Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
US Says California Order Discriminates Against Churches
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
May 20, 2020

Share

LOS ANGELES — The head of the federal Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division told Gov. Gavin Newsom Tuesday that his plan to reopen California discriminates against churches.

In a letter to the governor, Eric S. Dreiband said that despite a coronavirus pandemic “that is unprecedented in our lifetimes,” Newsom should allow some in-person worship under the current second phase of his four-part reopening plan.

In a letter to the governor, Eric S. Dreiband said that despite a coronavirus pandemic “that is unprecedented in our lifetimes,” Newsom should allow some in-person worship under the current second phase of his four-part reopening plan.

Restaurants and other secular businesses are being allowed to reopen under social distancing guidelines but not churches, which are limited to online and similar services.

That places an “unfair burden” on them that violates civil rights protections through “unequal treatment of faith communities,” the letter said.

“Simply put, there is no pandemic exception to the U.S. Constitution and its Bill of Rights,” said the letter.

A message seeking comment from the governor’s office wasn’t immediately returned.

Newsom this week further relaxed guidelines for counties to reopen more businesses closed under his March stay-at-home order that barred nonessential businesses to slow the spread of the coronavirus. He said churches and other religious institutions could start welcoming back the faithful for in-person services in the coming weeks.

A few churches have defied the ban on such services and sued to reopen, so far unsuccessfully.

Two Republican state lawmakers on Tuesday introduced a resolution to curtail the governor’s emergency powers.

Assemblymember Kevin Kiley said the extraordinary powers are for a governor “under conditions of extreme peril” and “were not meant to give a single person the ability to remake all of California law indefinitely.”

San Diego County supervisors voted Tuesday to ask the state to allow California’s second-most populous county to be a test case for more rapidly reopening businesses and allowing more gatherings and recreational options, including outdoor religious services with restrictions.

Letter to Newsom Appears to Be a Warning

Sacramento County health officials said they received approval from the state Tuesday to accelerate reopening, and the county will allow “drive-through” religious services.

States and local governments have differed on whether houses of worship must meet social distancing rules. Some states have provided a degree of exemption for religious activity.

The letter by Dreiband and four U.S. attorneys for California cites a statement issued in April by Attorney General William P. Barr that argued the government can’t impose “special restrictions” on religious activity. Barr had taken the rare step of filing papers to side with a Mississippi church suing after several parishioners were ticketed for violating a stay-at-home order by attending drive-in services.

With federal prosecutors now weighing in, the national debate over how far coronavirus gathering limits can go to restrict religion could get even louder. President Donald Trump’s reelection appeal to devout conservative voters rests in part on his vocal advocacy for religious freedom, making the issue a politically potent one for his administration to take up.

The letter to Newsom doesn’t threaten immediate legal action but appears to be a warning to the most nation’s most populous state. The prosecutors follow a line of argument used in the church lawsuits in saying that the religious groups can provide safe, socially distanced worship.

“Religion and religious worship continue to be central to the lives of millions of Americans. This is true now more than ever,” the letter said. “Religious communities have rallied to protect their communities from the spread of this disease by making services available online, in parking lots, or outdoors, by indoor services with a majority of pews empty, and in numerous other creative ways that otherwise comply with social distancing and sanitation guidelines.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Red No. 3 Ban: From Candy to Medicine, What’s Changing and When

DON'T MISS

Wall Street Banks Prepare to Offload Billions in Musk’s X Debt

DON'T MISS

State Department Freezes New Funding for Nearly All US Aid Programs Worldwide

DON'T MISS

As Schools in LA Reopen, Parents Worry About Harmful Ash From Wildfires

DON'T MISS

California Proves Renewable Energy’s Reliability in Groundbreaking Study

DON'T MISS

Trump Uses Mass Firing to Remove Independent Inspectors General at a Series of Agencies

DON'T MISS

Hamas Frees 4 Female Israeli Soldiers in Exchange for 200 Palestinian Prisoners as Ceasefire Holds

DON'T MISS

Senate Confirms Noem as Trump’s Homeland Security Secretary

DON'T MISS

Hegseth Is Quickly Sworn In as Defense Secretary After Dramatic Senate Vote

DON'T MISS

Ready to Invest in Love? Cash the Puppy Seeks Forever Home

UP NEXT

California Proves Renewable Energy’s Reliability in Groundbreaking Study

UP NEXT

Secret Service Agents Seeking Student Over Trump Video Blocked From School

UP NEXT

San Diego’s Border 2 Fire Engulfs 5,389 Acres in 24 Hours

UP NEXT

Reality TV Couple Sues Los Angeles After Losing Home in Fires

UP NEXT

Trump Targets California Water Policy, Voter ID as He Prepares to Tour LA Fire Damage

UP NEXT

Progress Is Made on a Huge Fire North of Los Angeles While New Fires Erupt in Southern California

UP NEXT

California Approves $2.5B for State Response to Los Angeles-Area Fires

UP NEXT

Trump Says California Must Change Water Policies, Threatens to Withhold Disaster Aid

UP NEXT

CNN Announces Layoffs as Part of a Further Shift to Digital Business

UP NEXT

House GOP Speaker Threatens to Saddle California Wildfire Aid With Conditions

As Schools in LA Reopen, Parents Worry About Harmful Ash From Wildfires

11 hours ago

California Proves Renewable Energy’s Reliability in Groundbreaking Study

11 hours ago

Trump Uses Mass Firing to Remove Independent Inspectors General at a Series of Agencies

13 hours ago

Hamas Frees 4 Female Israeli Soldiers in Exchange for 200 Palestinian Prisoners as Ceasefire Holds

13 hours ago

Senate Confirms Noem as Trump’s Homeland Security Secretary

13 hours ago

Hegseth Is Quickly Sworn In as Defense Secretary After Dramatic Senate Vote

13 hours ago

Ready to Invest in Love? Cash the Puppy Seeks Forever Home

14 hours ago

Trump’s Plan to Crush the Academic Left

15 hours ago

Secret Service Agents Seeking Student Over Trump Video Blocked From School

16 hours ago

Drone Delivery is Here: Zipline CEO Shares the Future of Product Transport

16 hours ago

Red No. 3 Ban: From Candy to Medicine, What’s Changing and When

Following last week’s FDA announcement banning the synthetic food dye FD&C Red No. 3, Salon has detailed which products will be af...

6 hours ago

6 hours ago

Red No. 3 Ban: From Candy to Medicine, What’s Changing and When

11 hours ago

Wall Street Banks Prepare to Offload Billions in Musk’s X Debt

11 hours ago

State Department Freezes New Funding for Nearly All US Aid Programs Worldwide

11 hours ago

As Schools in LA Reopen, Parents Worry About Harmful Ash From Wildfires

11 hours ago

California Proves Renewable Energy’s Reliability in Groundbreaking Study

13 hours ago

Trump Uses Mass Firing to Remove Independent Inspectors General at a Series of Agencies

13 hours ago

Hamas Frees 4 Female Israeli Soldiers in Exchange for 200 Palestinian Prisoners as Ceasefire Holds

13 hours ago

Senate Confirms Noem as Trump’s Homeland Security Secretary

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend