Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
High Court Could Halt Move Toward Leniency for Kids Who Kill
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 4 years ago on
November 5, 2020

Share

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court this week suggested it could halt what has been a gradual move toward more leniency for children who are convicted of murder.

In cases over more than a decade, the court has concluded that children should be treated differently from adults, in part because of their lack of maturity. But the court, which has become more conservative over the last few years, could decide not to go any further.

The justices on Tuesday were hearing a case about sentencing juveniles to life without parole. The court has previously said that should be rare, and the question before the justices has to do with what courts must do before deciding to impose a life without parole sentence on a juvenile.

During arguments, which the justices heard by phone because of the coronavirus pandemic, Justice Samuel Alito suggested the court has gone too far.

“What would you say to any members of this court who are concerned that we have now gotten light years away from the original meaning of the Eighth Amendment and who are reluctant to go any further on this travel into space?” Alito asked at one point, referencing the amendment’s prohibition against “cruel and unusual” punishment.

Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Neil Gorsuch also indicated they take issue with the court’s most recent case about juvenile life sentences.

The Court Has Changed Significantly in Recent Years

The case the court was hearing Tuesday is the latest in a series of cases going back to 2005, when the court eliminated the death penalty for juveniles. Five years later, the court barred life-without-parole sentences for juveniles, except in cases where a juvenile has killed someone.

Then, in 2012, the justices in a 5-4 decision said juveniles who kill can’t automatically be sentenced to life with no chance of parole. A related decision four years later said those sentences should be reserved “for all but the rarest of juvenile offenders, those whose crimes reflect permanent incorrigibility.”

The justices are now being asked whether a juvenile has to be found to be “permanently incorrigible,” incapable of being rehabilitated, before being sentenced to life without parole.

But the court has changed significantly in recent years. More conservative justices have replaced Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose votes were key to the 2012 decision.

The specific case before the justices involves Mississippi inmate Brett Jones, who was 15 and living with his grandparents when he fatally stabbed his grandfather. The two had a fight in the home’s kitchen after Bertis Jones found his grandson’s girlfriend in his grandson’s bedroom. Brett Jones, who was using a knife to make a sandwich before the fight, stabbed his grandfather first with that knife and then, when it broke, with a different knife. He was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Jones, who is now 31, says he is not “permanently incorrigible” and should therefore be eligible for parole. Mississippi says the Eighth Amendment doesn’t require that Jones be found to be permanently incorrigible to receive a life-without-parole sentence, just that Jones’ youth when he committed his crime be considered.

The case is Jones v. Mississippi, 18-1259.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

DON'T MISS

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

DON'T MISS

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

DON'T MISS

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

DON'T MISS

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

DON'T MISS

Rams Don’t Dominate, but They’re Mastered Winning Ugly

DON'T MISS

What Goes on at Fresno County School Board Meetings? It’s Hard to Tell

DON'T MISS

Elaborate Holiday Light Displays Are Making Spirits Bright in a Big Way

DON'T MISS

Bethlehem Marks a Second Subdued Christmas During the War in Gaza

DON'T MISS

The Fastest Spacecraft Ever Heads for Its Close-Up With the Sun

UP NEXT

Illegal Immigrant Faces Murder Charges in Death of Woman Lit on Fire in NYC Subway

UP NEXT

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

UP NEXT

Cheers! Wine Clubs Are This Year’s Hottest Last Minute Gift

UP NEXT

House Ethics Committee Accuses Gaetz of ‘Regularly’ Paying for Sex With Women, Including Minor

UP NEXT

Jeffrey Sachs Warns of Looming US War With Iran

UP NEXT

A Look at the $100 Billion in Disaster Relief in the Government Spending Bill

UP NEXT

New California Voter ID Ban Puts Conservative Cities at Odds With State

UP NEXT

US Deportations Surge to Highest Level in a Decade Before Trump Takes Office

UP NEXT

White House Pushes to Find American Journalist Abducted in Syria

UP NEXT

Liberal Donors Plot to Overturn Republican House Majority in 2026

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

60 minutes ago

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

2 hours ago

Rams Don’t Dominate, but They’re Mastered Winning Ugly

2 hours ago

What Goes on at Fresno County School Board Meetings? It’s Hard to Tell

2 hours ago

Elaborate Holiday Light Displays Are Making Spirits Bright in a Big Way

2 hours ago

Bethlehem Marks a Second Subdued Christmas During the War in Gaza

2 hours ago

The Fastest Spacecraft Ever Heads for Its Close-Up With the Sun

2 hours ago

Survey: Small Businesses Are Feeling More Optimistic About the Economy After the Election

2 hours ago

Heavy Travel Day off to a Rough Start After American Airlines Briefly Grounds All Flights

3 hours ago

Global Monitor Says Famine Is Weeks Away in North Gaza. A US Diplomat Calls Warning ‘Irresponsible’

3 hours ago

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

A vehicle crashed into a home near Cain Street and Ferguson Avenue in Visalia on Tuesday morning, prompting a response from the Visalia Poli...

17 minutes ago

A vehicle crashed into a home on North Cain Street in Visalia Tuesday morning, causing minor property damage but no injuries, with the unlicensed driver cited at the scene. (Visalia PD)
17 minutes ago

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

41 minutes ago

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

53 minutes ago

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

Economist Jeffrey Sachs warns of potential US-Iran war in an interview with Tucker Carlson (pictured), citing decades of Israeli-influenced foreign policy in the Middle East. (Shutterstock)
60 minutes ago

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

2 hours ago

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

Rams
2 hours ago

Rams Don’t Dominate, but They’re Mastered Winning Ugly

2 hours ago

What Goes on at Fresno County School Board Meetings? It’s Hard to Tell

2 hours ago

Elaborate Holiday Light Displays Are Making Spirits Bright in a Big Way

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend