Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Deadly Force Law Finally and Rightfully Changed
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
August 21, 2019

Share

The record of the 2019 legislative session – Gov. Gavin Newsom’s first – is still a work in progress, but his signature on Assembly Bill 392 this week makes it a success, no matter what else happens.


Dan Walters
CALmatters

Opinion
The measure, creating a tighter standard for use of deadly force by police, was long overdue. Officers almost never faced legal consequences for killing suspects.
An 1872-vintage state law, still on the books, made virtually any use of deadly force legal. Later U.S. Supreme Court rulings declared such blanket exemptions “constitutionally unreasonable,” but if an officer had a reasonable rationale, deadly force was acceptable.
Under the latter legal test, prosecutors have been hesitant to charge officers and civil rights advocates pushed to change it after a couple of particularly egregious police killings of black men in Sacramento, both within a few miles of the state Capitol.
Two Sacramento police officers fired 20 shots at the shadowy figure of 22-year-old Stephon Clark in the backyard of his grandmother’s home on March 18, 2018, hitting him seven times.
Clark was being chased because of reports he was breaking windows in the neighborhood and the two cops apparently mistook a cellphone in Clark’s hand for a gun in the dark and unleashed the barrage of pistol fire.

Joseph Mann Was Shot 14 Times by Two Sacramento Officers

In some ways, however, the death of 51-year-old Joseph Mann, a mentally ill and homeless man, nearly two years earlier, was even less justified because it occurred in broad daylight and Mann, carrying a knife and acting erratically, did not pose any immediate threat.
Mann was shot 14 times by two Sacramento officers who, it was revealed later, had tried to run down Mann with their patrol car. When he dodged out of the way, they radioed, “We’ll get him. We’ll get him,” then stepped from their car and almost immediately began shooting from a distance of at least 25 feet.
Assemblywoman Shirley Weber, a black woman raised in the South who had long championed civil rights issues, assembled a powerful political coalition to confront police unions which had long resisted changing deadly force law. The families of police shooting victims added their voices in public appeals for change.
Weber, a San Diego Democrat, enlisted Newsom and legislative leaders in the cause and intense negotiations finally resulted in a version of AB 392 that the police unions would not actively oppose.
Basically, it changes the legal rationale for deadly force from a “reasonable” fear to, as a legislative analysis puts it, “only when necessary in defense of human life” as determined by “the particular circumstances of each case.”

Legislation ‘Basically Changes the Culture of Policing in California’

Thus it moves the law closer to the standard applied to civilians. There’s little doubt that had civilians shot Clark and Mann under the same circumstances, they would have been prosecuted for homicide.

During Monday’s signing ceremony, Assemblywoman Shirley Weber said the legislation “basically changes the culture of policing in California” and “will make everyone in California safer.”
How the law is applied is still uncertain. Eventually, the courts will set the parameters of “necessary in defense of human life” just as they established the “reasonable” rationale.
During Monday’s signing ceremony, Weber said the legislation “basically changes the culture of policing in California” and “will make everyone in California safer.”
Pointedly, Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg was on hand and said Clark’s shooting death was “an unacceptable tragedy” and “one more is one more too many.”
AB 392 passed the Legislature in early July, but Newsom’s signature was delayed until Aug. 19, a date with special significance – the 400th anniversary of the first African slaves being brought to North America.
Symbolism? Yes, but in this case quite justified.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

Fight Over Phonics: Will CA Require the ‘Science of Reading’ in K-12 Schools?

DON'T MISS

Russia Says Trump’s Threats Against Iran Could Trigger ‘Global Catastrophe’

DON'T MISS

Get Off the Phone! Fresno Police Target Distracted Driving

DON'T MISS

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

DON'T MISS

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

DON'T MISS

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

DON'T MISS

Dodgers’ Freddie Freeman Lands on Injured List Following Fall in His Shower at Home

DON'T MISS

How Trump’s Latest Tariffs Could Affect Your Wallet

DON'T MISS

Curry Scores 37 Points and Warriors Beat Lakers in a Potential First-Round Playoff Preview

DON'T MISS

LA Fires Death Toll Rises to 30 After Remains Are Found

UP NEXT

As Dem Candidates for Governor Increase, They Wait for Harris to Decide

UP NEXT

Fresno County Head-On Crash Sends Two to the Hospital

UP NEXT

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

UP NEXT

Fresno County Sheriff’s Pilot Takes His Last Flight as He Retires After 31 Years of Service

UP NEXT

State Center Trustees Vote for Special Interest Giveaway Over Students: Opinion

UP NEXT

Voice of America Wins in Court, for Now, as Judge Blocks Trump Administration From Firing Staff

UP NEXT

Watch: City Demolishes Historic Chinatown Building to Make Way for Housing

UP NEXT

I Will Force Votes on Blocking Arms Sales to Israel: Sen. Bernie Sanders

UP NEXT

What Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’ Tariffs Could Mean for Americans: Fareed Zakaria

UP NEXT

A Look at Fresno City College’s New $87 Million Science Building

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

44 minutes ago

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

50 minutes ago

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

54 minutes ago

Dodgers’ Freddie Freeman Lands on Injured List Following Fall in His Shower at Home

60 minutes ago

How Trump’s Latest Tariffs Could Affect Your Wallet

1 hour ago

Curry Scores 37 Points and Warriors Beat Lakers in a Potential First-Round Playoff Preview

1 hour ago

LA Fires Death Toll Rises to 30 After Remains Are Found

1 hour ago

US Added 228,000 Jobs in March as Economy Showed Strength in Buildup to Trump Trade Wars

1 hour ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Samantha Jenny Audelo

2 hours ago

Russell Brand Charged With Rape, Sexual Assault

2 hours ago

Fight Over Phonics: Will CA Require the ‘Science of Reading’ in K-12 Schools?

This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters. Can you spell deja vu? By Carolyn Jones CalMatters The ...

38 seconds ago

38 seconds ago

Fight Over Phonics: Will CA Require the ‘Science of Reading’ in K-12 Schools?

40 minutes ago

Russia Says Trump’s Threats Against Iran Could Trigger ‘Global Catastrophe’

The Fresno Police Department will conduct an enforcement operation on April 7, 2025, to target drivers violating the hands-free cell phone law, aiming to reduce distracted driving. (Shutterstock)
43 minutes ago

Get Off the Phone! Fresno Police Target Distracted Driving

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell speaks during a news conference after the Federal Open Market Committee meeting, Wednesday, March 19, 2025, at the Federal Reserve in Washington. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
44 minutes ago

Federal Reserve Chief Says Trump Tariffs Likely to Raise Inflation and Slow US Economic Growth

50 minutes ago

The NBA’s Playoff Chase Enters Its Final Days. Here’s a Look at What’s Happening

54 minutes ago

USC’s JuJu Watkins Named AP Player of the Year After Historic Sophomore Season

60 minutes ago

Dodgers’ Freddie Freeman Lands on Injured List Following Fall in His Shower at Home

A hand-embroidery dress fabric made in India, costing a couple hundred dollars per yard, is sold at the Francia Textiles fabric store in the Fashion District in Los Angeles on Thursday, April 3, 2025. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes)
1 hour ago

How Trump’s Latest Tariffs Could Affect Your Wallet

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend