Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California’s Pension Debt Cannot Be Ignored
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 6 years ago on
September 25, 2019

Share

A decade ago, at Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s request, I supervised a graduate student team that performed a comprehensive analysis of public pensions in California.
The goal was to calculate California’s pension debt, the difference between assets and liabilities.


Joe Nation
Special to CalMatters

Opinion
The team’s conclusions: the unfunded liability was over $500 billion—seven times the number officially reported. That was in 2008.
The student team recommended several actions to lawmakers and pension managers. Almost all were ignored.
Over time, it has become clear that the students’ analysis was spot on. Public pension debt  doubled to more than $1.052 trillion in 2017, the last year of complete data.
Based on recently-reported public pension assets and estimated liabilities, that figure is now more than $1.109 trillion, an increase of $56 billion. That translates into $81,300 of pension debt per California household.
There are arguments about whether the students use of what economists would call a “market basis” to measure pension debt is too conservative. In short, a market basis uses accepted economic and finance principles to estimate liabilities.
But even figures reported by California’s pension systems on a more optimist “actuarial” basis produces the same trendline. Debt per household today is almost $22,800, compared with less than $8,000 when students submitted their work in 2010.

No One Knows if or When a Recession Will Hit

What is remarkable about this trend is that pension debt has continued to climb even as the stock market has soared.
The S&P 500 index, about 800 in early 2010, is now over 3,000. And yet over the last decade, public pension funded ratios, measured by assets divided by liabilities, have moved up only slightly.
The funded ratio for California Public Employees’ Retirement System’s Public Employees’ Retirement Fund was 60.8% in 2009. Now, it’s an estimated 72.6%.
This, unfortunately, isn’t the most alarming news.
No one knows if or when a recession will hit the global or U.S. economies, but we are due.  Another Great Recession-like downturn in the U.S. stock market could push California’s public pension system assets from $918 billion today to just over $700 billion.
The average funded ratio for all public pensions in California would fall from 75% to 56.4% on an actuarial basis, meaning pensions would have just over 50 cents for every dollar in obligations.
Remember that this is the optimistic scenario.
The average funded ratio on a market basis would fall from 45.7% today to 34.4%, or 34 cents on every dollar owed.
Pension debt would climb from $311 billion today to $543 billion on an actuarial basis. On a market basis, pension debt would climb to $1.341 trillion, or nearly $100,000 per household.

Ignoring This Problem Won’t Make It Go Away

A repeat of the Great Recession may be unlikely, but then again, we didn’t expect a sharp decline in 2008-2009.
Even a mini-recession in which pension systems’ assets fall by one-half Great Recession levels would be a horrible development. Schools and municipal governments, already cutting programs and services despite strong revenues, would be forced to cut even further.

Taxpayers would be asked to chip in more.  And public employees, especially those in areas where the economy remains weak, would face layoffs, salary cuts, and in some scenarios, reductions in retirement benefits.  
Taxpayers would be asked to chip in more.  And public employees, especially those in areas where the economy remains weak, would face layoffs, salary cuts, and in some scenarios, reductions in retirement benefits.
If there is any doubt about these impacts, ask Stockton employees who lost retiree health care, Loyalton employees who saw their pensions cut, or Detroit workers who lost both retirement pay and health benefits as the city emerged from bankruptcy.
One thing is certain: Ignoring this problem won’t make it go away.
Public pension debt will continue to grow.  K-12 classroom funds and municipal services will continue to be cut. Legislative attempts at reform barely made a dent in the problem overall.
The question isn’t really the size of California’s pension debt over the next 10 years. It is whether California’s leaders have the courage today to acknowledge and implement the aggressive and comprehensive reforms that are so clearly required.
About the Author 
Joe Nation is a professor of the Practice of Public Policy at Stanford University and the project director for PensionTracker at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, joenation@stanford.edu. He wrote this commentary for CalMatters, a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s Capitol works and why it matters.
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Investors React to US Attack on Iran Nuclear Sites

DON'T MISS

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

DON'T MISS

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

DON'T MISS

Trump Says US Forces Bombed Iran Nuclear Sites, Says ‘Fordow Is Gone’

DON'T MISS

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

DON'T MISS

Pakistan to Nominate Trump for Nobel Peace Prize

DON'T MISS

Vance, in Los Angeles, Says Troops Need to Stay, Blasts Newsom Over Immigration

DON'T MISS

Nuclear Diplomacy Stuck, Israel Says It Killed Top Iran Commander

DON'T MISS

Mahmoud Khalil Vows to Resume Pro-Palestinian Activism After Release From US Jail

DON'T MISS

Trump Says He Wants to Fund More Trade Schools. Just Not These.

UP NEXT

Groceries Are Now a Luxury. So Is Breathing.

UP NEXT

Fresno Area’s Newest College Grads Boast Nearly $24 Billion in Earning Power

UP NEXT

California Politicians Agree on School Money, but Poor Test Scores Need Attention

UP NEXT

Florida Congresswoman to Revive Bipartisan Immigration Bill. Valley Leaders Join the Push

UP NEXT

Sen. Alex Padilla: This Is How an Administration Acts When It’s Afraid

UP NEXT

Bay Area Transit Systems Want More Money. But Their Payrolls Soared as Ridership Declined

UP NEXT

Whatever Happened to the New Northwest Fresno Costco?

UP NEXT

History Suggests the GOP Will Pay a Political Price for Its Immigration Tactics in California

UP NEXT

Physician Warns Fresno County Supervisors About Jail’s Medical Provider, Private Equity Co.

UP NEXT

Only Nonviolence Will Beat Trump

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

2 hours ago

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

2 hours ago

Trump Says US Forces Bombed Iran Nuclear Sites, Says ‘Fordow Is Gone’

2 hours ago

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

7 hours ago

Pakistan to Nominate Trump for Nobel Peace Prize

7 hours ago

Vance, in Los Angeles, Says Troops Need to Stay, Blasts Newsom Over Immigration

7 hours ago

Nuclear Diplomacy Stuck, Israel Says It Killed Top Iran Commander

7 hours ago

Mahmoud Khalil Vows to Resume Pro-Palestinian Activism After Release From US Jail

7 hours ago

Trump Says He Wants to Fund More Trade Schools. Just Not These.

7 hours ago

Two Days of Terror: How the Minnesota Shooter Evaded Police and Got Caught

7 hours ago

Congress Members Split Over US Attack on Iran

WASHINGTON  – Republican and Democratic members of the U.S. Congress delivered swift reactions to U.S. bombings of Iranian nuclear fac...

22 minutes ago

The U.S. Capitol building is seen in Washington, U.S., December 1, 2023. (Reuters File)
22 minutes ago

Congress Members Split Over US Attack on Iran

Emergency personnel work at an impact site following Iran's missile strike on Israel, amid the Iran-Israel conflict, in Haifa, Israel, June 20, 2025. (Reuters File)
26 minutes ago

Investors Brace for Oil Price Spike, Rush to Havens After US Bombs Iran Nuclear Sites

President Donald Trump gestures next to a new flagpole with the U.S. flag after disembarking Marine One upon arrival at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., June 21, 2025. (Reuters/Kevin Mohatt)
2 hours ago

Investors React to US Attack on Iran Nuclear Sites

A wildfire dubbed the Colvin Fire broke out Saturday near Woodlake in Tulare County, burning 46 acres with 0% containment and threatening two structures, according to CalFire. (CalFire)
2 hours ago

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

2 hours ago

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

A B-2 Spirit stealth bomber takes off at Whiteman Air Force Base, Missouri, April 30, 2025. U.S. Air Force/Staff Sgt. Joshua Hastings/Handout via REUTERS
2 hours ago

Trump Says US Forces Bombed Iran Nuclear Sites, Says ‘Fordow Is Gone’

Oct 24, 2024; Los Angeles, CA, USA; General view of the centerfield plaza during media prior to game one of the World Series between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the New York Yankees at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images/File Photo
7 hours ago

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

President Donald Trump talks to reporters upon his arrival at Morristown Municipal Airport in Morristown, New Jersey, U.S., June 20, 2025. (Reuters File)
7 hours ago

Pakistan to Nominate Trump for Nobel Peace Prize

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend