Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Mobile Home Park Closure Halted. Chavez Floats Eminent Domain Proposal.
By admin
Published 1 year ago on
November 17, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

In a 6-0 decision, the Fresno City Council on Thursday rejected a plan to close a northside mobile home park. And, at least one council member expressed interest in the city taking ownership of the property.

“Given the housing crisis that we have in our community, to me, I think the city should pursue the eminent domain pathway.” — Fresno City Councilmember Luis Chavez

But even as the city has stopped the sale of the park, evictions there continue.

Councilmembers agreed with the city attorney’s office that Harmony Communities’ plan to close La Hacienda Mobile Estates lacked sufficient details on how the company would compensate tenants for their homes.

Attorney Sarah Papazian with the city of Fresno said appraisals of the mobile homes were not credible and did not provide reasonable estimates of market value.

Councilmembers agreed with her conclusions.

“All of those things are so off-base in what was estimated on the applicant’s report versus what it actually costs in the city of Fresno, in a city that has essentially a 0% vacancy rate when it comes to new housing, especially housing that is affordable for seniors on fixed incomes,” Fresno City Councilman Miguel Arias said.

Attorney Mariah Thompson with California Rural Legal Assistance represents tenants at the park.

She said during the council meeting they have an investor and a nonprofit who may be able to purchase the park. They would use state funds but need city assistance as funding from the state only happens once a year.

Councilmember Luis Chavez said he would be open to using eminent domain to take over the park.

“Given the housing crisis that we have in our community, to me, I think the city should pursue the eminent domain pathway,” Chavez said.

The park is at 104 E. Sierra Ave., east of Blackstone Avenue.

Alternate Buyer Might Mean Those Evicted Could Come Back

While the city action doesn’t keep resident Patricia Shawn in her home, for her neighbors, stopping the closure means having a place to stay for another year, she said.

“It means that my neighbors get to stay there, it just means that they’ve got a shot,” Shawn said. Shawn has lived at La Hacienda — formerly Trails End Mobile Home Park — since 1997.

Shawn had a chance to talk with a representative from the company who told her he would bring back as many people as he can.

Attorneys would not disclose what nonprofit was interested in buying the mobile home park.

Over half of the park has either left or been evicted, Thompson said.

Shawn keeps regular contact with many of those who left the park.

She found out one former resident, 50-year-old Clyde Helms, died from health complications. He had been evicted in May. He had been living with a friend and had been going back and forth to the hospital.

Another single mother and her children have been living out of a motel, Shawn said.

A copy of a 12-month eviction notice distributed to residents at La Hacienda in April 2023. (GV Wire File/David Taub)

More Than Half of Tenants Have Left or Been Evicted Since April

California law requires 12 months ‘ notice before a mobile home park can be closed.

Fresno, like many other cities, goes even further, requiring mobile home park owners to file reports on what impact shutting a park down would have.

It also requires a plan outlining how residents would be compensated for their property.

Harmony Communities sent out notices the park would close in April, accompanied by a tenant impact report in June. A report from the city attorney’s office stated the report lacked the required appraisal.

That appraisal didn’t come until September.

During that time, numerous eviction notices were given to residents.

Shawn estimates about 19 people have been evicted since the first notice went out.

Thompson said six evictions have been filed since the company’s last hearing before the council, most of whom are tenants she represents.

Another resident, David Willis, received an unlawful detainer notice Friday. He is one of the residents suing Harmony. He also sits on the rent control committee.

The notice is identical to six others, Thompson said. The notice claims Willis is a squatter with no rights and has to give up his home within five days.

Inadequate Plan by Harmony: City Attorneys

Papazian said the appraiser for Harmony used the same five comps for all the trailers, regardless of the age, type, or size.

Upon investigation, Papazian said, three of the comps came from the same buyer. One of the comps at a different mobile home park was a sale between family members.

The report from Harmony stated that only residents in good standing would be eligible for the relocation plan.

Attorney Jason Dilday for Harmony said their appraiser is state certified. He also said the company doesn’t need city approval to close the park down because it hasn’t applied for a change of use.

An active lawsuit against the city of Petaluma from Three Pillars Communities and Little Woods Mobile Villa LLC disputes the constitutionality of cities being able to prevent the closure of the park.

A statement from Harmony to GV Wire stated that it isn’t involved in the Petaluma lawsuit, but the address of one of the plaintiffs — Little Woods Mobile Villa LLC — shows the same business address as Harmony Communities.

The lawsuit contends that given rent control and park closure rules, companies are forced to operate at a loss.

Harmony’s report on La Hacienda Mobile Estate also states the reason for the need to close involves extensive upgrades that need to be done to the property.

Thompson said Harmony is intentionally operating at a loss to justify closing the park.

“This investor knew exactly what they were getting into,” Thompson said. “They were very familiar with the conditions in the park. They are a sophisticated entity with more than 50 parks that know that when you buy a park like this you lose money for the first couple years.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Trump Just Bet the Farm

DON'T MISS

Staged Crashes and Insurance Fraud: Is Your California Commute a Target?

DON'T MISS

Fight Over Phonics: Will CA Require the ‘Science of Reading’ in K-12 Schools?

DON'T MISS

Russia Says Trump’s Threats Against Iran Could Trigger ‘Global Catastrophe’

DON'T MISS

Get Off the Phone! Fresno Police Target Distracted Driving

DON'T MISS

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

DON'T MISS

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

DON'T MISS

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

DON'T MISS

Dodgers’ Freddie Freeman Lands on Injured List Following Fall in His Shower at Home

DON'T MISS

How Trump’s Latest Tariffs Could Affect Your Wallet

UP NEXT

Staged Crashes and Insurance Fraud: Is Your California Commute a Target?

UP NEXT

Russia Says Trump’s Threats Against Iran Could Trigger ‘Global Catastrophe’

UP NEXT

Get Off the Phone! Fresno Police Target Distracted Driving

UP NEXT

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

UP NEXT

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

UP NEXT

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

UP NEXT

Dodgers’ Freddie Freeman Lands on Injured List Following Fall in His Shower at Home

UP NEXT

How Trump’s Latest Tariffs Could Affect Your Wallet

UP NEXT

Curry Scores 37 Points and Warriors Beat Lakers in a Potential First-Round Playoff Preview

UP NEXT

LA Fires Death Toll Rises to 30 After Remains Are Found

Russia Says Trump’s Threats Against Iran Could Trigger ‘Global Catastrophe’

1 hour ago

Get Off the Phone! Fresno Police Target Distracted Driving

1 hour ago

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

1 hour ago

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

1 hour ago

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

1 hour ago

Dodgers’ Freddie Freeman Lands on Injured List Following Fall in His Shower at Home

2 hours ago

How Trump’s Latest Tariffs Could Affect Your Wallet

2 hours ago

Curry Scores 37 Points and Warriors Beat Lakers in a Potential First-Round Playoff Preview

2 hours ago

LA Fires Death Toll Rises to 30 After Remains Are Found

2 hours ago

US Added 228,000 Jobs in March as Economy Showed Strength in Buildup to Trump Trade Wars

2 hours ago

Trump Just Bet the Farm

Donald Trump is not known for doing his homework — he’s more of a go-with-my-gut kind of guy. What I find most terrifying about what T...

23 minutes ago

24 minutes ago

Trump Just Bet the Farm

30 minutes ago

Staged Crashes and Insurance Fraud: Is Your California Commute a Target?

34 minutes ago

Fight Over Phonics: Will CA Require the ‘Science of Reading’ in K-12 Schools?

1 hour ago

Russia Says Trump’s Threats Against Iran Could Trigger ‘Global Catastrophe’

The Fresno Police Department will conduct an enforcement operation on April 7, 2025, to target drivers violating the hands-free cell phone law, aiming to reduce distracted driving. (Shutterstock)
1 hour ago

Get Off the Phone! Fresno Police Target Distracted Driving

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell speaks during a news conference after the Federal Open Market Committee meeting, Wednesday, March 19, 2025, at the Federal Reserve in Washington. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
1 hour ago

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

1 hour ago

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

1 hour ago

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend