Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Madera, Merced Cattle Ranchers Circle Wagons Against Water 'Rustling'
SJV-Water
By SJV Water
Published 3 years ago on
June 17, 2021

Share

Central Valley cattle ranchers are gearing up for a fight against what they see as groundwater rustling.

Their fear is that newly formed groundwater agencies in some areas could devalue their land by not giving them a fair share of their own groundwater.

By Jesse Vad

SJV Water

Ranchers believe those fears were realized on June 8 when the Madera County Board of Supervisors approved a groundwater allocation that will partially exclude rangeland. Ranchers who own rangeland that has never been irrigated won’t receive a share of the county’s “transitional water” allotment.

This is all part of the county’s attempt to comply with the state’s new Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, which requires aquifers in overdrafted areas come into balance by 2040. That means more water can’t be pumped out than goes back in.

In Madera, the county took on responsibility for areas outside of existing agricultural water districts. That’s about 215,000 acres that stretch across the Madera, Chowchilla and Delta-Mendota water subbasins, all of which are considered critically overdrafted.

Being outside of existing water agencies means most of these lands don’t have access to canals or pipelines to bring in more surface water to replenish what they pump. With options toward achieving sustainability limited, Madera’s plan is to drastically cut pumping by 2040 – 50% from what’s allowed today, according to its plan filed with the state last year.

To get there, pumpers will be allowed some “transitional” groundwater, which will ramp down each year until they get to the 50% mark. Under the action approved by Madera supervisors June 8, that transitional amount is different for each subbasin and ranges from 11.2 inches per acre to 19.6 inches per acre this year.

Lands that have not previously been irrigated with groundwater — such as rangelands — will not receive a share of transitional water. But those landowners can get a share of the “sustainable yield,” the amount of water determined to be safe for pumping without overdrafting the aquifer, by simply asking — and paying a fee.

There is no cost for allocations this year, but there will be next year, after the county has worked out the rates.

Ranchers Seek Groundwater Credits

Ranchers aren’t satisfied.

“I’m really disturbed,” said Igal Treibatch, a Madera County farmer, about the county’s June 8 decision. “There are things being talked about that make no sense.”

“The farmers have been taking what should be my water. We should not be their asset.” — Madera County rancher Clay Daulton

Ranchers wondered how the county’s groundwater allocation won’t affect their rights.

In California, groundwater rights are property rights attached to land. Landowners have always had the right to sink a well and pump enough water for the “beneficial use,” on that land, typically farming. And while SGMA expressly states it doesn’t interfere with water rights, ranchers wonder how that can be true. As they see it, the June 8 Madera County action strips their land of some of its groundwater rights.

They believe that rather than being shorted on groundwater allocations, rangelands should get groundwater credits because they haven’t been pumping, worsening the overdraft. In fact, rangelands contribute more water than they consume, ranchers say.

“The farmers have been taking what should be my water,” said Clay Daulton, a Madera County rancher. “We should not be their asset.”

On April 29, the Madera County Cattlemen’s Association drafted a letter demanding the county reaffirm ranchers’ water rights.

“I know there is a concern about water rights being diminished,” said Stephanie Anagnoson, director of Water and Natural Resources for Madera County. “But I’m not sure that that’s valid and based in California water law.”

Rancher Wes Meyers and horse trainer Malena Valinote on the Flying M Ranch in Merced County. (Contributed: Wes Meyers)

‘Misinformation Is Out There’

This isn’t just an issue in Madera County. In Merced County, ranchers formed the Merced Grasslands Coalition to ensure their groundwater rights aren’t affected.

The coalition, a collection of ranchers and farmers in Merced County, has been advocating for rangeland owners in the Merced subbasin over the past year. Internally, members have heard their local groundwater agency is considering issuing water allocations based on irrigated farmland acreage, according to Wes Myers, Merced County rancher and member of the coalition.

“What that would do is decimate rangeland values,” said Myers. “You would no longer have the same water rights for rangeland as you do for farmland.”

Myers said he’s afraid of the domino effect. If one groundwater agency decides to take that approach, he thinks others will start doing the same.

Those claims aren’t true, said Lloyd Pareira, chairman of the Merced Subbasin Groundwater Sustainability Agency.

Pareira said SGMA doesn’t allow groundwater agencies to change water rights and rangeland owners shouldn’t be worried.

“It’s not our job to create value or take away value from land,” said Pareira. “When something’s plausible, people talk about it as if this is what’s going to happen. Misinformation is out there.”

Allocations and Rights

Groundwater agencies, “are not modifying ownership of water,” said James Nachbaur, director of the Office of Research, Planning and Performance at the State Water Resources Control Board. “But they do relate to how people can use the water that they presumably own.”

While it’s true that groundwater agencies are not allowed to change water rights, the agencies have broad authority under the law when it comes to allocating water. No groundwater agency has decided to allocate entirely based on irrigated acreage yet, but it is an option.

“What’s the difference between a pumping allocation and a water right? That can get murky really quickly,” said Eric Garner, water lawyer and managing partner at Best Best and Krieger law firm.

Because of the authority of groundwater agencies, Garner said rangeland owners do have cause for concern.

Water rights holders can always challenge a groundwater agency in court. But a recent court decision doesn’t bode well for rangeland owners.

“We wish to have the ability to opt into the fees of maintaining the basin with also the ability to participate in trading our water rights.” —Michele Lasgoity, president of the Madera County Cattlemen’s Association

In the Antelope Valley Groundwater Cases, a 22-year-long adjudication affecting desert land in northern Los Angeles and southeast Kern counties, a ruling in March left 18,000 landowners with zero groundwater allocations. Similar to ranchers in the San Joaquin Valley, those landowners didn’t pump water and their groundwater rights were classified as “dormant.”

Playing the Market

Even though they aren’t pumping, ranchers want to protect their groundwater rights in hopes of selling water in a future market.

“We wish to have the ability to opt into the fees of maintaining the basin with also the ability to participate in trading our water rights,” said Michele Lasgoity, president of the Madera County Cattlemen’s Association.

If ranchers received an allocation through SGMA but weren’t using that water, they could lease the rights to growers who don’t have enough, said Lasgoity.

It’s a popular idea among ranchers who want to generate extra income with water they’re not using.

But there are multiple roadblocks. For one, selling water would require a water market, something that doesn’t exist on a local level for most of the valley.

Madera County created a groundwater market simulation game to see how trading and selling water could help with sustainability but a true market isn’t happening any time soon, Madera County’s Anagnoson said. Even then, selling dormant water rights could bring up other issues.

“Allowing them to sell water that they weren’t using is going pretty far out there in my opinion,” said Anagnoson. “There’s really not a basis for this in water law.”

The path between water rights and managing groundwater toward sustainability will not be an easy one for groundwater agencies.

“That’s the tension,” said Garner. “SGMA didn’t throw California water rights law out at all. So it put the GSA in this very difficult position of having to use allocations without the authority, or really frankly, expertise to determine water rights.”

About SJV Water

SJV Water is an independent, nonprofit news site dedicated to covering water in the San Joaquin Valley.

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What to Know About Pam Bondi, Trump’s New Pick for Attorney General

DON'T MISS

North Korean Leader Says Past Diplomacy Only Confirmed US Hostility

DON'T MISS

Democrats Strike Deal to Get More Biden Judges Confirmed Before Congress Adjourns

DON'T MISS

Newsom Gaslights on Potential Gas Price Hikes in Fresno Visit

DON'T MISS

Automakers to Trump: Please Require Us to Sell Electric Vehicles

DON'T MISS

President Biden Welcomes 2024 NBA Champion Boston Celtics to White House

DON'T MISS

Ohtani Makes History With 3rd MVP, Judge Claims 2nd AL Honor

DON'T MISS

Trump Chooses Pam Bondi for Attorney General Pick After Gaetz Withdraws

DON'T MISS

Average Rate on a 30-Year Mortgage in the US Rises to Highest Level Since July

DON'T MISS

Cutting in Line? American Airlines’ New Boarding Tech Might Stop You at Now Over 100 Airports

UP NEXT

Is Fresno Mobile Home Park Controversy Over? Tenants Applaud Federal Judge’s Ruling

UP NEXT

What Will Happen to CNBC and MSNBC When They No Longer Have a Corporate Connection to NBC News?

UP NEXT

Conservative Professors and Students Are Beating CA Community Colleges in Court

UP NEXT

‘Woke’ Terminology Not Commonly Used by Americans: YouGov Survey

UP NEXT

Former Bitwise Employees Settle for $20 Million: Fresno Attorney

UP NEXT

Fresno County Sent Out Wrong Ballots. Will Errors Affect Close Races?

UP NEXT

Fresno Officials, Local Groups Prepare for Trump’s Promised Mass Deportations

UP NEXT

Volunteers Came Back to Nonprofits in 2023, After the Pandemic Tanked Participation

UP NEXT

New Study: Proposed Trump Tariffs Could Cost US Consumers $78 Billion a Year

UP NEXT

Riders Stuck in Midair for Over 2 Hours on Knott’s Berry Farm Ride

Newsom Gaslights on Potential Gas Price Hikes in Fresno Visit

8 hours ago

Automakers to Trump: Please Require Us to Sell Electric Vehicles

9 hours ago

President Biden Welcomes 2024 NBA Champion Boston Celtics to White House

9 hours ago

Ohtani Makes History With 3rd MVP, Judge Claims 2nd AL Honor

9 hours ago

Trump Chooses Pam Bondi for Attorney General Pick After Gaetz Withdraws

10 hours ago

Average Rate on a 30-Year Mortgage in the US Rises to Highest Level Since July

10 hours ago

Cutting in Line? American Airlines’ New Boarding Tech Might Stop You at Now Over 100 Airports

10 hours ago

MLB Will Test Robot Umpires at 13 Spring Training Ballparks Hosting 19 Teams

10 hours ago

Death Toll in Gaza From Israel-Hamas War Passes 44,000, Palestinian Officials Say

11 hours ago

Jussie Smollett’s Conviction in 2019 Attack on Himself Is Overturned

11 hours ago

What to Know About Pam Bondi, Trump’s New Pick for Attorney General

NEW YORK — Pam Bondi, the former Florida attorney general, was chosen Thursday by Donald Trump to serve as U.S. attorney general hours after...

7 hours ago

7 hours ago

What to Know About Pam Bondi, Trump’s New Pick for Attorney General

7 hours ago

North Korean Leader Says Past Diplomacy Only Confirmed US Hostility

8 hours ago

Democrats Strike Deal to Get More Biden Judges Confirmed Before Congress Adjourns

8 hours ago

Newsom Gaslights on Potential Gas Price Hikes in Fresno Visit

President Joe Biden with Mary Barra, the chief executive of General Motors, at the Detroit Auto Show, Sept. 14, 2022. President-elect Donald Trump has promised to erase the Biden administration’s tailpipe rules designed to get carmakers to produce electric vehicles, but most U.S. automakers want to keep them. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
9 hours ago

Automakers to Trump: Please Require Us to Sell Electric Vehicles

9 hours ago

President Biden Welcomes 2024 NBA Champion Boston Celtics to White House

9 hours ago

Ohtani Makes History With 3rd MVP, Judge Claims 2nd AL Honor

Former Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, speaks before Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump arrives to speak at a campaign rally at First Horizon Coliseum, Saturday, Nov. 2, 2024, in Greensboro, NC. (AP/Alex Brandon)
10 hours ago

Trump Chooses Pam Bondi for Attorney General Pick After Gaetz Withdraws

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend