they were being gouged by high freight rates and fueling a powerful populist movement.

Dan Walters Profile Picture
Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Farmers’ complaints spawned several efforts to regulate them and finally gave birth in 1911 to the California Railroad Commission. Just a year later, the commission’s rate-setting authority was expanded to natural gas, electric power, telephone and water utilities. In 1946, its name was changed to the California Public Utilities Commission.

The commission’s five members, all appointed by the governor, oversee hundreds of billions of dollars in utility bills each year, issuing its decrees after mind-numbingly complex legal and financial proceedings.

In theory, the CPUC is protecting customers of monopolistic utilities. However it also implements policy decrees, such as shifting power generation to renewable sources, and must – in its rate-setting role – ensure that the regulated utilities earn enough profit to maintain access to capital and debt markets.

The Impact of Regulation on California’s Power Rates

It’s that latter role that comes into play when the CPUC sanctions sharp increases in electric power rates, as it has been doing in recent years, much to the dismay of both residential customers and businesses that need electricity to survive.

California households and businesses now pay the nation’s highest power rates, although their actual power bills are marginally lower vis-a-vis other states due to California’s relatively temperate climate.

Thirty-six years ago, California voters subjected insurance premiums to the same kind of regulation by passing Proposition 103. It shifted the state insurance commissioner from an appointee of the governor to an elected position and gave the office new regulatory authority.

The measure’s sponsors promised that regulation would maintain a lid on consumer insurance costs and contend that it’s done so. However, unlike electric utilities, insurers are not monopolies and cannot be compelled to do business in California, so the insurance commissioner has the implicit duty to also maintain their profitability so they continue to offer coverage.

Over the last couple of years, in response to costly payouts for wildfires, insurers have been leaving the state or refusing to renew policies in fire-prone regions. Left without insurance, homeowners have flocked to the insurer of last resort, the California FAIR plan, which not only has high rates but imposes strict limits on coverage.

It’s a crisis, affecting not only current property owners, but those who aspire to homeownership and must have insurance to obtain mortgages.

Proposed Overhaul and Future of California’s Insurance Industry

Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara has proposed a regulatory overhaul to entice insurers to continue writing policies in California. It would allow them to include projections of future losses and the costs of reinsurance in premiums and speed up rate change rulings.

Lara is drawing fire from Consumer Watchdog, whose leaders wrote Prop. 103 and which has received millions of dollars in “intervenor fees” for participating in rate-setting proceedings. However, Lara draws support from legislators whose constituents are seeing their policies vanish and from Gov. Gavin Newsom. Last week, Newsom endorsed one aspect of Lara’s plan by submitting a budget trailer bill that would, if enacted, speed up rate-setting cases.

“This proposal requires the Department of Insurance to modernize and streamline its rate application process to get back to the expedited timelines outlined in Prop. 103,” Alex Stack, a spokesperson for the governor, said.

What’s happening underscores how regulators must protect the profitability of the corporations they oversee. It’s something to keep in mind as the state expands financial regulation of the health care industry, which is by far California’s biggest economic sector.

Ultimately there’s no free lunch.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Edman Delivers in 10th as Dodgers Weather Myers’ Pinch-Hit Slam for Win Over Marlins

DON'T MISS

Amazon Launches Its First Internet Satellites to Compete Against SpaceX’s Starlinks

DON'T MISS

Numbers That Matter From the First 100 Days of Trump’s Second Term

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Team Has Disrupted Some $430 Billion in Federal Funds, Top Democrats Say

DON'T MISS

Police Saddled Up for Alcohol Sting During Clovis Rodeo, 22 Arrested

DON'T MISS

Supply and Demand: Less Food Means Higher Prices – or Does It?

DON'T MISS

This Summer at the Movies, Superheroes, From ‘Superman’ to ‘Fantastic Four,’ Return

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Man, Linked to Norteño Gang, Sentenced for Manufacturing Explosives

DON'T MISS

Shedeur Sanders Was Not the Only Prospect to Receive a Prank Call During the NFL Draft

DON'T MISS

US Consumer Confidence Plunges to Lowest in 5 Years on Tariff Worries

UP NEXT

Trump’s Team Has Disrupted Some $430 Billion in Federal Funds, Top Democrats Say

UP NEXT

Supply and Demand: Less Food Means Higher Prices – or Does It?

UP NEXT

US Consumer Confidence Plunges to Lowest in 5 Years on Tariff Worries

UP NEXT

Coca-Cola Reports Better-Than-Expected Quarterly Profit, Says It Can Manage Through Tariffs

UP NEXT

Pre-Tariffs Stockpiling Boosts US Goods Trade Deficit to Record High

UP NEXT

US Job Openings Fall in March; Layoffs Decline

UP NEXT

Trump Administration Allows Temporary Sales of Summertime Higher-Ethanol Fuel

UP NEXT

Wall Street Mixed in Start to Busy Week for Earnings, Data

UP NEXT

Will California Meet Newsom’s 2035 EV Deadline? It Won’t Even Hit the 2026 Target 

UP NEXT

Dollar Doubts Dominate Gathering of Global Economic Leaders

Trump’s Team Has Disrupted Some $430 Billion in Federal Funds, Top Democrats Say

39 minutes ago

Police Saddled Up for Alcohol Sting During Clovis Rodeo, 22 Arrested

39 minutes ago

Supply and Demand: Less Food Means Higher Prices – or Does It?

42 minutes ago

This Summer at the Movies, Superheroes, From ‘Superman’ to ‘Fantastic Four,’ Return

48 minutes ago

Tulare County Man, Linked to Norteño Gang, Sentenced for Manufacturing Explosives

48 minutes ago

Shedeur Sanders Was Not the Only Prospect to Receive a Prank Call During the NFL Draft

56 minutes ago

US Consumer Confidence Plunges to Lowest in 5 Years on Tariff Worries

60 minutes ago

Coca-Cola Reports Better-Than-Expected Quarterly Profit, Says It Can Manage Through Tariffs

1 hour ago

How California Sanctuary Policies Are Faring Under Pressure From Trump

1 hour ago

Trump Signs 3 Executive Orders, Addressing Immigration and Policing

1 hour ago

Edman Delivers in 10th as Dodgers Weather Myers’ Pinch-Hit Slam for Win Over Marlins

LOS ANGELES — Tommy Edman hit a two-run single in the 10th inning and the Los Angeles Dodgers blew a five-run lead before rallying to beat t...

28 minutes ago

28 minutes ago

Edman Delivers in 10th as Dodgers Weather Myers’ Pinch-Hit Slam for Win Over Marlins

32 minutes ago

Amazon Launches Its First Internet Satellites to Compete Against SpaceX’s Starlinks

36 minutes ago

Numbers That Matter From the First 100 Days of Trump’s Second Term

39 minutes ago

Trump’s Team Has Disrupted Some $430 Billion in Federal Funds, Top Democrats Say

39 minutes ago

Police Saddled Up for Alcohol Sting During Clovis Rodeo, 22 Arrested

42 minutes ago

Supply and Demand: Less Food Means Higher Prices – or Does It?

48 minutes ago

This Summer at the Movies, Superheroes, From ‘Superman’ to ‘Fantastic Four,’ Return

A Porterville man and Norteño gang member was sentenced Monday, April 28, 2025, to nearly six years in prison for manufacturing 3D-printed explosives and possessing an unregistered silencer. (Department of Justice)
48 minutes ago

Tulare County Man, Linked to Norteño Gang, Sentenced for Manufacturing Explosives

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend