Judge Temporarily Blocks Law Aimed at Trump's Tax Returns
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
October 2, 2019
Share
SACRAMENTO — A U.S. judge on Tuesday temporarily blocked a California law aimed at forcing President Donald Trump to release his personal income tax returns in order to appear on the 2020 primary ballot.
“It is not the job of the courts, however, to decide whether a tax return disclosure requirement is good policy or makes political sense. Instead, it is the court’s job to make sure the Constitution wins.” — U.S. District Judge Morrison C. England Jr.
U.S. District Judge Morrison C. England Jr. issued a written opinion saying the law likely violates the U.S. Constitution. He had announced last month he planned to block the law.The law requires candidates for president or governor to file copies of their personal income tax returns dating back five years with the California secretary of state’s office. If they refuse, they could not appear on the state’s primary ballot. The law would not have applied to general elections.
Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom said he signed the law because California has a “special responsibility” to hold candidates to high ethical standards. The Trump campaign sued, arguing the law seeks to add another qualification for running for president, something state governments don’t have the authority to do.
In his 24-page ruling, Morrison wrote the state’s concerns are “both legitimate and understandable,” highlighting that candidates have offered “unnecessary and irrelevant excuses for shielding the public from such information.”
“It is not the job of the courts, however, to decide whether a tax return disclosure requirement is good policy or makes political sense,” wrote Morrison, who was appointed by former Republican President George W. Bush. “Instead, it is the court’s job to make sure the Constitution wins.”
Morrison Said the Law Violates Trump’s First Amendment Right
California Secretary of State Alex Padilla said he will appeal the ruling, asserting “this law is fundamental to preserving and protecting American democracy.”
“This decision rightfully stops the Democrats’ petty politics and their efforts to disenfranchise millions of California voters and suppress Republican voter turnout.” — California Republican Party chairwoman Jessica Millan Patterson
Morrison said the law violates Trump’s First Amendment right of associating with voters who share his political beliefs. He also noted the California Legislature is controlled by Democrats, who passed a law targeting a Republican president.“The dangerous precedent set by this act, allowing the controlling party in any state’s legislature to add substantive requirements as a precondition to qualifying for the state’s presidential primary ballot, should concern all candidates alike,” he wrote.
California Republican Party chairwoman Jessica Millan Patterson called the ruling a victory for voters and their ability to vote for the candidate of their choice.
“This decision rightfully stops the Democrats’ petty politics and their efforts to disenfranchise millions of California voters and suppress Republican voter turnout,” Patterson said in a news release.
Democratic Sen. Mike McGuire, the author of the law, said “the judge got it wrong.”
“Some of the brightest constitutional minds in the nation have been very clear that this law will withstand a constitutional test,” he said.
The deadline to file tax returns for California’s March 3 presidential primary would be Nov. 26.
Caitlin Clark Is Set to Sign a New Nike Deal Valued at $28 Million Over 8 Years, Reports Say
Sports /
2 hours ago
A Far-Right German EU Lawmaker’s Aide Is Arrested on Suspicion of Spying for China
World /
3 hours ago
Wall Street Rallies and Adds to Its Hot Start to the Week
Economy /
3 hours ago
Newsom Criticizes Local Response to Homelessness. He Should Look in the Mirror.
Opinion /
4 hours ago
Google Fires More Workers Who Protested Its Deal With Israel
Tech /
4 hours ago
Winn Sharp Again, Conforto Homers as Giants Clip Mets
Sports /
4 hours ago
CA Lawmakers Reject Bill Cracking Down on Utilities Spending Customers’ Money
Politics /
4 hours ago
Latest
Videos
Politics /
1 hour ago
Tabloid Publisher Says He Pledged to Be Trump Campaign’s ‘Eyes and Ears’ During 2016 Race
Business /
1 hour ago
General Motors Reports Strong First-Quarter Profits as Prices Help Offset Small US Sales Dip
Sports /
2 hours ago
Caitlin Clark Is Set to Sign a New Nike Deal Valued at $28 Million Over 8 Years, Reports Say
World /
3 hours ago
A Far-Right German EU Lawmaker’s Aide Is Arrested on Suspicion of Spying for China
Economy /
3 hours ago