Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Trump Fires IRS Commissioner, Bessent Named Acting Head

1 day ago

University of California Reviews US Government’s $1 Billion UCLA Settlement Offer

2 days ago

Kounalakis Exits California Governor’s Race, Will Run for State Treasurer

2 days ago

National Weather Service to Restore Hundreds of Jobs Cut Under Trump

2 days ago

Wall Street Gains as Trump’s Interim Fed Choice Stokes Dovish Bets

2 days ago

US, Russia Plan Truce Deal That Would Cement Putin’s Gains in Ukraine, Bloomberg Reports

2 days ago

Visalia Roadwork to Close Giddings Street Through December

2 days ago

Trump Asks US Supreme Court to Lift Limits on Immigration Raids

2 days ago
Opinion: Don’t Dumb Down Our Smart Speakers
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 6 years ago on
May 30, 2019

Share

Editor’s note: This commentary is a response to “Legislation seeks to outsmart ‘smart’ speakers,” May 23, 2019.

Voice recognition systems have streamlined our daily activities, from turning on the lights to important reminders about taking medications.  We have only scratched the surface of what is possible with voice recognition systems. But Assembly Bill 1395 by Assemblyman Jordan Cunningham, a Republican from San Luis Obispo, could halt this technology’s advancement.

Opinion

Courtney Jensen
Special to CALmatters

AB 1395 would create barriers to the type of learning that voice recognition technology depends on to unleash its full potential for consumers, and it would impose duplicative security provisions that would do nothing to enhance consumer privacy or device security.

Voice recognition systems rely on machine learning to adapt to users’ speech patterns and vocabulary, and are informed by the way users talk to the device. Our speech is nuanced and dynamic.

Users’ age, whether they are a native or non-native speaker of the language, and whether they have a speech impairment also impacts the voice recognition system’s learning. These variables make training critical to the success of voice recognition systems.

As consumers use devices, companies retain records so real-world data is available to train and improve the technology for the benefit of the consumer. This training has allowed voice recognition systems to become more useful. For example, real world data for training is critical for device learning in order to minimize false wakes, which is when a home speaker is activated unintentionally.

Enhancing Consumers’ Confidence in Devices They Use

Assemblyman Cunningham voiced concerns over devices being activated unintentionally. But his legislation would exacerbate this issue by restricting a company’s ability to avoid false wakes by limiting a manufacturer’s capacity to use stored voice recordings and transcripts to improve the product features.

A company cannot adequately fix bugs if recordings and transcripts can only be retained for the brief time a device needs the information to complete a requested command.

Voice recognition devices are designed with layers of security, privacy protections, and controls to minimize and protect the data collected. California is already a leader on device security.

Under the California Consumer Privacy Act approved last year, Californians can access and delete any voice recordings associated with their devices.  This safeguard gives consumers control over their data. AB 1395 would add layers of unnecessary, confusing, and unworkable mandates that would conflict with the Consumer Privacy Act.

Voice recognition devices are designed with layers of security, privacy protections, and controls to minimize and protect the data collected. California is already a leader on device security.

Legislation to enhance consumers’ confidence in the devices they use is something we can all support. But AB 1395 would do nothing to advance that goal.

Instead, it will make “smart” devices not-so-smart and impact the accessibility of these devices for all consumers, as well as conflict with existing privacy laws.  California has always successfully championed consumers and technology. Legislators should reject AB 1395 because it does neither.

Courtney Jensen is executive director for California and the Southwest of TechNet, cjensen@technet.org. She wrote this commentary for CALmatters, a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s Capitol works and why it matters.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

How a CIA Hit on Al Qaeda Ensnared a US Citizen in Afghanistan

DON'T MISS

California Escalates Texas Redistricting Fight With November Ballot Measure

DON'T MISS

White House to Hold Press Conference on Crime in DC on Monday, Trump Says

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Recommends Vaccination as Whooping Cough Cases Rise

DON'T MISS

How Long Before the Navy Moves Crashed Jet Out of Buddy Mendes’ Cotton Field?

DON'T MISS

Sierra Unified Unveils Renovated Library in First Phase of Campus Modernization

DON'T MISS

Madera County’s Former Sheriff-Turned-Top Exec Jay Varney Ready to Retire

DON'T MISS

California Antisemitism Bill Sparks Clash Between Jewish Groups and Educators

DON'T MISS

Rivian Opens EV Dealership, Service Center in Fresno. First for Central Valley

DON'T MISS

Trump Fires IRS Commissioner, Bessent Named Acting Head

UP NEXT

Democracy Be Damned: Texas and California Plot Dueling Gerrymanders

UP NEXT

The America We Knew Is Rapidly Slipping Away

UP NEXT

With Kamala Harris Out, Who Will Emerge as Frontrunner for California Governor?

UP NEXT

Why Building More Homes Near Transit Will Transform Lives Across California

UP NEXT

Israel Must Open Its Eyes. Defeating Hamas Doesn’t Require Starving a Single Child

UP NEXT

‘South Park’ Skewers a New Kind of Sanctimony and Trump

UP NEXT

Corruption Scandal Puts Mexico’s President on Defense Against Trump

UP NEXT

The Trump Presidency Takes a Better Turn

UP NEXT

How Netanyahu Keeps Playing Trump for a Fool in Gaza

UP NEXT

How Israel’s War With Hamas Became Unjust

Tulare County Recommends Vaccination as Whooping Cough Cases Rise

17 hours ago

How Long Before the Navy Moves Crashed Jet Out of Buddy Mendes’ Cotton Field?

17 hours ago

Sierra Unified Unveils Renovated Library in First Phase of Campus Modernization

17 hours ago

Madera County’s Former Sheriff-Turned-Top Exec Jay Varney Ready to Retire

1 day ago

California Antisemitism Bill Sparks Clash Between Jewish Groups and Educators

1 day ago

Rivian Opens EV Dealership, Service Center in Fresno. First for Central Valley

1 day ago

Trump Fires IRS Commissioner, Bessent Named Acting Head

1 day ago

University of California Reviews US Government’s $1 Billion UCLA Settlement Offer

2 days ago

Trump Officials Will Not Face Contempt Over Venezuela Deportations, Appeals Court Rules

2 days ago

Kounalakis Exits California Governor’s Race, Will Run for State Treasurer

2 days ago

How a CIA Hit on Al Qaeda Ensnared a US Citizen in Afghanistan

As a crowd looked on, uniformed Taliban surrounded the Toyota Landcruiser in which Mahmood Habibi, a naturalized U.S. citizen, sat. Other Ta...

14 hours ago

Ahmad Habibi and his younger brother Mahmood Habibi pose for the camera, Canada, 2014. Mahmood Habibi was taken hostage by the Taliban in Afghanistan on August 10, 2022, the U.S. government says. Ahmad Shah Habibi/Handout via REUTERS
14 hours ago

How a CIA Hit on Al Qaeda Ensnared a US Citizen in Afghanistan

California Governor Gavin Newsom speaks at a press conference, accompanied by members of the Texas Democratic legislators, at the governor’s mansion in Sacramento, California, U.S., August 8, 2025. REUTERS/Carlos Barria
15 hours ago

California Escalates Texas Redistricting Fight With November Ballot Measure

President Donald Trump takes questions from reporters at the White House in Washington, July 30, 2025. The conversation between President Trump and former Gov. Andrew Cuomo came at a time when Cuomo was publicly pushing Mayor Eric Adams and other rivals to drop out of the race in hopes of consolidating the support of voters who oppose the frontrunner, Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani. (Eric Lee/The New York Times)
15 hours ago

White House to Hold Press Conference on Crime in DC on Monday, Trump Says

Tulare County experiencing an increase of whooping cough cases
17 hours ago

Tulare County Recommends Vaccination as Whooping Cough Cases Rise

17 hours ago

How Long Before the Navy Moves Crashed Jet Out of Buddy Mendes’ Cotton Field?

Sierra Unified Library Renovations
17 hours ago

Sierra Unified Unveils Renovated Library in First Phase of Campus Modernization

Jim Varney retiring from madera County
1 day ago

Madera County’s Former Sheriff-Turned-Top Exec Jay Varney Ready to Retire

1 day ago

California Antisemitism Bill Sparks Clash Between Jewish Groups and Educators

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend