Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Barrett Unscathed by Tough Democratic Confirmation Probing
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 4 years ago on
October 13, 2020

Share

WASHINGTON — Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett batted back Democrats’ skeptical questions on abortion, health care and a possible disputed election in a lively Senate confirmation hearing Tuesday, insisting she would bring no personal agenda to the court but would decide cases “as they come.”

The 48-year-old appellate court judge declared her conservative views with often colloquial language, but refused many specifics. She declined to say whether she would recuse herself from any election-related cases involving President Donald Trump, who nominated her to fill the seat of the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and is pressing to have her confirmed before the the Nov. 3 election.

“Judges can’t just wake up one day and say I have an agenda — I like guns, I hate guns, I like abortion, I hate abortion — and walk in like a royal queen and impose their will on the world,” Barrett told the Senate Judiciary Committee during its second day of hearings.

“It’s not the law of Amy,” she said. “It’s the law of the American people.”

Barrett returned to a Capitol Hill mostly locked down with COVID-19 protocols, the mood quickly shifting to a more confrontational tone from opening day. She was grilled in 30-minute segments by Democrats strongly opposed to Trump’s nominee yet unable to stop her. Excited by the prospect of a conservative judge aligned with the late Antonin Scalia, Trump’s Republican allies are rushing ahead to install a 6-3 conservative court majority for years to come.

Trump has said he wants a justice seated for any disputes arising from his heated election with Democrat Joe Biden, but Barret testified she has not spoken to Trump or his team about election cases. Pressed by panel Democrats, she skipped over questions about ensuring the date of the election or preventing voter intimidation, both set in federal law, and declined to commit to recusing herself from any post-election cases without first consulting the other justices.

‘It’s Distressing Not to Get a Good Answer’

“I can’t offer an opinion on recusal without short-circuiting that entire process,” she said.

A frustrated Sen. Dianne Feinstein, the top Democrat on the panel, all but implored the nominee to be more specific about how she would handle landmark abortion cases, including Roe v. Wade and the follow-up Pennsylvania case Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which confirmed it in large part.

“It’s distressing not to get a good answer,” Feinstein told the judge.

Barrett was unmoved. “I don’t have an agenda to try to overrule Casey,” she said. “I have an agenda to stick to the rule of law and decide cases as they come.”

She later declined to characterize the Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion as a “super-precedent” that would not be overturned.

The committee chairman, Republican Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, opened the day-long session under coronavirus protocols that kept it off limits to in-person attendance by members of the public.

Republicans have been focused on defending Barrett and her Catholic faith against possible criticism concerning issues such as abortion and same-sex marriage, and Graham asked if she would be able to shelve her personal beliefs to adhere to law.

“I have done that,” she said. “I will do that still.”

He said, “I will do everything I can to make sure that you have a seat at the table. And that table is the Supreme Court.”

Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett speaks during the second day of her confirmation hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2020. (Drew Angerer/Pool via AP)

Senators Probed Her Views on Gun Ownership and Racial Equity

The Senate, led by Trump’s Republican allies, is pushing Barrett’s nomination to a quick vote before Nov. 3, and ahead of the latest challenge to the “Obamacare” Affordable Care Act, which the Supreme Court is to hear a week after the election.

“I’m not hostile to the ACA,” Barrett told the senators. She distanced herself from her past writings perceived as critical of the Obama-era health care law, saying those pieces were not addressing specific aspects of the law as she would if confirmed to the court. “I’m not here on a mission to destroy the Affordable Care Act.”

She appeared stumped when Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., tried to put her on the spot about several details of the health care law’s effects. She could not recite specifics, including that 23 million people are covered by the law or that more than 2 million young people are on their parents’ health insurance.

The Indiana judge, accompanied by her family, described herself as taking a conservative, originalist approach to the Constitution. She told the senators that while she admires Scalia, her conservative mentor for whom she once clerked, she would bring her own approach.

“You would not be getting Justice Scalia, you would be getting Justice Barrett,” she declared.

Senators probed her views on gun ownership and racial equity, at one point drawing an emotional response from the mother of seven, whose children include two adopted from Haiti, as she described watching the video of the death of George Floyd at the hands of police.

“Racism persists,” she said, adding that Floyd’s death had a “very personal” effect on her family and that she and her children wept over it. But she told Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., that “making broader diagnoses about the problem of racism is kind of beyond what I’m capable of doing as a judge.”

Protesters Rallied Outside the Senate Building, Unable to Come Inside the Hearing Room

Republicans were thrilled when she held up a blank notebook, apparently showing she had been fielding questions without aid.

Overall, Barrett’s conservative views are at odds with the late Ginsburg, the liberal icon whose seat Trump nominated her to fill.

“You would be the polar opposite of Justice Ginsburg,” said Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn.

Barring a dramatic development, Republicans appear to have the votes to confirm Barrett to a lifetime seat on the Supreme Court, and they spent their time portraying her as a thoughtful judge with impeccable credentials. She would be Trump’s third justice.

Underscoring the Republicans’ confidence, Graham set an initial committee vote on the nomination for Thursday, the last day of hearings, which would allow final approval by the panel one week later and a vote for confirmation by the full Senate on Oct. 26.

Protesters rallied outside the Senate building, unable to come inside the hearing room.

Other issues aside, Democrats are outraged that Republicans are moving so quickly, having refused to consider President Barack Obama’s nominee after Scalia’s death in February 2016, well before that year’s election.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Newsom Signs Law Aimed at Preventing CA Gas Price Spikes

DON'T MISS

Pumpkin Weighing 2,471 Pounds Wins California Contest

DON'T MISS

Vientos Hits Grand Slam as Mets Cool Dodgers’ Hot Pitching to Even up NLCS

DON'T MISS

Minnesota City Says Trump Campaign Still Owes More Than $200,000 for July Rally

DON'T MISS

6 People Accuse Diddy of Sexual Assault in New Lawsuits, Including Man Who Was 16 at Time

DON'T MISS

‘Extortion’ and ‘Bullying’ Accusations Fly: Who Should Pay for Sinking the Friant-Kern Canal?

DON'T MISS

US Deploys THAAD Missile Defense System and Troops to Israel, Sparking Debate

DON'T MISS

Christopher Reeve’s Children Share Their Father’s Complex Legacy in ‘Super/Man’

DON'T MISS

Bakersfield Prof, Community College Reach $2.4M Settlement in Free Speech Case

DON'T MISS

‘Terrifier 3’ Slashes ‘Joker’ to Take No. 1 at the Box Office, Trump Film the Apprentice Fizzles

UP NEXT

Meteorologists Face Harassment and Death Threats Amid Hurricane Disinformation

UP NEXT

Sanger Man Killed in Shooting Identified

UP NEXT

Las Vegas Says Goodbye to the Tropicana With a Flashy Casino Implosion

UP NEXT

Merced County CHP Traffic Stop Turns Into $1.2 Million Fentanyl Bust

UP NEXT

Tulare County Men Arrested in Party Shooting, Victim Hospitalized

UP NEXT

Houthis Vow Retaliation Against US for Yemen Airstrikes

UP NEXT

Clovis Daytime Burglary: 2 Suspects Arrested, 1 at Large

UP NEXT

Tulare County Teen Arrested for School Shooting Threat

UP NEXT

Chemical Smoke Spewing From a Georgia Factory Is Projected to Spread Toward Atlanta as Winds Shift

UP NEXT

Hurricane Helene’s Death Toll Passes 150 as Crews Search for Survivors

Minnesota City Says Trump Campaign Still Owes More Than $200,000 for July Rally

9 hours ago

6 People Accuse Diddy of Sexual Assault in New Lawsuits, Including Man Who Was 16 at Time

9 hours ago

‘Extortion’ and ‘Bullying’ Accusations Fly: Who Should Pay for Sinking the Friant-Kern Canal?

10 hours ago

US Deploys THAAD Missile Defense System and Troops to Israel, Sparking Debate

10 hours ago

Christopher Reeve’s Children Share Their Father’s Complex Legacy in ‘Super/Man’

11 hours ago

Bakersfield Prof, Community College Reach $2.4M Settlement in Free Speech Case

11 hours ago

‘Terrifier 3’ Slashes ‘Joker’ to Take No. 1 at the Box Office, Trump Film the Apprentice Fizzles

11 hours ago

Oregon, Penn State Move Behind No. 1 Texas. Army, Navy Both Ranked for 1st Time Since ’60

11 hours ago

I Have No Confidence in FUSD’s Measure H Projects List: Trustee Candidate Villa

12 hours ago

Body Found in Kings River Near Reedley. Fresno Sheriff Investigates.

12 hours ago

Newsom Signs Law Aimed at Preventing CA Gas Price Spikes

SACRAMENTO — California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a law Monday aimed at preventing gas prices from spiking, marking the Democrat’s late...

9 hours ago

9 hours ago

Newsom Signs Law Aimed at Preventing CA Gas Price Spikes

9 hours ago

Pumpkin Weighing 2,471 Pounds Wins California Contest

9 hours ago

Vientos Hits Grand Slam as Mets Cool Dodgers’ Hot Pitching to Even up NLCS

9 hours ago

Minnesota City Says Trump Campaign Still Owes More Than $200,000 for July Rally

9 hours ago

6 People Accuse Diddy of Sexual Assault in New Lawsuits, Including Man Who Was 16 at Time

10 hours ago

‘Extortion’ and ‘Bullying’ Accusations Fly: Who Should Pay for Sinking the Friant-Kern Canal?

10 hours ago

US Deploys THAAD Missile Defense System and Troops to Israel, Sparking Debate

11 hours ago

Christopher Reeve’s Children Share Their Father’s Complex Legacy in ‘Super/Man’

Search

Send this to a friend