Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Should Therapists Be Mandatory Child Porn Reporters?
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
December 27, 2019

Share

SACRAMENTO — The California Supreme Court revived a long-running debate Thursday when it reinstated a lawsuit over whether psychotherapists must tell authorities when patients report they are attracted to child pornography.
Lower courts had tossed out the lawsuit by three therapists who argued that California’s mandatory reporting law violates patient confidentiality and dissuades patients from revealing that they downloaded or electronically viewed child pornography.

The proliferation of child pornography on the internet “is an urgent problem of national and international dimension,” the justices acknowledged. They said the blame falls with people who produce it and those who “perpetuate the victimization with every viewing.”
The high court split 4-3 in favor of reinstating the case and sending it back to Superior Court, where the burden will fall to the offices of the state attorney general and Los Angeles County district attorney to show whether the mandatory reporting protects children.
The dissenting justices said the therapists were unlikely to win the lawsuit.

2014 State Law at Center of Debate

The majority was careful to note that the therapists had argued that the patients in the case do not present a serious risk of sexual contact with children. Those justices also concluded that patient privacy rights only apply to disclosures during voluntary psychotherapy sessions, not to actually possessing or viewing child porn, which remains illegal and reportable.
Nor do the rights apply if the therapist “believes the patient has committed hands-on sexual abuse or poses a threat of doing so,” the justices said.
At issue is a 2014 law that modernized California’s 40-year-old mandatory reporting requirement by including downloading, streaming and electronically accessing child porn.
Six other states have laws requiring mandatory reporting of psychotherapy patients who knowingly possess or view child pornography. Another 10 states allow exceptions to psychotherapist-patient privacy for child abuse or neglect.
The California high court majority noted, however, that none had interpreted their laws to include simple possession or viewing of child porn.
The proliferation of child pornography on the internet “is an urgent problem of national and international dimension,” the justices acknowledged. They said the blame falls with people who produce it and those who “perpetuate the victimization with every viewing.”

Law Requires Therapists to Report Dangerous Patients

All three of the therapists involved in the lawsuit are experienced in treating sex addiction. One founded what the lawsuit calls the nation’s largest outpatient treatment center for sexual compulsion or addiction.
Allowing patients to admit their problems “is an essential prerequisite for patients to seek and succeed in treatment,” the suit argues.
Yet patients who are reported to police will either stop therapy because they face criminal prosecution and public outrage, or stop being candid with their therapists, the lawsuit states.
The attorney general and district attorney argued that patients’ privacy rights under the state constitution are outweighed by the law’s requirement that therapists report dangerous patients.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Authorities Seek Help Finding Relatives of Deceased Fresno Man

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Felecia Johnson

DON'T MISS

How in the World Did Fresno End Up on Trump’s Sanctuary Cities List?

DON'T MISS

X Marks the Spot: Bruised Musk Says His Young Son Punched Him

DON'T MISS

PBS Suing Trump Administration Over Defunding, Three Days After NPR Filed Similar Case

DON'T MISS

Loretta Swit, Emmy-winner Who Played Houlihan on Pioneering TV Series ‘M.A.S.H.,’ Has Died at 87

DON'T MISS

San Francisco 49ers Acquire Eagles Edge Rusher Bryce Huff, AP Source Says

DON'T MISS

California Lawmaker Won’t Be Charged After Citation for Suspicion of Impaired Driving

DON'T MISS

California School Awards Dinner at Disneyland Comes With Hefty Price Tag

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Release Video of Officer-Involved Shooting

UP NEXT

California Lawmaker Won’t Be Charged After Citation for Suspicion of Impaired Driving

UP NEXT

1 in 4 US Children Have Parents With Substance Use Disorder, Study Finds

UP NEXT

Dozens Sickened in Expanding Salmonella Outbreak Linked to Recalled Cucumbers

UP NEXT

Newsom Tussles With Local Officials Over Homelessness

UP NEXT

How Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

UP NEXT

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

UP NEXT

A Program Paying CA Jurors $100 a Day Would End Due to Newsom’s Budget Cuts

UP NEXT

‘I’m Really Scared’: Elderly and Disabled Californians Could Lose Medi-Cal Over $2,000 Limit

UP NEXT

California Avocado Growers Say Mexican Imports Have Helped Their Sales

UP NEXT

Business Insider Cuts 21% of Workforce, Memo Shows

US Defense Secretary Warns Indo-Pacific Allies of ‘Imminent’ Threat From China

4 hours ago

Hamas Responds to the US Ceasefire Proposal for Gaza While Seeking Amendments

4 hours ago

No. 15 Overall Seed UCLA Eases Past Fresno State Behind a Season-High 22 Hits

4 hours ago

Judge and Ohtani Light Up the First Inning With Historic Homers in Yankees-Dodgers Rematch

4 hours ago

Chapman Homers, Harrison Pitches Five Scoreless Innings as Giants Beat Marlins

4 hours ago

General Is a Good Boy — in English and Spanish

5 hours ago

Two Renovated Tot Lots Promise Family Fun at Roeding Park

5 hours ago

Visalia Police Hand Out 55 Citations During Motorcycle Safety Crackdown

6 hours ago

Chronic Stress Linked to Higher Dementia Risk, Experts Warn

6 hours ago

How Gentrification Is Killing the Bus: California’s Rising Rents Are Pushing Out Commuters

7 hours ago

California Gubernatorial Candidate Steve Hilton Vows to Repeal Transgender Athlete Law

If Steve Hilton becomes California governor, he says he would demand the state Legislature overturn a law allowing transgender athletes to c...

2 minutes ago

Steve Hilton, a 2026 candidate for governor, speaks at a news conference on May 31, 2025, outside Veterans Memorial Stadium in Clovis. (GV Wire/David Taub)
2 minutes ago

California Gubernatorial Candidate Steve Hilton Vows to Repeal Transgender Athlete Law

3 hours ago

Trans Athlete Competes in California Championships in Clovis Despite National Controversy

4 hours ago

Tim Walz Urges Democrats to Fight Back Harder Against ‘Bully’ Trump

4 hours ago

US Defense Secretary Warns Indo-Pacific Allies of ‘Imminent’ Threat From China

4 hours ago

Hamas Responds to the US Ceasefire Proposal for Gaza While Seeking Amendments

4 hours ago

No. 15 Overall Seed UCLA Eases Past Fresno State Behind a Season-High 22 Hits

4 hours ago

Judge and Ohtani Light Up the First Inning With Historic Homers in Yankees-Dodgers Rematch

4 hours ago

Chapman Homers, Harrison Pitches Five Scoreless Innings as Giants Beat Marlins

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend