Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Federal Appeals Court Overturns 1991 Death Sentence in Fresno Double Murder
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 1 year ago on
June 2, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal appeals court in a rare move overturned the death sentence of a man who was convicted of robbing and killing two people in Fresno in 1988, saying prosecutors knowingly presented false testimony from a key witness.

The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in its Wednesday ruling upheld Colin Dickey’s robbery conviction and said prosecutors could decide whether to retry him for murder. Dickey remains in prison.

“This is an exceptional case in which the prosecutor deliberately elicited, and then failed to correct, false and misleading testimony from the State’s star witness,” the court said in a ruling overturning Dickey’s 1991 death sentence.

The Fresno County prosecutor elicited the testimony from key witness Gene Buchanan, who told the jury he had not met with prosecutors or accepted any benefits from them. In fact, the court said, they had met a dozen times during the investigation, and the district attorney’s office had dismissed drug charges against him and helped him collect a $5,000 reward for implicating Dickey, one of his roommates.

Dickey was convicted in the murders of two neighbors, Marie Caton, 76, and Louis Freiri, 67, who were beaten and stabbed to death in November 1988 at Caton’s home in Fresno, where Freiri was a boarder, the San Francisco Chronicle reported.

Both Dickey and Buchanan lived with Caton’s grandson, Richard Cullumber, who according to witnesses was a drug user who frequently requested money from Caton. Five days after the attack, the court said, Cullumber fled police in a car, said he had “killed a woman,” was cornered after a high-speed chase and shot himself to death.

According to another roommate, Dickey said he had gone to Caton’s house with Cullumber to help him get the money but had nothing to do with the killings. But Buchanan testified that Dickey told him he was at the scene of the attacks, saw Freiri lying with his head slumped down, and decided that “if you kill one you might as well kill them both.”

Buchanan’s testimony “was the centerpiece of the state’s case” and without his dubious statements, “the state’s case against Dickey was weak” and lacked any direct evidence of intent to kill, Judge Morgan Christen said in the 3-0 ruling.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

California Firefighters Gain Ground Against Big Wildfires After Hot, Windy Weekend

DON'T MISS

‘The Outsiders’ Wins Best Musical and ‘Stereophonic’ Best Play as Women Make Strides at Tony Awards

DON'T MISS

This Is How Clovis East Alum Bryson DeChambeau Won His 2nd US Open, Denying Rory McIlroy

DON'T MISS

Biden’s Campaign Announces a $50 Million Advertising Blitz Highlighting Trump’s Conviction

DON'T MISS

Surgeon General Asks Congress to Require Warning Labels for Social Media, Like Those on Cigarettes

DON'T MISS

What Have We Liberals Done to the West Coast?

DON'T MISS

Caitlin Clark Overcomes Another Physical Game, Scores 23 to Lead Fever Past Sky

DON'T MISS

Giants Drop Angels as Soler’s 3-Run HR Keys a 9-Run Inning

DON'T MISS

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore to Issue Over 175,000 Marijuana Pardons

DON'T MISS

Ohtani Has Second Two-Homer Game of Season, Betts Breaks Hand as Dodgers Beat Royals

UP NEXT

‘The Outsiders’ Wins Best Musical and ‘Stereophonic’ Best Play as Women Make Strides at Tony Awards

UP NEXT

This Is How Clovis East Alum Bryson DeChambeau Won His 2nd US Open, Denying Rory McIlroy

UP NEXT

Biden’s Campaign Announces a $50 Million Advertising Blitz Highlighting Trump’s Conviction

UP NEXT

Surgeon General Asks Congress to Require Warning Labels for Social Media, Like Those on Cigarettes

UP NEXT

What Have We Liberals Done to the West Coast?

UP NEXT

Caitlin Clark Overcomes Another Physical Game, Scores 23 to Lead Fever Past Sky

UP NEXT

Giants Drop Angels as Soler’s 3-Run HR Keys a 9-Run Inning

UP NEXT

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore to Issue Over 175,000 Marijuana Pardons

UP NEXT

Ohtani Has Second Two-Homer Game of Season, Betts Breaks Hand as Dodgers Beat Royals

UP NEXT

US: Michigan, CUNY Failed to Assess Hostile Environment from Israel-Hamas War Protests

Biden’s Campaign Announces a $50 Million Advertising Blitz Highlighting Trump’s Conviction

26 mins ago

Surgeon General Asks Congress to Require Warning Labels for Social Media, Like Those on Cigarettes

35 mins ago

What Have We Liberals Done to the West Coast?

1 hour ago

Caitlin Clark Overcomes Another Physical Game, Scores 23 to Lead Fever Past Sky

1 hour ago

Giants Drop Angels as Soler’s 3-Run HR Keys a 9-Run Inning

2 hours ago

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore to Issue Over 175,000 Marijuana Pardons

2 hours ago

Ohtani Has Second Two-Homer Game of Season, Betts Breaks Hand as Dodgers Beat Royals

2 hours ago

US: Michigan, CUNY Failed to Assess Hostile Environment from Israel-Hamas War Protests

2 hours ago

Putin to Visit North Korea Amid Concerns Over Military Cooperation

2 hours ago

Netanyahu Dissolves War Cabinet After Key Partner Exits, Say Israeli Officials

2 hours ago

California Firefighters Gain Ground Against Big Wildfires After Hot, Windy Weekend

GORMAN — Firefighters increased their containment of a large wildfire in mountains north of Los Angeles on Monday after a weekend of explosi...

7 mins ago

7 mins ago

California Firefighters Gain Ground Against Big Wildfires After Hot, Windy Weekend

15 mins ago

‘The Outsiders’ Wins Best Musical and ‘Stereophonic’ Best Play as Women Make Strides at Tony Awards

20 mins ago

This Is How Clovis East Alum Bryson DeChambeau Won His 2nd US Open, Denying Rory McIlroy

26 mins ago

Biden’s Campaign Announces a $50 Million Advertising Blitz Highlighting Trump’s Conviction

35 mins ago

Surgeon General Asks Congress to Require Warning Labels for Social Media, Like Those on Cigarettes

1 hour ago

What Have We Liberals Done to the West Coast?

1 hour ago

Caitlin Clark Overcomes Another Physical Game, Scores 23 to Lead Fever Past Sky

2 hours ago

Giants Drop Angels as Soler’s 3-Run HR Keys a 9-Run Inning

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend