Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Sick of Loud Ads on Netflix? A Proposed California Law Turns Down the Volume

5 hours ago

Fresno Airport Director Henry Thompson Dies. He Led Major Expansion

6 hours ago

Record Numbers of Americans Say Immigration Is Good for Country: Gallup Poll

7 hours ago

In California Strawberry Fields, Immigration Raids Sow Fear

8 hours ago

Trump to Send Weapons to Ukraine, Threatens Secondary Sanctions on Russia in 50 Days

8 hours ago

Newsom’s Office Attacks Stephen Miller, Calling Him a ‘Fascist Cuck’

9 hours ago

Trump’s Spending Bill Will Likely Boost Costs for Insurers, Shrink Medicaid Coverage

9 hours ago

American Allies Want to Redraw the World’s Trade Map, Minus the US

10 hours ago

Trump Says He Spoke to FBI’s Bongino Amid Epstein Uproar

10 hours ago
Will Amtrak Joe Save California's Troubled High-Speed Rail Project?
Joe-Mathews
By Joe Mathews
Published 4 years ago on
April 22, 2021

Share

Dear Joe,

I should call you Mr. President, but there’s no time for formalities. You better move fast if you’re going to save California’s high-speed rail project.

portrait of columnist Joe Mathews

Joe Mathews

Opinion

No malarkey: It has to be you. California has shown itself incapable of funding, managing, or building deep popular support for this $80 billion train, which would be the first truly high-speed rail system in the United States. You — Amtrak Joe, with your personal devotion to rail and your $2 trillion infrastructure proposal — are the last hope for making it a reality.

Is it worth the political risk of associating yourself with an epic failure? You and your advisors are cautious people who don’t want to give Republicans who oppose infrastructure spending a tempting target. But If you can fix this problematic and high-profile project, you will demonstrate just how committed you are to remaking this country’s infrastructure, and fulfilling your campaign promise to “build back better.”

California Has Completely Bungled a Valuable Project

To succeed, you’ll have to change the mindset around the project. Most of the attention paid to high-speed rail focuses on its lack of money — the state has less than $30 billion of the $80 billion-plus needed for completion. But the project’s biggest problem is not money but management.

Thirteen years after California voters approved the railway, the California High-Speed Rail Authority still hasn’t managed the basic task of assembling the land necessary for the first piece of the line in the Central Valley. The agency, and its contractors, lack the combination of size, engineering expertise, and management chops to handle a construction project of this scale.

 Most of the attention paid to high-speed rail focuses on its lack of money — the state has less than $30 billion of the $80 billion-plus needed for completion. But the project’s biggest problem is not money but management.

California politicians, instead of supporting the project, are taking it apart. In 2019, Gov. Gavin Newsom abruptly abandoned the plan to connect the Bay Area to the Central Valley, leaving behind a diminished railway from Bakersfield to Merced. By making high-speed rail a Central Valley-only regional project, Newsom hurt support for rail in other regions, whose politicians are now trying to grab high-speed rail funds for their own local projects.

Joe, high-speed rail will die — unless you intervene soon. The good news is that California’s mismanagement has given your administration many leverage points to justify an intervention.

Federal Money Can Be Used as Leverage

One leverage point is $929 million in rail funding that the Trump administration pulled back in 2019 after Newsom abandoned the Bay-Area-to-San-Joaquin plan. The second involves $2.6 billion the state received for high-speed rail from the 2009 federal stimulus bill that it still hasn’t spent. California is almost certain to miss a 2022 deadline for using the money, which means you have the power to take it back.

Since you control $3.5 billion that this project needs to stay afloat, you can force Californians to confront the question: Are we serious about completing this train or not?

Your demands should be straightforward. As a condition of California getting the money it needs to keep the project alive — not to mention the tens of billions of additional federal dollars that will be necessary to complete it—you can demand major changes in the management. First, require the replacement of today’s weak and part-time board, and flailing CEO, with a leadership team that you trust. Second, insist on the replacement with today’s expensive and ineffective contractors with an engineering and management heavyweight —I’m thinking California giant, Bechtel — that can handle a project of this scale.

Unless It’s LA to SF, What’s the Point?

Third, insist that the project plan take the high-speed rail from the Bay Area all the way to L.A. Otherwise, what’s the point?

If California won’t meet your demands, or if our leaders undermine the project, you should pull back the money and leave the state to clean up its own unfinished mess.

One cautionary note: Don’t make any big promises now about future funding. Only once your preferred team is in place should you offer a schedule of future federal payments. Joe, we Californians need to be kept on a short leash.

You’ll have to shrug off criticism from Californians who say that the state, having put bond money and cap-and-trade dollars into the project, deserves to hold the reins. The hard truth about California is that we’ve never built much of anything big without federal assistance — our aqueducts, our highways, and our internet all required Washington’s help.

But the biggest thing you’ll need is the resolve to walk away. If California won’t meet your demands, or if our leaders undermine the project, you should pull back the money and leave the state to clean up its own unfinished mess.

Your love must be tough, but high-speed rail is worth the trouble. The project also isn’t as big a loser as it appears. Already, thousands of people are building new crossings and bridges in the Central Valley. And with a proven record of success in other countries, high-speed could provide a convenient, climate-friendly alternative to flying or driving around our state, and country.

But none of that will happen, Joe, unless you kick California in the butt right now.

About the Author

Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Max Fire Near Pine Flat Lake Grows to 426 Acres. Evacuations Remain in Place

DON'T MISS

Vendors Demand Arias Resign Over False ICE Raid Warning. He Says Trump Is the Culprit

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Rewards Incompetence? Ex-Comms Chief Could Get Huge Severance

DON'T MISS

Elmo’s X Account Gets Hacked, Posts Antisemitic and Racist Messages

DON'T MISS

3-Year-Old Dies After Drowning in Backyard Pool in Porterville

DON'T MISS

Meta Investors, Zuckerberg to Square off at $8 Billion Trial Over Alleged Privacy Violations

DON'T MISS

MAGA Is Tearing Itself Apart Over Jeffrey Epstein

DON'T MISS

Fresno Grass Fire Burns Along Veterans Boulevard, Under Investigation

DON'T MISS

Trump to Unveil $70 Billion in AI and Energy Investments

DON'T MISS

Fire at Boston-Area Senior Living Facility Kills at Least Nine

UP NEXT

Vendors Demand Arias Resign Over False ICE Raid Warning. He Says Trump Is the Culprit

UP NEXT

Fresno Unified Rewards Incompetence? Ex-Comms Chief Could Get Huge Severance

UP NEXT

Elmo’s X Account Gets Hacked, Posts Antisemitic and Racist Messages

UP NEXT

3-Year-Old Dies After Drowning in Backyard Pool in Porterville

UP NEXT

Meta Investors, Zuckerberg to Square off at $8 Billion Trial Over Alleged Privacy Violations

UP NEXT

MAGA Is Tearing Itself Apart Over Jeffrey Epstein

UP NEXT

Fresno Grass Fire Burns Along Veterans Boulevard, Under Investigation

UP NEXT

Trump to Unveil $70 Billion in AI and Energy Investments

UP NEXT

Fire at Boston-Area Senior Living Facility Kills at Least Nine

UP NEXT

Arizona Governor Wants Investigation of Federal Handling of Grand Canyon Fire

Elmo’s X Account Gets Hacked, Posts Antisemitic and Racist Messages

2 hours ago

3-Year-Old Dies After Drowning in Backyard Pool in Porterville

3 hours ago

Meta Investors, Zuckerberg to Square off at $8 Billion Trial Over Alleged Privacy Violations

3 hours ago

MAGA Is Tearing Itself Apart Over Jeffrey Epstein

3 hours ago

Fresno Grass Fire Burns Along Veterans Boulevard, Under Investigation

4 hours ago

Trump to Unveil $70 Billion in AI and Energy Investments

4 hours ago

Fire at Boston-Area Senior Living Facility Kills at Least Nine

4 hours ago

Arizona Governor Wants Investigation of Federal Handling of Grand Canyon Fire

4 hours ago

Egypt Says Israel-EU Agreement Has Not Increased Aid to Gaza

5 hours ago

US Supreme Court Clears Way for Trump to Gut Education Department

5 hours ago

Max Fire Near Pine Flat Lake Grows to 426 Acres. Evacuations Remain in Place

A wildfire burning near Pine Flat Lake has scorched 426 acres and remains just 5% contained as of Monday, according to CalFire. Dubbed the M...

35 minutes ago

The Max Fire near Pine Flat Lake has burned 427 acres, is 5% contained, and continues to prompt evacuation orders in the Blue Canyon area as of Monday, July 14, 2025. (CalFire)
35 minutes ago

Max Fire Near Pine Flat Lake Grows to 426 Acres. Evacuations Remain in Place

2 hours ago

Vendors Demand Arias Resign Over False ICE Raid Warning. He Says Trump Is the Culprit

2 hours ago

Fresno Unified Rewards Incompetence? Ex-Comms Chief Could Get Huge Severance

Elmo speaks at The Wall Street Journal's Future of Everything Festival in New York City, U.S., May 22, 2024. (Reuters/Andrew Kelly)
2 hours ago

Elmo’s X Account Gets Hacked, Posts Antisemitic and Racist Messages

3 hours ago

3-Year-Old Dies After Drowning in Backyard Pool in Porterville

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg looks on before the luncheon on the inauguration day of U.S. President Donald Trump's second Presidential term in Washington, U.S., January 20, 2025. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Meta Investors, Zuckerberg to Square off at $8 Billion Trial Over Alleged Privacy Violations

3 hours ago

MAGA Is Tearing Itself Apart Over Jeffrey Epstein

4 hours ago

Fresno Grass Fire Burns Along Veterans Boulevard, Under Investigation

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend