Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: The GOP's Decline and Fall in California
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
December 1, 2019

Share

The very rapid decline of California’s Republican Party — from near-dominance in the 1980s and early 1990s to its current irrelevance — has been one of the state’s most dramatic political events.
Thirty years ago, in 1989, Republicans were on a roll in California, to wit:


Dan Walters
Opinion
—GOP candidates dominated the state’s presidential elections, including the election and re-election of Ronald Reagan.
—Republican George Deukmejian was winding up two terms as governor and would soon be succeeded by another Republican, Pete Wilson.
—Democratic registration, once close to 60%, had dropped to below 50% while the GOP’s share had climbed to nearly 40% and leading Democrats were openly worried about becoming the state’s minority party.
The roll continued into the early 1990s as Wilson won re-election in 1994, his party captured several other statewide offices and Republicans won a one-seat majority in the state Assembly.
And then the bottom dropped out. Republicans now claim fewer than 24% of the state’s registered voters, are frozen out of every statewide office, hold just 7 of the state’s 53 congressional districts, have seen Democrats capture three-quarters of the Legislature’s seats, and have lost every state presidential election since 1998.

One Major Factor Was the End of the Cold War

The dramatic turnaround was a convergence of economic, demographic and cultural factors, along with years of denial by Republican leaders.
One major factor was the end of the Cold War, which led to the near-collapse of Southern California’s defense industry, a severe recession and then to an out-migration by hundreds of thousands of aerospace workers.
Simultaneously, the region saw a wave of in-migration, primarily from Latin America, that sharply altered its cultural ambiance and political orientation.
What had been a largely conservative, pro-Republican region morphed into a more liberal, Democratic-voting region. The transition was accelerated by Proposition 187, championed by Wilson as he sought re-election in 1994, which would have denied public benefits to undocumented immigrants.
Initially, Democratic politicians aligned themselves with it. The Legislature’s Democratic majority denied driver’s licenses to undocumented immigrants, for example, and  Democratic U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein accused her 1994 Republican challenger, Michael Huffington, of being soft on illegal immigration and advocated hardening the state’s border with Mexico.
Although Proposition 187 was blocked in the courts, it awakened political activism within the state’s fast-growing Latino population and eventually, the Democratic Party benefited handsomely.

Discontent Is Fueling the Emergence of Democratic Subfactions

As California’s white population declined, it also underwent something of a cultural change. Crime, which had been a potent political issue for Republicans, declined in importance, while support for abortion rights and gay rights and environmental protection increased — especially in key suburban communities.

“After three decades of radical progressivism, California residents are tiring of one-party straitjacket rule. The hard-liberal order normalized massive power blackouts, the nation’s highest array of taxes, the forest mismanagement that fuels deadly fires, an epidemic of homelessness in major cities, eroding schools, ossified infrastructure, and soaring energy costs.” — California historian Richard Davis Hanson
GOP registration dropped, while that of Democrats remained fairly static and the ranks of “no-party-preference” voters swelled. They now outnumber Republicans and tend to back Democrats in partisan contests.
So is California now permanently a blue state, just as it once was red, or at least purple?
Writing in the National Review, conservative California historian Richard Davis Hanson sees a tinge of magenta at the end of the tunnel.
“After three decades of radical progressivism, California residents are tiring of one-party straitjacket rule,” Hanson writes. “The hard-liberal order normalized massive power blackouts, the nation’s highest array of taxes, the forest mismanagement that fuels deadly fires, an epidemic of homelessness in major cities, eroding schools, ossified infrastructure, and soaring energy costs.”
He’s right about many Californians’ concerns over these and other issues. But it’s highly unlikely that they will turn Republican in reaction — especially given the abject unpopularity of President Donald Trump.
Rather, discontent is fueling the emergence of Democratic subfactions which duel for dominance, leaving the GOP irrelevant for at least the foreseeable future.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Alum Davante Adams Returns to California, Signs with Rams

DON'T MISS

Small Earthquake Rattles Southern California

DON'T MISS

Tribes and Students Sue Trump Administration Over Firings at Native Schools

DON'T MISS

A Single-Engine Plane Crashes Near a Pennsylvania Airport. All 5 Aboard Are Taken to Hospitals.

DON'T MISS

Secret Service Shoots Armed Man Near the White House

DON'T MISS

Super Bowl Stars Josh Sweat and Milton Williams Headline a List of NFL Free Agents

DON'T MISS

ICE Arrests Palestinian Activist Who Helped Lead Columbia University Protests

DON'T MISS

Ex-Central Banker Mark Carney to Become Canada’s Next Prime Minister

DON'T MISS

Israel Cuts off Electricity Supply to Gaza, Affecting a Desalination Plant Producing Drinking Water

DON'T MISS

Tens of Thousands of Mexicans Rally With President to Celebrate US Decision to Delay Tariffs

UP NEXT

California’s List of Failed Tech Projects Just Added an Agency

UP NEXT

Capitol Rioter Ben Martin of Madera to Be Released From Federal Prison

UP NEXT

Trump Wants to Fix US Lumber Industry. Home Prices Hang in the Balance.

UP NEXT

Instead of Policing Student Use of AI, California Teachers Need to Reinvent Homework

UP NEXT

Trump Tariffs Have Valley Farmers on Edge With Billions of Dollars at Stake

UP NEXT

Justice, 40 Years Late, for Kiki Camarena

UP NEXT

Reflecting on 50 Years of Writing About California’s Politics — and Still Counting

UP NEXT

We Can Achieve Great Things

UP NEXT

Fresno EOC Tightens Belt Through Layoffs. Former Acting CEO Is Among Them.

UP NEXT

DACA Reform Gains Momentum. Valadao Says Program Fix Needed.

A Single-Engine Plane Crashes Near a Pennsylvania Airport. All 5 Aboard Are Taken to Hospitals.

8 hours ago

Secret Service Shoots Armed Man Near the White House

9 hours ago

Super Bowl Stars Josh Sweat and Milton Williams Headline a List of NFL Free Agents

9 hours ago

ICE Arrests Palestinian Activist Who Helped Lead Columbia University Protests

9 hours ago

Ex-Central Banker Mark Carney to Become Canada’s Next Prime Minister

9 hours ago

Israel Cuts off Electricity Supply to Gaza, Affecting a Desalination Plant Producing Drinking Water

9 hours ago

Tens of Thousands of Mexicans Rally With President to Celebrate US Decision to Delay Tariffs

9 hours ago

Mystery Solved? A Submerged Car From the 1950s May Belong to a Missing Oregon Family

16 hours ago

A Day of Trump-Musk Cost-Cutting Overhauls Federal Government

17 hours ago

Traveling Abroad? If You’re Paying With Dollars, Your Trip Is on Sale.

1 day ago

Fresno State Alum Davante Adams Returns to California, Signs with Rams

LOS ANGELES — Receiver Davante Adams agreed to terms on a two-year deal with the Los Angeles Rams on Sunday, bringing the three-time All-Pro...

8 hours ago

8 hours ago

Fresno State Alum Davante Adams Returns to California, Signs with Rams

The aftermath of the Palisades fire, in Malibu, Calif., Jan. 17, 2025. Residents of parts of Los Angeles County on Sunday afternoon felt a minor earthquake centered west of Malibu, Calif. and preliminary estimates showed that the quake had a magnitude of 4.1, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. (Mark Abramson/The New York Times)
8 hours ago

Small Earthquake Rattles Southern California

A "Justice for HINU” sign rests at the base of a statue on the lawn at the entrance of Haskell Indian Nations University in Lawrence, Kansas, Feb. 25, 2025. A group of Native American tribes and students is suing the Trump administration to reverse its recent firing of federal workers at Native schools that they said has severely lowered their quality of education. (Chase Castor/The New York Times)
8 hours ago

Tribes and Students Sue Trump Administration Over Firings at Native Schools

First responders work the scene after a plane crashed in the parking lot of a retirement community in Manheim Township, Pa., Sunday, March 9, 2025. (Logan Gehman/LNP/LancasterOnline via AP)
8 hours ago

A Single-Engine Plane Crashes Near a Pennsylvania Airport. All 5 Aboard Are Taken to Hospitals.

The White House in Washington, Feb. 6, 2025. The Secret Service shot a man near the White House early Sunday around midnight on Saturday after an “armed confrontation” with law enforcement officers, the agency said in a statement. (Eric Lee/The New York Times)
9 hours ago

Secret Service Shoots Armed Man Near the White House

Philadelphia Eagles linebacker Josh Sweat (19) reacts after sacking Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes during the first half of the NFL Super Bowl 59 football game, Sunday, Feb. 9, 2025, in New Orleans. (AP/Matt Slocum)
9 hours ago

Super Bowl Stars Josh Sweat and Milton Williams Headline a List of NFL Free Agents

Student negotiator Mahmoud Khalil is on the Columbia University campus in New York at a pro-Palestinian protest encampment on April 29, 2024. (AP File)
9 hours ago

ICE Arrests Palestinian Activist Who Helped Lead Columbia University Protests

Liberal Party of Canada leadership candidate Mark Carney delivers a speech as he's introduced during the Liberal leadership announcement in Ottawa, Ontario, Sunday, March 9, 2025. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press via AP)
9 hours ago

Ex-Central Banker Mark Carney to Become Canada’s Next Prime Minister

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend