Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Bill Moyers, Broadcaster and LBJ’s White House Press Secretary, Dies at 91

19 hours ago

State Department Approves $30 Million for Gaza Humanitarian Foundation

20 hours ago

S&P 500, Nasdaq Near Record Highs as Rate-Cut Bets Creep Up

1 day ago

Bobby Sherman, Easygoing Teen Idol of the 1960s and ’70s, Dies at 81

1 day ago

Cargo Ship That Caught Fire Carrying Electric Vehicles Sinks in the Pacific

1 day ago

US Supreme Court Backs South Carolina Effort to Defund Planned Parenthood

1 day ago

4 Million Acres of California Forests Could Lose Protection. What Trump’s ‘Roadless Rule’ Repeal Could Do

2 days ago

West Nile Virus Detected in Mosquitoes in Fresno County

2 days ago

Fresno Residents Join Nationwide Fast to Call Attention to Gaza Crisis

2 days ago

Suspect in Bombing at California Fertility Clinic Dies in Federal Custody

3 days ago
Does California Bill Limiting Vaccine Protests Violate First Amendment?
David Taub Website photo 2024
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 4 years ago on
March 9, 2021

Share

A proposed bill that would place limitations on vaccine site protests is drawing criticism from one prominent California civil rights attorney.

State Sen. Richard Pan, D-Sacramento, introduced SB 742, which would place limitations on vaccine site protests. The law is modeled after a 2012 state law that limits protests at funerals.

Under the proposed law, protesters at locations where vaccines are administered — which can include hospitals or doctor’s offices — would have to stay at least 300 feet away, unless they’re on private property. The penalty could be a $1,000 fine and/or up to six months in county jail.

Harmeet Dhillon, attorney and CEO of Center for American Liberties, says the bill goes too far.

“Protesting those sites is a First Amendment-protected activity,” Dhillon said. “It prohibits ‘picketing targeted at a vaccination site,’ and that could be interpreted under First Amendment law as a viewpoint based discrimination.”

Pan’s office did not respond to a request for comment by GV Wire℠. A Pan-affiliated group, ProtectUs, also did not respond.

Pan a Vaccine Advocate

Photo of Attorney Harmeet Dhillon

“It prohibits ‘picketing targeted at a vaccination site,’ and that could be interpreted under First Amendment law as a viewpoint based discrimination.”Civil rights attorney Harmeet Dhillon

Pan, a licensed pediatrician, is known for his vaccine advocacy and public backlash against his policies.

He previously authored bills removing personal belief exemptions (SB 277 of 2015) and and a bill tightening requirements on how doctors can issue medical exemptions (SB 276 of 2019) for vaccines so children can attend school.

Both bills were met with opposition from a variety of homeschool and medical freedom groups.

Pan recently penned a commentary in the Washington Post, blasting anti-vaccine advocates.

“This campaign to deny potentially lifesaving vaccines to those seeking them, and to poison public opinion against vaccinations, could result in countless American deaths. That is akin to domestic terrorism,” Pan wrote.

Pan has also criticized Facebook and other social media groups for allowing vaccine skeptics to post their views.

“This movement not only puts out mis- or disinformation about vaccines or lies about vaccines, which in itself can be harmful, but they are also aggressively bullying, threatening and intimidating people who are trying to share accurate information about vaccines,” Pan told the New York Times.

Pan was physically assaulted by an anti-vaccine activist in 2019, being shoved in the back on a Sacramento street. Another incident in the state Senate chambers last June saw a woman throw a cup of menstrual blood from the gallery, splashing several legislators below.

Some Vaccine Sites Shut Down After Protests

A vaccine site at Los Angeles’ Dodger Stadium temporarily shut down after the presence of protesters.

The Jan. 30 event was closed for about an hour. There were no arrests and the event was called peaceful. The group did not attempt to block entrance into the site.

Last week, a vaccine site at Golden Gate Fields in Berkeley was shut down with protesters “citing dozens of horse deaths over the past year as well as widespread COVID-19 outbreaks among workers at the track” according to ABC 7 in San Francisco.

No Protesting at Funerals

Pan’s bill refers to a similar law adopted in 2012 aimed at funeral protests.

The bill came in the wake of a series of protests by members of Westboro Baptist Church. The Kansas-based church gained notoriety by crusading against homosexuality by protesting at military funerals.

In a 2011 Supreme Court case, Snyder vs. Phelps, an 8-1 ruling overturned a lower court decision awarding a military family damages against the church. The court held that the church’s activities were protected by the First Amendment.

A state Senate analysis in 2012 said “the case turned largely on whether the speech was of a private or public concern because, while the First Amendment protections of private speech are less rigorous, speech on matters of public concern, go to the very heart of First Amendment protections.”

The California law was written to avoid First Amendment concerns by not specifying any group or viewpoint. Dhillon said Pan’s bill does target a viewpoint.

“I think that the mass vaccination of citizens, particularly where the state is talking about requiring that they try to get you enjoying certain civil rights, is 100% a matter of public interest,” Dhillon said.

Medical Freedom Group Opposes, Vaccine Group Supports

“We have not once prevented or attempted to prevent any individual from receiving a vaccination, and therefore do not see the grounds for which this bill is justified.”Olivia Mikos, V is for Vaccine

Olivia Mikos, co-founder of V is for Vaccine — a self-described California medical freedom group — opposes SB 742. She said “this bill very much appears to be targeted at our organization.”

She says her group is nothing like the Westboro Baptist Church.

“We have not once prevented or attempted to prevent any individual from receiving a vaccination, and therefore do not see the grounds for which this bill is justified,” Mikos said. “SB742 is a clear violation of the constitution and would set a dangerous precedent for other activist groups and organizations.”

Catherine Flores Martin, executive director with the nonprofit California Immunization Coalition, sees Pan’s bill as fair to both vaccine providers and protesters.

“I don’t think it’s a an overreaction. I think Dr. Pan is looking ahead in protecting the community from these kind of activities,” Flores said. “It still gives these these folks the right to protest people getting vaccinated by their own choices. But it also puts parameters on it, so everybody’s safe.”

The California Immunization Coalition has not taken a formal position, but has supported Pans’ bill in the past.

The ACLU of California said they have not taken a position on the bill. They did formally oppose the 2012 funeral protest bill.

SB 742 Starting Legislative Path

Senators voted 32-4 to bypass state constitutional rules requiring a bill to be in print for 30 days prior to being debated. It is slated to be heard in the Senate rules committee, but a date has not been set.

If passed and signed by the governor, it would take effect immediately.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Calwa Park Sitting on $7.4M in Grants. Where is New Pool, Other Upgrades?

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Teisha Zonnette Thomas

DON'T MISS

Fourth of July Celebrations Begin Saturday. Here’s Your Fresno Area Guide

DON'T MISS

Hawaiian Airlines Hit by Cyber Attack

DON'T MISS

US House Committee Subpoenas Harvard Over Tuition Costs

DON'T MISS

Convicted Felon Caught With Guns, Ammunition in Fresno Bust

DON'T MISS

Fresno Advocates Want Respect for Immigrants, Defend Miguel Arias

DON'T MISS

Crypto Industry Moves Into US Housing Market

DON'T MISS

Bill Moyers, Broadcaster and LBJ’s White House Press Secretary, Dies at 91

DON'T MISS

Trump Says a Deal Related to Trade Was Signed With China on Wednesday

UP NEXT

Why Is Usually Sleepy Fresno County Schools Superintendent Race Suddenly Hot?

UP NEXT

US Justice Department to Probe Hiring Practices at University of California

UP NEXT

Newsom and Legislature Tangle With Construction Unions Over Minimum Wage

UP NEXT

Tesla Executive, Elon Musk Confidant Leaves EV Maker, Bloomberg News Reports

UP NEXT

4 Million Acres of California Forests Could Lose Protection. What Trump’s ‘Roadless Rule’ Repeal Could Do

UP NEXT

Trump Administration Orders CA to Strip Trans Athlete of Medals

UP NEXT

Can New Star Zohran Mamdani Help Guide the Democratic Party Out of the Darkness?

UP NEXT

SoCal Vice Mayor Urges Street Gang ‘Cholos’ to Rise Up Against ICE

UP NEXT

How a Birthday Boat Ride on Lake Tahoe Turned Tragic

UP NEXT

Cuomo Concedes to Mamdani in New York City Democratic Mayoral Contest

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Hawaiian Airlines Hit by Cyber Attack

17 hours ago

US House Committee Subpoenas Harvard Over Tuition Costs

17 hours ago

Convicted Felon Caught With Guns, Ammunition in Fresno Bust

17 hours ago

Fresno Advocates Want Respect for Immigrants, Defend Miguel Arias

17 hours ago

Crypto Industry Moves Into US Housing Market

18 hours ago

Bill Moyers, Broadcaster and LBJ’s White House Press Secretary, Dies at 91

19 hours ago

Trump Says a Deal Related to Trade Was Signed With China on Wednesday

19 hours ago

Clovis Police Searching for At-Risk Missing Man Last Seen in Fresno

20 hours ago

State Department Approves $30 Million for Gaza Humanitarian Foundation

20 hours ago

Wonderdog Still Barking: Justin Wilson Thrives With Boston Red Sox

20 hours ago

Calwa Park Sitting on $7.4M in Grants. Where is New Pool, Other Upgrades?

Next month, the historic Calwa Park will host a groundbreaking on a massive, $6.6 million renovation five years in the making. However, the ...

55 minutes ago

Calwa_Empty_Pool_1280x720
55 minutes ago

Calwa Park Sitting on $7.4M in Grants. Where is New Pool, Other Upgrades?

Teisha Zonnette Thomas is Valley Crime Stoppers' Most Wanted Person of the Day for June 27, 2025. (Valley Crimes Stoppers)
1 hour ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Teisha Zonnette Thomas

2 hours ago

Fourth of July Celebrations Begin Saturday. Here’s Your Fresno Area Guide

Hawaiian Airlines airplanes on the runway at the Daniel K. Inouye International Airport in Honolulu, Hawaii, U.S. April 28, 2020.
17 hours ago

Hawaiian Airlines Hit by Cyber Attack

A view of Harvard campus on John F. Kennedy Street at Harvard University is pictured in Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S., December 7, 2023. (Reuters File)
17 hours ago

US House Committee Subpoenas Harvard Over Tuition Costs

A convicted felon was arrested in Fresno County after investigators found a rifle, handgun, and ammunition while serving a search warrant. (Fresno PD)
17 hours ago

Convicted Felon Caught With Guns, Ammunition in Fresno Bust

17 hours ago

Fresno Advocates Want Respect for Immigrants, Defend Miguel Arias

American_Flag_Bitcoin_1280x720
18 hours ago

Crypto Industry Moves Into US Housing Market

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend