The Fresno Unified School Board continues to grapple with whether to use project labor agreements for upcoming school construction projects such as the new southeast elementary school.

Indecision about the agreements, which are supported by labor unions but opposed by general contractors and business owners, has pushed the school’s opening back a year.

Listen to this article:


The $44 million Juan Felipe Herrera Elementary now is scheduled to open in August 2022, chief of staff David Chavez told board members Wednesday afternoon at a PLA workshop.

Chief operations officer Karin Temple had cautioned the board in September that if it delayed advertising for bids on the project to consider a project labor agreement, the opening likely would be delayed a year.

Learning The Pros and Cons of PLAs

Attorney Phil Henderson of Orbach Huff Suarez + Henderson, which negotiates project labor agreements, was joined by Chuck Riojas of the Fresno, Madera, Tulare, Kings Building and Construction Trades Council and Nicole Goehring of Associated Builders and Contractors in a discussion of the pros and cons of PLAs.

The city of Fresno has a PLA for its airport expansion.

“If we’re going to be submitting for matching money for our projects, we need to position ourselves as best as we can to get that matching money.”Trustee Carol Mills

Conflicting studies have raised questions about whether PLAs contribute to higher costs and limit opportunities for apprentice workers. The trustees expressed interest in having career technology pathways incorporated in any PLA to benefit high schoolers preparing for construction trades careers.

One big advantage to having a PLA: Fresno Unified’s upcoming projects could jump closer to the head of the line to get state school construction money under the language in Proposition 13, the $15 billion proposition on the March ballot, chief financial officer Ruthie Quinto told the board.

Priority Goes to PLA Projects

Photo of Carol Mills

Carol Mills

Getting the biggest bang for the district’s buck is key, trustee Carol Mills said. “Part of our obligation is to maximize the funding that’s available for our contracts,” she said. “We didn’t create the state provisions, but we are going to have to follow them. If we’re going to be submitting for matching money for our projects, we need to position ourselves as best as we can to get that matching money.

“Because every school district in the state is going to be looking for that matching money, and there’s going to be more requests than there is money available.”

Mills and other trustees expressed their support for continuing to consider a PLA for Herrera School, and possibly other future projects.

Support Waning for Bond Measure

But Goehring noted that support for Proposition 13, based on the latest Public Policy Institute of California survey, appears to be slipping and is polling at less than 50% approval.

“I’m not suggesting that a PLA had anything to do with that,” she said. “But if there are contractors in the community that you would want to be supportive of your bond, you definitely would want to keep the opportunities open for everyone. So I would encourage you to keep fair and open competition in your district.”

Claudia Cazares

That sparked an angry comment at the close of the workshop from board president Claudia Casares. Compared to the vast amounts of construction bids that the district has awarded to the private sector, Herrera School is a “tiny little (PLA) project that we may or may not do, (that) deserves our support.

“I would like to think that the history of all the projects that we’ve had in this district, and the partnerships we’ve had with our private entities in this district, will be more than enough to have their support in our future bond.”

The trustees voted later Wednesday for a resolution to put a $325 million bond for school facilities on the March 3 ballot.

4 Responses

  1. Karl

    Using unions helps maintain a living wage for residents of the valley. Trade unions are made up of proud workers who build with pride and knowledge. The results are schools that last, reduce maintenance costs, and provide CTE students with great jobs when they graduate from FUSD schools.

    • Nacho

      Karl, perhaps back in the day, but the reality now is that Harris Construction owns FUSD, does no work of their own, subs everything, and treats the sub like crap, workers and companies that are treated poorly do shoddy work Meanwhile after harris makes the subs eat the change orders harris back bills the district. It’s all a scam

  2. matt

    Can the Unions bid on the project if it is not a Project Labor Agreement? Yes. There is your answer.

  3. John

    PLAs have a history of projects coming in way over budget. PLAs also deter non-union contractors from bidding on those projects because of their restrictive policies.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

We've got issues, and we're willing to share
(but only if you want them in your inbox).